|
|
|
|
Vol. 11, Issue 2, 721-734, February 2000
and
*Departments of Cell Biology and Biochemistry, *Lipid and
Lipoprotein Research Group, and
Department of Medicine,
University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta T6G 2S2, Canada
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Apolipoprotein B (apoB) is an essential component of chylomicrons, very low density lipoproteins, and low density lipoproteins. ApoB is a palmitoylated protein. To investigate the role of palmitoylation in lipoprotein function, a palmitoylation site was mapped to Cys-1085 and removed by mutagenesis. Secreted lipoprotein particles formed by nonpalmitoylated apoB were smaller and denser and failed to assemble a proper hydrophobic core. Indeed, the relative concentrations of nonpolar lipids were three to four times lower in lipoprotein particles containing mutant apoB compared with those containing wild-type apoB, whereas levels of polar lipids isolated from wild-type or mutant apoB lipoprotein particles appeared identical. Palmitoylation localized apoB to large vesicular structures corresponding to a subcompartment of the endoplasmic reticulum, where addition of neutral lipids was postulated to occur. In contrast, nonpalmitoylated apoB was concentrated in a dense perinuclear area corresponding to the Golgi compartment. The involvement of palmitoylation as a structural requirement for proper assembly of the hydrophobic core of the lipoprotein particle and its intracellular sorting represent novel roles for this posttranslational modification.
| |
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Apolipoprotein B (apoB) is an essential component of chylomicrons,
very low density lipoproteins (VLDL), and low density lipoproteins (Havel and Kane, 1995
; Davis and Vance, 1996
). These plasma lipoprotein particles are important agents responsible for the transport of hydrophobic, water-insoluble lipids in the bloodstream. Interestingly, the plasma concentrations of low density lipoproteins, intermediate density lipoproteins, and VLDL correlate positively with the propensity to develop atherosclerosis (Havel and Kane, 1995
). ApoB is one of the
largest known single polypeptide chains (4536 amino acids or 512 kDa).
In humans, there are two natural forms of apoB found in lipoprotein
particles: apoB-100 is synthesized by the liver, whereas apoB-48 is
synthesized by the intestine through a process of RNA editing
(Boström et al., 1990
; Innerarity et al.,
1996
) (note that apoB-48 represents the N-terminal 48% of apoB). In rats, both forms of apoB are synthesized in the liver and the intestine. Likewise, rat hepatoma cells express both apoB-48 and apoB-100.
In some ways, the biosynthesis of apoB is similar to that of most
secreted proteins. ApoB is translated on ribosomes bound to the
endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and is cotranslationally translocated across
the ER membrane to the lumen and transported through the secretory
pathway (Palade, 1975
). Unlike other secretory proteins, though, the
secretion of a mature form of apoB requires cotranslational or
posttranslational assembly with triacylglycerols (TG), cholesteroyl esters (CE), and phospholipids to produce TG-rich lipoprotein particles. The assembly of apoB-containing lipoproteins has been proposed to occur via a two-step mechanism. In the first step, the
initial lipoprotein particle is formed in the rough ER (Borén et al., 1994
). In the second step, expansion of the lipid
core of the lipoprotein occurs in the rough ER and the smooth ER or in
the Golgi (Alexander et al., 1976
; Higgins, 1988
). Several lines of evidence suggest that this process occurs predominantly in the
rough ER (Alexander et al., 1976
; Rusiñol et
al., 1993
) or, more accurately, at the smooth-surfaced terminal
ends of the rough ER cisternae or at the junction between the rough and
smooth ER compartments (Alexander et al., 1976
). In
addition, elegant kinetic studies by Borchardt and Davis (1987)
on the
secretion rate of apoB demonstrated that exit from the ER compartment
is the rate-limiting step in hepatocytes. Furthermore, they showed that
the rate of intracellular transport of apoB-100 was approximately two
times slower than that of albumin, suggesting that a processing step
unique to apoB was occurring in the ER (Borchardt and Davis, 1987
). The
final lipoprotein particle product of this complex biosynthetic process
is often depicted as a lipid-containing sphere made of a polar shell
containing amphipathic protein, unesterified cholesterol, and
phospholipids, with a neutral lipid core rich in TG and CE (Davis and
Vance, 1996
).
Many studies have shown that the regulation of apoB secretion is
posttranslational and depends on the availability of neutral lipids.
Under physiological conditions in which the availability of neutral
lipid substrates is limiting, the secretion of apoB is reduced and a
large proportion of nascent apoB will be degraded (Borchardt and Davis,
1987
; Davis et al., 1990
). On the other hand, when the
availability of neutral lipids is increased, the secretion of apoB
lipoproteins is also increased. It is believed that apoB that fails to
engage in lipoprotein assembly is inefficiently translocated and
undergoes transmembrane integration (Davis et al., 1990
;
Fisher et al., 1997
; Mitchell et al., 1998
). The
transmembrane form of apoB is still competent for assembly with lipid
and translocation into the ER lumen (Sakata et al., 1993
).
Furthermore, transmembrane apoB was recently shown to remain in close
proximity to the translocon, where it potentially waits to be lipidated
and translocated (Mitchell et al., 1998
). In the prolonged
absence of assembly with neutral lipids, apoB is proteolytically
degraded (reviewed by Yao et al., 1997
) in the secretory
pathway (Davis et al., 1990
; Dixon et al., 1991
;
Furukawa et al., 1992
; Wang et al., 1995
) or by
the ubiquitin-proteosome pathway after retrograde transport of apoB to
the cytosol (Fisher et al., 1997
). Undoubtedly,
translocation of apoB plays a key role in the regulation of lipoprotein
particle secretion. To further illustrate this point, several domains
of apoB known as pause-transfer sequences have been shown to
transiently uncouple translocation of apoB in cell-free systems (Chuck
and Lingappa, 1992
, 1993
; Nakahara et al., 1994
; Hegde and
Lingappa, 1996
) and thus could participate in the translocational
regulation of lipoprotein assembly. Despite this knowledge, the
molecular switch that links the availability of newly synthesized
neutral lipids and the targeting of apoB lipoprotein for either
secretion or proteolytic degradation has remained elusive.
