|
|
|
|
Vol. 11, Issue 4, 1197-1211, April 2000
Abteilung Molekulare Mikrobiologie, Biozentrum, Universität Basel, CH-4056 Basel, Switzerland
Submitted May 4, 1999; Revised December 16, 1999; Accepted January 13, 2000| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Saccharomyces cerevisiae cnm67
cells
lack the spindle pole body (SPB) outer plaque, the main attachment site
for astral (cytoplasmic) microtubules, leading to frequent nuclear
segregation failure. We monitored dynamics of green fluorescent
protein-labeled nuclei and microtubules over several cell cycles.
Early nuclear migration steps such as nuclear positioning and spindle
orientation were slightly affected, but late phases such as rapid
oscillations and insertion of the anaphase nucleus into the bud neck
were mostly absent. Analyzes of microtubule dynamics revealed normal
behavior of the nuclear spindle but frequent detachment of astral
microtubules after SPB separation. Concomitantly, Spc72 protein, the
cytoplasmic anchor for the
-tubulin complex, was partially lost from
the SPB region with dynamics similar to those observed for
microtubules. We postulate that in cnm67
cells
Spc72-
-tubulin complex-capped astral microtubules are released from
the half-bridge upon SPB separation but fail to be anchored to the
cytoplasmic side of the SPB because of the absence of an outer plaque.
However, successful nuclear segregation in cnm67
cells can still be achieved by elongation forces of spindles that were
correctly oriented before astral microtubule detachment by action of
Kip3/Kar3 motors. Interestingly, the first nuclear segregation in
newborn diploid cells never fails, even though astral microtubule
detachment occurs.
| |
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
During mitosis, precise positioning and migration of the nucleus
as well as orientation of the spindle are crucial events for the
successful propagation of the genetic material. In the genetically
tractable budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, the
dividing nucleus has to penetrate a small channel (bud neck) between
mother and daughter cell. The migration of the nucleus to the bud neck
and orientation of the mitotic spindle along the mother-daughter axis
depend on dynamic forces that act on the nucleus via astral
(cytoplasmic) microtubules (Huffaker et al., 1988
; Sullivan
and Huffaker, 1992
; Carminati and Stearns, 1997
; Shaw et
al., 1997
). Microtubules are nucleated by the
-tubulin complex
(Sobel and Snyder, 1995
; Marschall et al., 1996
),
which is anchored to the spindle pole body (SPB) (Geissler et
al., 1996
; Spang et al., 1996b
; Knop et al.,
1997
; Knop and Schiebel, 1998
; Pereira et al., 1999
), the
yeast microtubule-organizing center. The SPB consists of three main,
electron-dense layers: the inner, central, and outer plaques. The inner
plaque serves as the attachment site for intranuclear microtubules, the
outer plaque is the major structure for binding of astral microtubules
(Byers, 1981
; Rose et al., 1993
; Winey and Byers, 1993
;
Kilmartin, 1994
; Snyder, 1994
; Bullitt et al., 1997
).
Only recently research focused on another SPB substructure that is also
capable of organizing astral microtubules: the half-bridge or, upon its
duplication, the bridge (Brachat et al., 1998
; Adams and
Kilmartin, 1999
; O'Toole et al., 1999
; Pereira et
al., 1999
), which had already been described by Byers and Goetsch
(1975)
. It lies adjacent to the central plaque within the nuclear
envelope and initiates microtubules during the early part of the cell
cycle before SPB duplication and continuing until SPB separation. For the rest of the cell cycle microtubules are organized by the SPB outer
plaque (Byers and Goetsch, 1975
). The cell cycle-dependent change of
microtubule attachment to distinct SPB substructures is concomitant
with different phases of nuclear migration. The nucleus is moved from
an apparently random position in the mother cell to a region close to
the mother-daughter boundary, the bud neck (nuclear positioning). The
nucleus then rapidly elongates along the mother-bud axis at the onset
of anaphase (fast spindle elongation). Proper orientation of the
elongated nucleus and the mitotic spindle (spindle orientation) at this
stage depends on the action of astral microtubules (Huffaker et
al., 1988
; Sullivan and Huffaker, 1992
). In wild-type cells fast
elongation of the anaphase nucleus is accompanied by its movement into
the bud (spindle insertion). This phase is followed by rapid
oscillations, with subsequent slow spindle elongation and final
division of the nucleus, as concluded from in vivo video microscopy
observations (Yeh et al., 1995
).