During its complex biosynthesis, apoB is further modified by disulfide
bond formation, glycosylation, phosphorylation, and fatty acylation
(Havel and Kane, 1995
; Davis and Vance, 1996
). Earlier studies have
demonstrated that apoB was covalently modified by the fatty acid
palmitate via a thioester bond (Hoeg et al., 1988
; Huang
et al., 1988
; Kamanna and Lee, 1989
; Lee and Singh, 1990
;
Lee, 1991
). Typically, protein palmitoylation is a reversible posttranslational modification that occurs on cysteine residues and is
recognized to be an essential component of the dynamic membrane
targeting of several signal-transducing proteins (Schlesinger, 1993
;
Casey, 1995
; Milligan et al., 1995
; Dunphy and Linder,
1998
). Proper palmitoylation of signaling proteins, such as the
nonreceptor protein tyrosine kinases, the 224 subunits of
heterotrimeric G-proteins, and some Ras protooncogenes, is critical for
their function. Mutations preventing palmitoylation of these signaling
proteins abolished or impaired proper membrane targeting and biological
function. The role of protein palmitoylation has been studied
extensively in signal-transducing proteins, but its involvement in the
structure or function of a secreted lipoprotein has not yet been investigated.
In the present work, we mapped a palmitoylation site in apoB and studied the contribution of a single palmitoylated cysteine in the structure and function of apoB lipoprotein. We found that palmitoylation of apoB plays two critical roles in lipoprotein biogenesis: first, a structural role in the assembly of the neutral hydrophobic core of the lipoprotein particle; second, a positional role in the intracellular trafficking of apoB lipoprotein. These exciting new roles for protein palmitoylation add to its established role in reversible membrane targeting of signal-transducing proteins.
| |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Cell Lines, Antibodies, and Reagents
McArdle-RH7777 rat hepatoma cells were maintained in 10% FBS and 10% horse serum in DMEM (Life Technologies, Grand Island, NY) with 100 U/ml penicillin G sodium, 100 mg/ml streptomycin sulfate (Life Technologies) and passed twice per week. HepG2 human hepatoma cells were maintained in 10% FBS in modified Eagle's medium (Life Technologies) with the antibiotics mentioned above. Cells were maintained at 37°C in a humidified atmosphere containing 5% CO2. McArdle-RH7777 cells stably expressing apoB-18, apoB-31, and apoB-37 were kind gifts from Drs. Zemin Yao (University of Ottawa, Ontario, Canada) and Stephen H. Young (University of California, San Francisco).
Na[125I] (2.14 Ci/mmol) and
[3H]glycerol (3.5 Ci/mmol) were purchased from
Amersham-Pharmacia (Arlington Heights, IL).
[125I]Iodopalmitate was radiolabeled as
described by Berthiaume et al. (1995)
without HPLC
purification of the final product. Donkey anti-rabbit immunoglobulin
G-Texas Red (IgG-TR) and anti-rabbit IgG-FITC, donkey anti-mouse
IgG-TR and anti-mouse IgG-FITC secondary Abs, normal donkey serum, and
IgG-free, protease-free BSA were obtained from Jackson ImmunoResearch
Laboratories (West Grove, PA). The 1D1 mouse monoclonal anti-human apoB
antibody, which recognizes an epitope on the N terminus of human apoB
(amino acids 474-539) (Pease et al., 1990
), was a kind gift
of Drs. R.W. Milne and Y.L. Marcel (University of Ottawa). This mAb did
not cross-react with rat apoB. The SY rabbit anti-mouse apoB-100
antibody used in immunocytochemistry was made with the use of a
C-terminal epitope antigen of mouse apoB in a transgenic rabbit
expressing human apoB-100. This SY antibody detected endogenous rat
apoB-100 in Western blot and immunofluorescence protocols but did not
react with mouse or rat apoB-48 or cross-react with human apoBs. This antibody was a kind gift of Dr. Stephen H. Young. The RD rabbit antibody recognizing both forms of rat apoB (B-48 and B-100) and not
human apoB was a gift of Dr. Roger A. Davis (University of Colorado
Health Science Center, Denver, CO). Rabbit anti-protein disulfide isomerase (PDI) antibody was a kind gift from Dr. Marek Michalak (University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada). Rabbit anti-
-mannosidase II was from Dr. Kelley Moremen (University of
Georgia, Athens, GA). All other reagents were of the highest purity available and were generally purchased from Sigma (St. Louis, MO).
Metabolic Labeling
McArdle-RH7777 rat hepatoma cell lines expressing various human
C-terminally truncated apoBs and HepG2 human hepatoma cells expressing
apoB-100 were metabolically labeled with
[125I]iodopalmitate (Berthiaume et
al., 1995
). After a 4-h incubation with 50-100 µCi per 100-mm
dish, the radiolabeling media containing the
[125I]iodopalmitate were removed and cells were
washed twice with culture media and allowed to secrete radiolabeled
apoB-containing particles for 16 h in serum-free media. Media
containing secreted apoB were harvested, and detached cells were
removed by low-speed centrifugation. Media were concentrated by
ultrafiltration, delipidated by extraction with chloroform:methanol
(1:3, vol/vol), dissolved in sample buffer containing 4% SDS, 40%
glycerol, 65 mM DTT, and 0.5 M Tris-HCl, pH 6.5, and separated on 5%
SDS-PAGE. The proportions of chloroform and methanol in the organic
extraction were critical to remove the various types of glycerolipids
bound to apoB particles before electrophoresis. This ensured minimal
nonspecific binding of radiolabeled lipids to the various apoBs.
Similar amounts of secreted lipoproteins (as judged by titration on a
pilot Coomassie-stained gel) were separated by SDS-PAGE and
electroblotted onto Immobilon-P polyvinylidene difluoride (PVDF)
membranes (Millipore, Bedford, MA). Western blot analysis of various
secreted apoB constructs was performed with the use of the mouse
monoclonal 1D1 anti-human apoB antibody followed by ECL detection
(Amersham-Pharmacia). Incorporation of
[125I]iodopalmitate into various secreted apoB
proteins was visualized by phosphorimaging and autoradiography of the
PVDF membrane.
Hydroxylamine Hydrolysis of apoB-29 Metabolically Labeled with [125I]Iodopalmitate
After metabolic labeling of cells stably expressing apoB-29 with
[125I]iodopalmitate and SDS-PAGE analysis of
the secreted apoB-29, the apoB-29 samples were blotted onto PVDF
membranes. The membranes were soaked in either 1 M neutral
hydroxylamine or 1 M Tris-HCl, pH 7.0, for 72 h (Schlesinger,
1993
). After hydrolysis, membranes were rinsed several times in PBS and
processed for Western blot and ECL. Dried membranes were subjected to
phosphorimaging and autoradiography.
Hydrolysis of [125I]Iodopalmitate-radiolabeled apoB-29 and TLC
After SDS-PAGE analysis of
[125I]iodopalmitate-labeled apoB-29, the
acrylamide gel was subjected to autoradiography at
80°C to identify
the gel band corresponding to apoB-29. The corresponding gel band was
cut out, crushed with a glass rod, and hydrolyzed with 0.5 ml of 0.5 M
KOH for 16 h at 4°C. The hydrolysate was then acidified to pH
5.0 with HCl, and the suspension was extracted twice with 1 ml of
chloroform. Chloroform extracts were pooled, reduced to a small volume
under a nitrogen stream, and analyzed by TLC on silica gel 60 plates
(EM Separation Technology, Gibbstown, NJ). TLC plates were
developed with a heptane:isopropylether:glacial acetic acid (60:40:4,
vol/vol) mobile phase. [125I]Iodopalmitate was
used as a standard. Dried chromatograms were subjected to autoradiography.
Mutagenesis and Establishment of McArdle-RH7777 Cell Lines Stably Expressing Truncated apoB-29s
Cys-1085 in human apoB-29 cDNA was substituted by a serine
residue with the use of the Quik-change protocol (Stratagene, La Jolla,
CA). In the Quik-change mutagenesis protocol, copies of the template
are made in a non-PCR mechanism with the use of high-fidelity thermostable Pfu DNA polymerase, minimizing second-site
mutation. Methylated parental DNA is removed by DpnI
digestion. DNA containing the mutation is then transformed into
bacteria. Five mutant cDNA clones were sequenced by automated dideoxy
DNA sequencing (University of Alberta Biochemistry DNA Core Facility)
to confirm the presence of the mutation. We subcloned the five
independently sequenced cDNAs containing the mutation encoding for the
Cys1085Ser substitution in apoB-29 and the corresponding wild-type (WT)
apoB-29 cDNA into the mammalian expression vector pCMV5 (Andersson
et al., 1989
). McArdle-RH7777 cell lines stably expressing
the apoB-29s were established by cotransfecting the pCMV5 expression
vectors containing either WT or Cys1085Ser mutant apoB-29 cDNAs with
pSV2Neo vector encoding neomycin resistance (Clontech, Palo Alto,
CA) and selecting for neomycin-resistant cells (Sambrook et
al., 1989
; Blackhart et al., 1990
; Yao et
al., 1991
). Neomycin-resistant clones secreting apoB-29 proteins
were identified by Western blot analysis of culture supernatants.
Nondenaturating Gel Electrophoresis
Media from overlaying stably transfected McArdle-RH7777 cells
grown on a 100-mm dish were concentrated by ultrafiltration, and
aliquots were loaded on nondenaturing 3-10% polyacrylamide gradient
gel and separated by electrophoresis, as described by McLeod et
al. (1993)
. ApoBs were detected by Western blot as described above
with the use of the 1D1 mAb.
Isopycnic Density Gradient Analysis of Secreted Lipoproteins and TLC of Lipids Bound to apoB Lipoproteins
Stably transfected McArdle-RH7777 cells were radiolabeled for
4 h with [125I]iodopalmitate as described
above. Media were concentrated by ultrafiltration, and 0.7 g of
KBr was added to 1 ml of concentrated medium containing similar amounts
of apoB-29 lipoproteins (as judged by titration of various aliquots on
a pilot Coomassie-stained polyacrylamide gel). After dissolution,
additional saline solution (0.9% NaCl) was added to complete the
volume to 5.0 ml. After centrifugation for 1 h at 100,000 × g at 4°C in a Ti90 vertical rotor (Beckman, Fullerton,
CA), 20 fractions of 250 µl each were collected from the bottom of
the centrifugation tube. The density corresponding to each fraction was
measured gravimetrically. Lipids corresponding to these fractions were
extracted with chloroform:methanol (1:3, vol/vol) and analyzed by TLC,
according to the procedure of Yao and Vance (1988)
, followed by
autoradiography. Lipoproteins from each fraction were concentrated with
the use of Cab-o-sil beads (Sigma, St. Louis, MO) and separated
on 5% SDS-PAGE followed by Western blot analysis (Yao et
al., 1991
, 1992
; McLeod et al., 1993
).
Immunocytochemistry
McArdle-RH7777 cells stably expressing either apoB-29 or
apoB-29(Cys1085Ser) were fixed for 10 min in 4% paraformaldehyde in
PBS at 25°C and then permeabilized for 2 min at 25°C with 0.2% Triton X-100 in PBS. To detect human apoB-29s, permeabilized cells were
incubated for 1 h at 37°C in a humidified atmosphere with the
mouse monoclonal 1D1 anti-human apoB antibody in 1× Blotto. Goat anti-mouse IgG conjugated with TR (Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR)
was then incubated as described above at 4 µg/ml. Between all steps,
cells were washed four times with PBS during a 5-min period. Endogenous
rat apoB-100 was detected with the use of the SY rabbit polyclonal
anti-mouse apoB-100 antibody. Anti-rabbit IgG-FITC conjugate (Molecular
Probes) was incubated as described above to detect the rabbit
anti-mouse apoB-100 antibody. For colocalization of various apoBs with
the ER marker PDI (Ferrari and Söling, 1999
) and with the Golgi
compartment marker protein
-mannosidase II (Velasco et
al., 1993
), primary rabbit anti-PDI and rabbit anti-
-mannosidase II antibodies were used, followed by anti-rabbit IgG-FITC conjugate. Cells were mounted in Prolong antifade solution (Molecular Probes) and observed by confocal laser scanning microscopy with the use of a Zeiss (Thornwood, NY) 510 fluorescence confocal laser
scanning microscope located at the Cross Cancer Institute (University
of Alberta).