The observation of mutant phenotypes such as spindle misorientation and
nuclear division within the mother cell have identified several factors
that contribute to precise nuclear migration in S. cerevisiae. Among them are cytoskeletal components and proteins that are thought to support the microtubule-based motor dynein (Magdolen et al., 1988
; Haarer et al., 1990
;
Palmer et al., 1992
; Eshel et al., 1993
; Li
et al., 1993
; Clark and Meyer, 1994
; McMillan and Tatchell,
1994
; Muhua et al., 1994
; Yeh et al., 1995
).
Several members of the kinesin class of microtubule-based motor
proteins have also been associated with roles in nuclear migration and spindle orientation (Cottingham and Hoyt, 1997
; DeZwaan et
al., 1997
; Miller et al., 1998
), as well as two
suggested microtubule-cortex mediators (Farkasovsky and Kuntzel, 1995
;
Miller and Rose, 1998
).
We recently characterized Cnm67, a novel component of the SPB outer
plaque, which is required for the formation of this structure (Brachat
et al., 1998
, Wigge et al., 1998
). In cells
lacking Cnm67, the SPB outer plaque was not detectable by electron
microscopy, indicating that the main attachment site for astral
microtubules was defective. Nevertheless, cnm67
cells
were still able to organize long astral microtubules. By electron
microscopy, Brachat et al. (1998)
could show that in
cnm67
mutants astral microtubules exclusively emanated
from the bridge or half-bridge throughout the cell cycle. Therefore,
cnm67
mutants were forced to rely solely on half-bridge- and bridge-organized microtubules for nuclear migration. These cells
showed impaired spindle orientation and nuclear migration, leading to
the accumulation of bi- and multinucleate cells (Brachat et
al., 1998
).
In this study, we investigate the underlying mechanism for both failed
and successful nuclear migrations in cells lacking the SPB outer
plaques. We analyze nuclear movements as well as astral and spindle
microtubule dynamics during mitotic divisions in a large number of
wild-type and cnm67
mutant cells by in vivo time-lapse
microscopy. In addition, using a series of double mutants, we address
the question of which astral microtubule motors and cortex interactions
are required for the remaining successful nuclear migrations in this
mutants. Our results not only allow us to explain the changes in
nuclear dynamics in cnm67
cells but also point to a
general cell cycle-dependent switch in astral microtubule organization.
| |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Strains, Media, and Yeast Transformation
Yeast strains used in this study are summarized in Table
1. Yeast media were prepared as
described by Guthrie and Fink (1991)
. The yeast transformation
procedure was based on the protocol by Schiestl and Gietz (1989)
. After
the heat shock step, cells were pelleted and resuspended in 5 ml of YPD
and incubated for 2 h at 30°C. Cells were again pelleted,
resuspended in 1 ml of distilled H2O
(dH2O), and plated on selective YPD-G418
medium (200 mg/l geneticin). The Escherichia coli strain
XL1-blue (Bullock et al., 1987
) was used to propagate
plasmids.
|
DNA Manipulations and Strain Constructions
Standard DNA manipulations were performed as described by
Sambrook et al. (1989)
. We applied a PCR-based method to
construct gene deletion cassettes that were used in yeast
transformations (Wach et al., 1994
). DNA of E. coli plasmids pFA6-KanMX4 (Wach et al., 1994
),
pFA6-HIS3MX6, pFA6-GFP-KanMX6, pFA6-GFP-HIS3MX6 (Wach et
al., 1997
), and pYM3-klTRP1 (Knop et al., 1999
) served as template for preparative PCR reactions. Correct genomic integration of the corresponding construct was verified by analytical PCR (Huxley
et al., 1990
; Wach et al., 1994
). Yeast strains
were grown on YPD-G418 (200 mg/l geneticin) to select for transformants
that had integrated kanMX4 or GFP-kanMX6 deletion cassettes. Growth on
SD plates lacking histidine and tryptophane selected for GFP-HIS3MX6, HIS3MX6, or klTRP1 integration.