Each image was collected within the linear range of fluorescence intensity based on the imaging software. Image overlays represent samples acquired with the use of the sequential mode for double-label collection. Final image manipulations were done in Adobe (Mountain View, CA) Photoshop 5.0. To ensure optimal comparisons, images of cells of similar size (10-20 µm diameter) and brightness were captured with the use of similar pinhole and laser intensity. No cross-reaction or bleed through was detected with the combinations of primary and secondary antibodies listed above.
| |
RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Identification of Palmitoylated Cysteine Residue(s) in apoB
To begin the investigation of the role of palmitoylation of apoB,
we needed to identify which of the nine cysteines of apoB that is (are)
not involved in intramolecular disulfide bond formation (Yang et
al., 1990
) is (are) palmitoylated. Maps describing the positions
of these cysteine residues in various apoBs are shown in Figure
1, A and B. Therefore, we used a deletion
analysis approach combined with metabolic labeling of truncated human
apoBs (apoB-18, apoB-29, apoB-31, apoB-37) secreted from McArdle-RH7777
cells to narrow the region of palmitoylation. Then, we used
site-directed mutagenesis to eliminate a putative palmitoylation site.
Incorporation of [125I]iodopalmitate
(Berthiaume et al., 1995
) into the various secreted apoBs is
depicted in Figures 1 and 2.
|
|
In Figure 1, C and D, various apoBs are shown to be secreted from McArdle-RH7777 or HepG2 cells, and our metabolic labeling study shows that human apoB-29, apoB-31, apoB-37, and apoB-100 secreted from cells incorporate [125I]iodopalmitate, whereas apoB-18 does not. Because apoB-29 contains a single free cysteine residue and incorporates [125I]iodopalmitate, this suggests that Cys-1085 of apoB-29 appears to be a palmitate acceptor (Figure 1D). Also noteworthy, radiolabeling signals resulting from apparent covalent incorporation of [125I]iodopalmitate into apoB proteins are progressively more intense in apoBs larger than apoB-29 (Figure 1D). These results suggest that other cysteine residues in apoB-31, apoB-37, and apoB-100 also are potentially palmitoylated. Consistent with this possibility, for apoB-29, apoB-31, and apoB-37, the intensity of the signal is proportional to the number of free cysteine residues present in those truncated apoBs (Figure 1, B and D). In this study, different McArdle-RH7777 cell lines stably expressing various apoBs were used and exhibit various ratios of endogenous apoB to human apoB. This accounts for variations in the amounts of endogenous apoB-100 present on PVDF membranes, as detected by autoradiography and shown in Figure 1D.
We also validated our methodology to ensure that the autoradiographic signal obtained from our metabolic labeling approach was not the result of nonspecific binding of indirectly radiolabeled glycerolipids to apoBs. In a parallel experiment, we metabolically labeled cells with 60 µCi of [3H]glycerol (instead of [125I]iodopalmitate) and processed samples as described in MATERIALS AND METHODS. Bands corresponding to apoB were excised from the PVDF membrane and counted by scintillation. No [3H]radioactivity could be detected in those samples (data not shown). This result suggests that our methodology, which uses a pulse-chase labeling approach, organic extraction of secreted apoBs followed by SDS-PAGE analysis, and Western blotting before autoradiography, removed all detectable traces of glycerolipids specifically or nonspecifically bound to apoBs.
ApoB Cysteine Residue 1085 Is Palmitoylated via a Thioester Bond
The chemical nature of the bond linking the
[125I]iodopalmitate analogue and apoB-29 was
investigated by treatment with 1 M neutral hydroxylamine, which cleaves
thioester bonds but leaves ester (carboxyl ester or oxyester) bonds
intact (Schlesinger, 1993
). Figure 2A shows the autoradiogram
corresponding to two radiolabeled bands containing apoB-29 on PVDF
membranes before hydrolysis with neutral hydroxylamine or Tris-HCl, pH
7.0, as a control. As shown in Figure 2B, neutral hydroxylamine
treatment resulted in a loss of radioactivity from apoB-29, compared
with the control treatment with neutral Tris buffer. These results
confirm that apoB-29 radiolabel was incorporated into apoB-29 through a
thioester bond. Hydroxylamine treatment is typically performed in gel
slices (Schlesinger, 1993
) or even in solution (Schroeder et
al., 1996
). In the present case, hydroxylamine hydrolysis was
performed on apoB-29 bound to PVDF membranes because hydroxylamine
treatment caused aggregation of apoBs tested in solution (our
unpublished observation) and thus potentially in gel as well. To ensure
that an equivalent amount of apoB-29 remained bound to the PVDF
membrane, the membrane was stained with Coomassie. Hydroxylamine
treatment did not alter the amount of apoB-29 present on the membrane
(data not shown).
To further confirm the chemical nature of the labeled moiety bound to apoB-29, we hydrolyzed a polyacrylamide gel band containing radiolabeled apoB-29 with 0.5 M KOH at 4°C for 16 h and extracted the acidified (pH 5.0) hydrolysate with chloroform. TLC analysis of this hydrolysate revealed that the radioactive signal hydrolyzed from apoB-29 comigrated and corresponded to [125I]iodopalmitate used as a standard (Figure 2C). To control for the possibility that our hydrolytic treatment might have cleaved off fatty acid moieties linked to glycerolipids via carboxyl ester linkages, we incubated tritiated triolein in 0.5 M KOH at 4°C for 16 h, acidified it (pH 5.0), and extracted the mixture with chloroform. The organic phase extract was then analyzed by TLC with appropriate standards. Under these conditions, no [3H]oleate was released from the glycerol backbone of the tritiated triolein (data not shown).
To test whether the only free cysteine residue of apoB-29, Cys-1085, was palmitoylated, we substituted a serine residue for this cysteine residue by site-directed mutagenesis. McArdle-RH7777 cell lines stably expressing similar levels of WT and Cys1085Ser mutant apoB-29s were then metabolically labeled with [125I]iodopalmitate, as described in MATERIALS AND METHODS. Incorporation of the [125I]iodopalmitate analogue into both apoB-29s was evaluated after organic extraction, SDS-PAGE, Western blotting (Figure 2D), and autoradiography (Figure 2E). The results indicate that the Cys1085Ser mutant of apoB-29 was not a substrate for palmitoylation.