For gene deletions we followed the EUROFAN guidelines (A. Wach,
A. Brachat, and P. Philippsen [1996]. Guidelines for EUROFAN B0
program ORF deletants, plasmid tools, basic functional analyses, available at www.mips.biochem.mpg.de/proj/eurofan/index.html) for gene replacement in S. cerevisiae. The
cnm67
1::kanMX mutant strain was
constructed as published by Brachat et al. (1998)
. We used
the following oligonucleotide pairs for generation of the kanMX4,
His3MX6, klTRP1 deletion cassettes with flanking homologies to the
target genes: dhc1
1,
5'-TACTCGTTCAGAGCTTAAATTGGAAAGTACGTCAAAACGTTTTTTAGGCAGGTCGACGGATCCCCGGG-3' and
5'-TTTGAACCTGTTCTATACAATTTTGTATATCATCTTTTAG-TTTGA-TGACTACATCGATGAATTCGAGCTCG-3'; kip2
1,
5'-AGA-ACACT-TGATAAAATTCTTACCATAATACCACCATTGATGCGTACGCTGCAGGTCGAC-3' and
5'-AACAATCCGCACAAGGAA-AAAAGCACCCGAGATCTGGGACCCCATCGATGAATTCGAGCT-CG-3'; kip3
1,
5'-CTTGAGTTTTCTTTCCAGCTGTATACTATTGACACTAACATGCGTACGCTGCAG-GTCGAC-3' and
5'-AATGCT-GGCGGAAAGAAGTTATATTCGATAGTTTACGTAGGACATCGATG-AATTCGAGCTCG-3'; kar3
1,
5'-AAATAAAGGACTTAGAGAAATTCTGGCAACTATTAAACTATGCGTACGCTG-CAGGTCGAC-3' and
5'-GTCTCTGTCATTTGTCAAAGGAGTGAAAAAGACCAGA-AAAGGCATCGATGAATTCGAGCTCG-3'; kar9
1,
5'-GTCTGTACAAGCCTTAAAGATTTCAGTAGCACTGCCATGCGTACGCTGCA-GGTCGAC-3' and 5'-TATAAAAATGTATAACTATACAGTTTTAGGTTAGTATCACATCGATGAATTCGAGCTC-3'; num1
1,
5'-ATGTCCCACAACAACAGGCATAAAAAGAATAACGATAAAGACAGCGGTCGACGGATCCCCGGG-3' and
5'-CTATCGTAAATTGCCAAATGATCGGCTTTGTGGTACTCTATGTCTTACATCGATGAATTCGAGCTCG-3'; bud8
1,
5'-CCAATATCCTCTTTCTACTTGAGAATTTTTTCGATTCTACATGAAGTGGTCGACGGATCCCCG-GG3' and
5'-AGTTTTTTATTTTTTATCCTATTTGATGAATGAT-ACAGTTTCTTATTCCATCGATGAATTCGAGCTCG-3'; she1
1,
5-AATTCTAAAACACAAAAAAACAAAAAAAATCCTATAACCAGTTCTCCCGCGGTCGACGGATCCCCGGG-3' and
5'-AGGATATA-TGTATATATACATATATACATATATGGGCGTATATTTACTTTGC-ATCGATGAATTCGAGCTCG-3'; yeb1
1,
5'-AGGCAGACTCAAA-AGCAAGGATAATATTCCACCAAATCAGGGACGAAGGGTCGA-CGGATCCCCGGG-3' and
5'-ATAATACATATTCGAAAACAAT-ACTGCTTTTTAGTTCTCAACTTAAAACATCGATGAATTCGAGC-TCG-3'; cln3-1,
5'-ATTCTACCGTTCACAAGAATTGGAAACCA-TGTACAATACTATCTTTGCTCAGTAAAAAGTGGAACGATCATT-CA-3' and
5'-GTGATGCAGAGTCTGGGGTCGTCATTGAACTTGA-A-GTCTTGTAAGGGGAACATCGATGAATTCGAGCTCG-3'; and cln3
1,
5'-AAGACACTGATTTGATACGCTTTCTGTACGATGGCC-ATATTGAAGGATACGCTTCGTACGCTGCAGGTCG-3' and
5'ATTTATTTGTTGTTAAATGCATTTTTTTTTTGTCGTTTCAGCGAG-TTTTCCATCGATGAATTCGAGCTCG-3'.
C-terminal fusion of the S65T variant of green fluorescent protein
(GFP) to Hhf2 (histone H4) was performed as described by Wach et
al. (1997)
. This label was used in one copy in diploid strains.
Growth rate and morphology of these strains were indistinguishable from
those of wild type. A slight growth rate reduction could be observed in
haploid strains. The haploid strains carrying the HHF2::GFPHis3MX6 label in addition to other
genetic alterations were obtained by crossing DHY31 with the
corresponding strains that were histidine prototrophic followed
by sporulation and tetrad dissection. Selected strains that showed
Hhf2-GFP fluorescence were prototrophic for histidine. We did not
determine in each case whether these strains carried in addition the
S. cerevisiae wild-type HIS3 allele or the mutant
HIS3
200 allele.
We integrated a GFP (N-terminal fusion)-labeled copy of the TUB1 gene
under control of the endogenous promoter into the URA3 locus as
described by Straight et al. (1997)
using plasmid pAFS125. Spindle and astral microtubules were clearly observable under the
fluorescence microscope upon successful transformation. The suitability
of this label for in vivo studies has already been demonstrated
(Straight et al., 1997
).
C-terminal fusion of the S65T variant of GFP to Spc72 was performed as
described by Wach et al. (1997)
. The label was shown to be
functional because it fully complemented the deletion phenotype and was
generated by the use of the following oligonucleotide pair: SPC72-GFP,
5'-AGAGTGACTGAGTGTTACATTAAATATATTTATATATAAACGTATATATCATCGATGAATTCGAGCTCG-3' and
5'-GAGTCATTGAGATCGAAACTTTTCAACCTATCAATCAACA-ATCCCGGTCGACGGATCCCCGGG-3'.
The cln3-1 mutant was generated by deleting the last 76 codons of the CLN3 gene and introducing a stop codon,
thereby recreating the original cln3-1 mutation (Cross, 1988
). To allow
for correct termination of transcription we fused the terminator region
of the HA tag of pYM3-klTRP1 (Knop et al., 1999
) after the
stop codon.
Generation of double mutants was achieved either by crossing of the single mutants followed by sporulation and dissection of the four-spored asci or by serial gene deletion using the kanMX4/His3MX6 with the klTRP1 cassette. Spore colonies were checked for GFP fluorescence visually and for presence of the corresponding deletion by analytical PCR.
Video Microscopy Setup
The video microscopy setup consisted of an Axioplan 2 microscope (Carl Zeiss, Feldbach, Switzerland), equipped with a 75W/XBO epifluorescence illumination source, a motorized stage, a Plan-Neofluar 100×, 1.3 oil PH3 objective, and a 2× camera magnification lens. HiQ FITC, DAPI, and TRITC filter sets were used (Chroma Technology, Brattleboro, VT). Because the spectrum of an XBO lamp shows a considerable emission in the infrared range, we doubled the normal heat absorption and reflection filters in the microscope to protect the specimen. Fluorescence excitation was controlled by a shutter controller in combination with a MAC2000 shutter system (Ludl controller MAC 2000; Ludl Electronics, Hawthorne, NY). We used a TE/CCD-1000PB back-illuminated cooled charge-coupled device camera mounted on the primary port and used in combination with the ST-133 controller (Princeton Instruments, Trenton, NJ).