Palmitoylation Is Critical for the Assembly of Neutral Lipid Core into apoB-29 Lipoprotein Particle
To determine if palmitoylation plays a role in lipoprotein
particle assembly, we compared the size and buoyancy of WT and Cys1085Ser apoB-29-containing lipoproteins. We first measured the
relative electrophoretic mobilities of palmitoylated and
nonpalmitoylated forms of apoB-29 with the use of nondenaturing
gradient gel electrophoresis. Second, we analyzed the lipoproteins'
densities by isopycnic gradient centrifugation. In four independent
determinations, particles containing nonpalmitoylated apoB-29 formed
electrophoretically more mobile particles on native gels. Typical
results are shown in Figure 3A. Although
the difference in electrophoretic mobility was slight, it was
reproducible. Our density gradient analyses also demonstrated that
nonpalmitoylated apoB-29 lipoproteins formed significantly denser
particles. Typical data obtained from an experiment that was repeated
seven times are shown in Figure 3B. Figure 3C shows the corresponding
graphical representation of relative amounts of apoB-29s calculated as
a percentage of the peak value analyzed in fractions 1-14 of each
gradient. The maximal distribution of the particles containing mutant
apoB-29 in the KBr gradient was up to fraction 7 ± 2 (n = 6), whereas that of the WT apoB-29 was up to fraction 12 ± 2 (n = 7). The average density corresponding to the tube containing
the most apoB-29 (peak), as determined by Western blot analysis, was
1.23 ± 0.02 (n = 6) for the particles containing Cys1085Ser
mutant apoB-29, whereas it was significantly lower for particles
containing WT apoB-29 (1.16 ± 0.03; n = 7). The peak density
reached by lipoprotein particles containing WT apoB-29 in our
experiments was similar to that reported by McLeod et al.
(1996)
for particles containing apoB-29 (density of the peak fraction
[
peak] = 1.12) and for particles containing
apoB-28 (
peak = 1.17) (Yao et al.,
1991
). Our average density for WT apoB-29-containing particles is also similar to those reported by Spring et al. (1992)
for
particles containing either apoB-26 (
peak = 1.163) or apoB-33 (
peak = 1.143). In our
experiments, great care was taken to ensure that identical amounts and
volumes of WT and mutant apoB-29s were loaded on each gradient to avoid
potential differences in spread of the protein through the gradient or
position of the peak fraction. The fact that mutant apoB-29 lipoprotein
particles formed smaller and denser particles than the WT apoB-29 was
consistent with the possibility that fewer lipids were present in the
mutant lipoprotein particle. These results were confirmed in two other
independent clones for each McArdle-RH7777 cell line stably expressing
WT or mutant human apoB-29s (data not shown).
|
The next experiments compared the lipid content of lipoprotein
particles containing the WT and Cys1085Ser mutant apoB-29s. To ensure
minimal lipid contribution from endogenous apoB-48 or apoB-100
lipoproteins, secreted lipoproteins were separated on an isopycnic KBr
gradient and TLC analysis was performed on the lipid content of
fractions containing apoB-29 proteins but not apoB-100, as judged by
Western blot analysis of corresponding aliquots (Figure 3B, fractions
1-7). Although particles containing endogenous apoB-100 were
effectively separated from those containing apoB-29s, particles
containing endogenous apoB-48 were not (data not shown). The particles
containing endogenous apoB-48 were typically found in fractions 5-9
(
peak = 1.10-1.06) when detected.
Indeed, in five independent determinations, levels of secreted apoB-48 were at least 100 times lower than levels of either apoB-29 (n = 3) or were undetectable (n = 2), as judged by Western blot
analysis or Coomassie staining of PVDF membranes (data not shown). As
such, the amounts of apoB-48 present in fractions 5-9 were so small that we believe the vast majority of lipids isolated from fractions 1-7 belong to particles containing apoB-29s and not to particles containing endogenous apoB-48. The low levels of apoB-48 in the clones
of McArdle-RH7777 cells we obtained from Dr. Zemin Yao have also been
reported previously (Hussain et al., 1995
).
The lipid content in particles containing nonpalmitoylated Cys1085Ser
apoB-29 was significantly different from that in particles containing
WT apoB-29 (Figure 4). When the ratios of
neutral lipids in WT and mutant particles were analyzed by TLC and
quantified by phosphorimager analysis, the relative concentrations of
nonpolar lipids were three to four times lower in lipoprotein particles containing apoB-29(Cys1085Ser) compared with those in particles containing WT apoB-29. The mutant particles reproducibly contained 36 ± 8% CE and 26 ± 12% TG of the WT lipoprotein
particles in three different experiments. Typical results are shown in
Figure 4. In contrast, levels of polar lipids isolated from WT or
mutant apoB-29 lipoprotein particles were almost identical (Figure 4). These results are consistent with a structural role for protein palmitoylation in the assembly of the nonpolar hydrophobic core in the
apoB lipoprotein. We also determined if expression of various apoB-29s
affected the secretion and composition of lipids from endogenous apoB
particles from McArdle-RH7777 cells expressing either WT or Cys1085Ser
mutant apoB-29s by analyzing an aliquot of pooled fractions 11-20. In
Figure 4B, we show that lipid composition and content were not altered
significantly in endogenous rat apoB lipoproteins secreted from
McArdle-RH7777 cells expressing either WT or Cys1085Ser mutant apoB-29.
Furthermore, levels of expression of endogenous apoBs were similar in
both cell lines (data not shown). As such, stable expression of either
apoB-29 did not have any apparent dominant effects on the cellular
machinery responsible for assembling lipids into lipoproteins in
McArdle-RH7777 cells. The presence of free fatty acids in fractions
1-5 of the KBr density gradient was attributed to the content of BSA
in these fractions (Yao et al., 1991
).
|
Palmitoylation of apoB-29 Is Involved in Intracellular Sorting
To explain the differences in lipid content between WT and
mutant apoB-29 lipoprotein particles, we tested whether the lack of
palmitoylation could influence the intracellular localization of
Cys1085Ser apoB-29 and thus prevent interaction with the neutral lipid-loading machinery. Immunocytochemistry was used to localize either human apoB-29 or endogenous apoB-100 within McArdle-RH7777 cells
(Figure 5A). Images obtained from the
confocal laser scanning microscope showed that the apparent majority of
WT human apoB-29 and endogenous rat apoB-100 was localized in rather
large spherical vesicular structures distributed throughout the cytosol
(Figure 5A, a, c, d, and f). In addition, both apoB-29s and apoB-100
showed diffuse fluorescence staining throughout the cytosol. The
intensity of this apparent cytosolic fluorescence varied from cell to
cell. In contrast, nonpalmitoylated apoB-29 was concentrated in a dense perinuclear area similar to that of the Golgi compartment (Figure 5A, b
and e). We then tested whether the large vesicular structures containing WT apoB-29 or endogenous apoB-100 would represent the same
intracellular structures. Our indirect double immunofluorescence studies showed significant overlap between the fluorescent signals corresponding to WT apoB-29 and those of endogenous rat apoB-100 (Figure 5B). The colocalization was restricted to the large vesicular structures distributed throughout the cytosol (Figure 5B). Typically, the fluorescent signals corresponding to large vesicles containing WT
apoB-29 were encompassed within those corresponding to large vesicles
containing endogenous apoB-100. This observation is consistent with the
possibility that other protein-sorting determinants might lie in the
C-terminal 71% of apoB-100.
|
Based on the similarity in size and distribution of these vesicles and the significant extent of colocalization between WT apoB-29 and endogenous rat apoB (Figure 5, A and B), we conclude that the presence of a single palmitoylated cysteine residue on apoB-29 is a key signaling determinant that is responsible for proper intracellular localization of apoB-29 lipoprotein. Cells expressing nonpalmitoylated Cys1085Ser apoB-29 exhibited some colocalization between mutant apoB-29 and endogenous rat apoB. The extent of this colocalization was restricted to the dense perinuclear area enriched in mutant apoB-29 (results not shown).
Most WT apoB-29 Is Found in a Subcompartment of the ER, Whereas Nonpalmitoylated apoB-29 Is Found Mostly in the Golgi Apparatus
To identify the cellular compartments corresponding to the
localization of both apoB-29s, indirect double immunofluorescence colocalization studies were carried out between apoB-29s and known organelle markers of the secretory pathway. Although WT apoB-29 colocalized very significantly with the large vesicular structures containing PDI, an ER organelle marker (Ferrari and Söling,
1999
), nonpalmitoylated Cys1085Ser apoB-29 and apoB-18 only partially colocalized with PDI (Figure 6). The
extent of the partial colocalization of Cys1085Ser mutant apoB-29 and
apoB-18 with PDI was mostly restricted to a dense juxta/perinuclear
area. In McArdle-RH7777 cells, the distribution of the fluorescence
corresponding to the ER marker PDI was more punctate than reticular
(Figure 6), although the shape/structure of the ER appeared normal upon
fluorescence staining of the cells with the use of FITC-conjugated
concanavalin A (our unpublished results). Cell-specific distribution of
PDI was also noticeable (Figure 6, middle panels), especially in cells
apparently expressing larger amounts of WT apoB-29. Thus, these results
are consistent with the proposition that the large vesicular structures containing WT apoB-29 and/or endogenous apoB represent a distinct subcompartment of the ER. As such, protein palmitoylation appears to be
required to localize apoB-29 to these ER subcompartments.
|
Although the overlap between signals corresponding to large vesicular
structures containing WT apoB-29 (or endogenous apoB-100; results not
shown) and PDI was predominant, it was rarely total (Figure 6). This
finding could be explained by the fact that some of these large
vesicular structures colocalized with the trans-Golgi network organelle marker TGN38 (our unpublished results). This latter
observation is consistent with the results of Hamilton et
al. (1991)
, who showed that apoB-VLDL particles were found in
dilated ends of the trans-Golgi by electron microscopy of
intact Golgi fractions isolated from rat livers.
In the absence of palmitoylation, apoB-29(Cys1085Ser) seemed to
be concentrated in a compartment similar to the Golgi apparatus. To
test whether this was the case, a double immunofluorescence study was
performed between various apoBs and a known marker of the medial Golgi
compartment,
-mannosidase II (Velasco et al., 1993
).
Distinct from nonpalmitoylated forms of apoB, staining corresponding to
large vesicular structures containing WT apoB-29 or endogenous apoB-100
showed only partial colocalization with that of
-mannosidase II
(Figure 7). The extent of this partial colocalization was restricted to a dense juxta/perinuclear area. In
McArdle-RH7777 cell lines stably expressing mutant apoB-29, the
localization of the medial Golgi marker
-mannosidase II completely overlapped with the dense perinuclear staining of apoB-29(Cys1085Ser) and apoB-18 (our unpublished observations). These results suggest that
nonpalmitoylated apoB-29 and apoB-18 showed an apparent increased concentration in the Golgi apparatus. Under steady-state conditions, it
appears that palmitoylated and nonpalmitoylated forms of apoB accumulate in different cellular compartments. This difference is
consistent with a change in the rate-limiting step of secretion of
these apoBs.
|
In our study, McArdle-RH7777 cell lines stably expressing either WT or Cys1085Ser apoB-29s were matched for their ability to secrete similar levels of both apoB-29s. Similar intracellular distributions were found with the use of immunofluorescence in five different McArdle-RH7777 cell lines stably expressing WT or mutant apoB-29s (our unpublished results). In those experiments, McArdle-RH7777 cell lines stably expressing mutant apoB-29s were obtained with the use of five independently sequenced Cys1085Ser apoB-29 cDNAs. Thus, we believe that the observed variations in neutral lipid assembly and/or subcellular localization of Cys1085Ser apoB-29 are representative and are not caused by deleterious insertion of the expression vector in the genome of McArdle-RH7777 cells or by the presence of a spontaneous secondary mutation resulting in nonspecific alteration of the secretory pathway.
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
ApoB Is Palmitoylated on Cysteine Residue 1085 via a Thioester Bond
The biosynthesis and maturation of apoB-containing lipoprotein
particles is a complex multistep process that has been shown to involve
cotranslational addition of lipids, several chaperonins, including
calreticulin and Bip (Linnik and Herscovitz, 1998
), microsomal lipid
transfer protein (Wu et al., 1996
; Wang et al., 1997
; Rustaeus et al., 1998
), and a series of
posttranslational covalent modifications, including protein fatty
acylation (Hoeg et al., 1988
; Huang et al.,
1988
). Here, a fatty acid in the form of a
[125I]iodopalmitate analogue was shown to be
bound covalently to apoB via a hydroxylamine-sensitive thioester bond.
These data confirmed those previously reported by Hoeg et
al. (1988)
and Huang et al. (1988)
. With the use of a
combination of metabolic labeling and site-directed mutagenesis, a
palmitoylation site was localized to cysteine residue 1085 in human
apoB-29. Furthermore, the metabolic labeling results show an increased
autoradiographic signal intensity in apoB-31 and apoB-37 compared with
apoB-29. This finding suggests that there may be more than one
palmitoylation site on apoB. This increase appeared proportional to the
number of free cysteine residues present in apoB-31 (two) and apoB-37
(four). Consistent with this possibility, the amino acids surrounding
the first three free cysteine residues of human apoB are very similar
(LSC1085D, LSC1395D, and
LSC1478Q). This amino acid sequence could
potentially represent a recognition motif for a protein fatty acyl
transferase (PAT) that could palmitoylate apoB. The amino acids
surrounding the fourth free cysteine residue are somewhat less related
but still are relatively similar to those surrounding the first three
(LKC1635S). The sequence context of the remaining
five free cysteine residues present in human apoB did not show any
apparent similarity with that of the first four. Unfortunately, only
the human apoB cDNA sequence is available in the area of Cys-1085
(Segrest et al., 1998
). As such, we cannot assess the level
of conservation of that cysteine residue among apoBs from various
species, nor can we extrapolate our findings.
Palmitoylation of apoB Is Required for Proper Assembly of the Neutral Lipid Core of the Lipoprotein Particle
Studying the role of multiple potential palmitoylation sites in
apoB-100 might have complicated the interpretation of results because
these palmitoylation sites might have different functions in apoB-100.
Fortunately, apoB-29, a truncated lipoprotein that can form functional
buoyant lipoprotein particles, offers the unique opportunity to study
the role of a single palmitoylation site in the structure and function
of a lipoprotein. The elimination of the single palmitoylation site in
apoB-29 resulted in secretion of smaller and denser lipoprotein
particles than those containing palmitoylated apoB-29, as judged by
native PAGE and isopycnic gradient analyses. Differences in size and
density could be explained by the fact that nonpalmitoylated apoB-29
mutant particles contained on average five times less TG and no
detectable CE compared with lipoprotein particles containing WT
apoB-29; thus, they were less buoyant. Although the lack of
palmitoylation of apoB-29 had a striking deleterious effect on the
assembly of TG and CE in the neutral lipid core, it did not alter the
levels of the polar phospholipids that are components of the
amphiphatic shell of the lipoprotein particle. As such, palmitoylation
of apoB plays a specific role in the assembly of the neutral lipids (CE
and TG) into the hydrophobic core of the lipoprotein particle. Thus,
palmitoylation may be involved in the second step of the lipoprotein
particle assembly, whereby a lipid droplet rich in CE and TG
originating from the smooth ER would fuse to the lipid-poor nascent
apoB lipoprotein particle originating from the rough ER (Alexander
et al., 1976
).
Palmitoylation Is Required for Localization of apoB-29 to Large Vesicular Structures Corresponding to a Subcompartment of the ER
Double-labeling immunofluorescence techniques were used to
localize various apoBs within the cell. Using these techniques, we saw
profound differences in subcellular localization patterns between the
nonpalmitoylated apoB-29 and palmitoylated WT apoB-29 in McArdle-RH7777
cells. Whereas Cys1085Ser mutant apoB-29 was concentrated in the Golgi
apparatus, the vast majority of WT apoB-29, like endogenous apoB-100,
was located in punctate or large vesicular structures containing the ER
marker PDI. As such, these large vesicular structures could represent
subcompartments of the rough ER, as described by Mitchell et
al. (1998)
, who showed that apoB-100 was present in punctate
structures corresponding to extensions of the rough ER. Also, elegant
work with the electron microscope by Claude (1970)
and Alexander
et al. (1976)
showed that nascent apoB-VLDL particles were
present at smooth-surfaced terminal ends of the rough ER cisternae and,
in some vesicles, in close proximity to the rough ER or interposed
between rough ER cisternae and the Golgi apparatus. These latter
structures were then postulated to represent specialized
smooth-surfaced tubular elements that could transport nascent apoB-VLDL
to the Golgi apparatus. Our results are thus consistent with a role for
palmitoylation in the localization of apoB-29 to large spherical
structures that may represent extensions or subcompartments of the ER.
Whether the spherical/punctate form of the large vesicular structures containing WT apoB-29 and apoB-100 can be attributed to distinct vesicles or a cross-section of tubular elements of the ER is not known
at present.
Pre-Golgi elements described by Presley et al. (1997)
were
often larger than 1.5 µm and were similar in size and distribution to
our large vesicular structures containing WT apoB-29 or endogenous apoB-100. Thus, our large vesicular structures may represent pre-Golgi elements similar to those involved in the transport of the viral glycoprotein VSV-G (Presley et al.,1997
). Also, VSV-G has
been found in smaller vesicular carriers (40-80 nm) and
vesicular-tubular clusters responsible for transporting the protein
from the ER to the Golgi apparatus (Balch et al., 1994
).
Whether our large vesicular structures represent pre-Golgi elements
such as those described by Presley et al. (1997)
, vesicular
carriers, or vesicular-tubular clusters (Balch et al., 1994
)
is not known.
The fact that, under steady-state conditions, the majority of WT and
Cys1085Ser mutant apoBs do not accumulate in the same subcellular
compartments definitely suggests a role for palmitoylation of apoB-29
in the routing of apoB through the secretory pathway. These data are
thus consistent with the palmitoylation-dependent retention/sequestration of lipid-poor apoB particles in large vesicular
structures (potentially a specialized ER compartment) awaiting the
addition of neutral lipids to occur. Once the neutral lipids are added,
the lipoprotein particle could be transported to the Golgi apparatus,
further concentrated, and secreted by exocytosis (Claude, 1970
;
Alexander et al., 1976
). In the absence of this potential
palmitoylation-dependent transport signal, nonpalmitoylated Cys1085Ser
apoB-29 would not be routed properly and could be transported by
default through the secretory pathway. In that case, transport by
default would preclude the addition of neutral lipids in the second-step part of the lipoprotein particle assembly process and
nonpalmitoylated apoB-29 would be secreted as part of smaller, denser,
lipid-poor lipoprotein particles. Alternatively, or in addition to the
subcellular localization signal provided by palmitoylation, palmitoylation may facilitate the fusion between the nascent
lipoprotein particle and the lipid droplet originating from the smooth
ER in a specialized extension/subcompartment of the ER.
As with any mutagenesis protocol, the risk of generating an
inappropriately folded mutant always exists. Although the
cysteine-to-serine substitution in mutant apoB-29 results in the net
substitution of a sulfur atom for an oxygen atom and thus represents an
extremely conservative change, some local structural alterations could
occur in addition to the prevention of palmitoylation. The proposed flexible structure of apoB (Segrest et al., 1998
) and the
fact that apoBs with significant deletions can still bind lipids (Yao et al., 1991
; Spring et al., 1992
) and form
functional lipoprotein particles suggest that the impact of a free
cysteine-to-serine substitution on the apoB structure should be
minimal. Nonetheless, functions specific to Cys-1085 in the structural
context in which it is present in apoB may also account for some of the
differences in localization independent of, or in addition to, its role
as a palmitate acceptor. By analogy, when the
O-glycosylation site of erythropoietin (EPO) was abolished
by mutagenesis (Ser126Gly mutation), mutant EPO was not secreted
(Dubé et al., 1988
). However, when secretion of EPO
was analyzed in an O-glycosylation conditional mutant cell
line, EPO was secreted at the nonpermissive temperature (Wasley
et al., 1991
). This suggested that the mutation of a single residue that was glycosylated had two consequences: 1) prevention of
glycosylation; and 2) some disruption in the folding or structure of
the protein so that it was retained in the ER. Unlike the Ser126Gly EPO
mutant, however, our Cys1085Ser apoB-29 mutant appears to be secreted
to a similar extent as WT apoB-29 in several cell lines. Furthermore,
in our case, WT apoB-29 is the protein that accumulates in the ER
during the secretion process. Clearly, the Cys1085Ser mutation leads to
a loss of function (i.e., proper routing and assembly), whether from
the absence of palmitoylation or from the net substitution of the
sulfur atom for an oxygen atom. Structural differences attributable to
the absence of palmitoylation may occur and could potentially account
in part for the differential routing of mutant apoB and its
accumulation in the Golgi instead of the ER extensions.
Palmitoylation as a Novel Molecular Sensor for Assembly, Sorting, and Secretion of apoB Lipoprotein Particles
Under anabolic conditions, a proportion of metabolic energy is
stored in the form of lipids. One of these lipids, palmitate (C16:0),
is a precursor of several other lipids, including oleate (C18:1), CE,
TG, and phospholipids. Before it is converted to other fatty acid
species or transferred to cholesterol or glycerol moieties, palmitate
must be activated to palmitoyl-CoA. Interestingly, palmitoyl-CoA is
also the palmitoyl donor in the reaction catalyzed by the PAT enzymes
that transfer palmitate or various long-chain fatty acids onto a
variety of proteins (Schlesinger, 1993
). Under conditions in which
levels of palmitoyl-CoA would be greater than the
Km of the putative PAT that
palmitoylates apoB and of various enzymes involved in neutral lipid
synthesis (e.g., acyl-CoA:cholesterol acyltransferase and
glycerol-3-phosphate acyltransferase), palmitoyl-CoA could stimulate in
a concerted manner the synthesis of neutral lipids (CE and TG), the
palmitoylation of apoB, and the secretion of lipid-rich apoB
lipoprotein particles. Thus, palmitoylation of apoB could represent the
molecular sensor mechanism that links the availability of newly
synthesized neutral lipids to the engagement of apoB lipoprotein for secretion.
Palmitoylation of apoB is required for proper assembly of the TG- and CE-rich hydrophobic core of the lipoprotein particle and mediates its effect by allowing apoB to be localized to a subcompartment of the ER where neutral lipids have been proposed to be assembled into the lipid-poor nascent lipoprotein particle. Because apoB, TG, and CE concentrations in the blood are major risk factors for atherosclerosis, their reduction is associated with a reduction in mortality from coronary heart disease. By understanding the molecular mechanisms by which palmitoylation of apoB occurs and can act as a potential transport signal for the secretion of TG- and CE-rich lipoprotein particles, it should become possible to alter this process in a beneficial manner.
| |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
Many thanks to our friends and colleagues Drs. David N. Brindley, Robert O. Ryan, Richard Lehner, Alexandro Claude, Tom Hobman, and Paul Melançon for critical reading of the manuscript and valuable suggestions throughout. Special thanks to Dr. Xuejun Sun for his help with the confocal imaging facility at Cross Cancer Institute. This work was supported by grants from the Medical Research Council of Canada (MT-13447) and the Heart and Stroke Foundation of Alberta and Northwest Territories. L.G.B. is a scholar of the Medical Research Council (MRC) of Canada and the Alberta Heritage Foundation for Medical Research (AHFMR). J.B.M. is supported by MRC Ph.D. and AHFMR M.D. and Ph.D. studentships.
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
§ Corresponding author. E-mail address: luc.berthiaume{at}ualberta.ca.
| |
ABBREVIATIONS |
|---|
Abbreviations used:
apoB, apolipoprotein B;
CE, cholesteroyl
esters;
EPO, erythropoietin;
ER, endoplasmic reticulum;
IgG, immunoglobulin G;
PAT, protein fatty acyl transferase;
PDI, protein
disulfide isomerase;
PVDF, polyvinylidene difluoride;
peak, density of the peak fraction;
TG, triacylglycerol;
TR, Texas Red;
VLDL, very low density lipoproteins;
WT, wild-type.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|