Fluorescence Microscopy Procedures and Techniques
For in vivo time-lapse studies Hhf2-GFP- or GFP-Tub1-labeled strains were grown in YPD medium to early logarithmic phase. One milliliter of the culture was transferred to a reaction tube, pelleted, and resuspended in 1 ml of fresh YPD. Three microliters were then placed on top of the agarose surface of a ground well microscopy slide (Huber, Reinach, Switzerland). This had been prepared by placing a drop of hot growth medium (SD complete medium plus 1.7% agarose) onto the slide and covering it with a coverslip. To enrich the growth medium with oxygen, it had been vigorously vortexed before. As soon as the medium was solid, the coverslip was carefully pushed sideward, resulting in a very smooth agarose surface. Cells were placed on top and covered by another coverslip that was sealed to allow for long investigation times without liquid loss. Steady growth rates were observed until the whole layer was covered with a thin layer of cells up to 3 d later.
For DAPI staining, yeast cells were grown in YPD to early log phase. Approximately 5 × 107 cells were pelleted, resuspended in 50 µl of dH2O, and fixed for 5 min by addition of 1 ml of 70% ethanol. One microliter of a 1 mg/ml DAPI stock solution was added, and the suspension was incubated for 1 min at room temperature. Cells were subsequently washed twice in dH2O and mounted on a poly-L-lysine-treated slide for microscopy.
For visualization of bud and birth scars, cells were grown in YPD to early log phase. Approximately 5 × 107 cells were pelleted, washed with 1 ml of dH2O, resuspended in 100 µl of a 1 mg/ml calcofluor (fluorescence brightener; Sigma-Aldrich, Deisenhofen, Germany) solution, and incubated for 5 min at room temperature. Cells were washed in 1 ml of dH2O, pelleted, and resuspended in 50 µl of dH2O. Approximately 4 µl were mounted on a poly-L-lysine-treated slide for microscopy.
Membranes were stained using 1,1-dioctadecyl-3,3,3',3'-tetramethyl-indocarbocyanine perchlorate (DiI; Fluka, Buchs, Switzerland). Cells were grown in YPD to early log phase. Approximately 5 × 107 cells were pelleted, washed three times in 1 ml of dH2O, and resuspended in 0.5 ml of dH2O, and 1.5 µl of a 1 mg/ml DiI solution were added. After 5 min of incubation at room temperature, cells were washed twice in 1 ml of dH2O and finally resuspended in 50 µl of dH2O. Approximately 4 µl were mounted on a poly-L-lysine-treated slide for microscopy.
Image Acquisition and Picture Processing
The microscope, camera, and fluorescence shutter were controlled by Metamorph 3.51 software (Universal Imaging, West Chester, PA). General Hhf2-GFP acquisition settings were 1-min interval time, 0.1-s exposure time, 3% illumination transmission/, one z-axis plane, and no binning. General GFP-Tub1 acquisition settings were 2-min interval time, 0.4-s exposure time, 50% illumination transmission, three z-axis planes spaced by 0.8 µm, and 2 × 2 binning. Using these conditions cells showed steady growth for >72 h. Nuclear and microtubule dynamics of individual cells could be tracked for more than eight divisions. Acquisition settings for the short GFP-Tub1 or Spc72-GFP studies were 15-s interval time, 1-s exposure time, 100% illumination transmission, three z-axis planes spaced by 0.8 µm, and no binning. The temperature of immersion oil on the microscopy slide near the sample was ~24°C. The z-axis stacks were merged into one plane using the "stack arithmetic: maximum" command of Metamorph. The stored images were then scaled and converted to 8-bit files. A red look-up table was assigned to the phase-contrast image, and a green look-up table was assigned for the fluorescence image. The phase-contrast and fluorescence 8-bit planes were then overlaid using the built-in "Overlay" command with the default balance. For time-lapse analysis we then assembled the picture files to a movie in QuickTime format (Apple Computer, Cupertino, CA) with a frame rate of 10 frames per second using the Premiere 4.2 program (Adobe Systems Europe, Edinburgh, Scotland).
| |
RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Nuclear Segregation in cnm67
Cells Depends on Correctly
Positioned Nuclei and Oriented Spindles
The dynamic behavior of nuclear migration was assessed by in vivo
time-lapse fluorescence microscopy of cells carrying a bright nuclear
Hhf2-GFP label (GFP fused to histone H4), which we had previously
introduced (Wach et al., 1997
). This label colocalized with
the conventional DAPI staining of nuclei. We developed a mounting
procedure (see MATERIALS AND METHODS) that supported cell growth on
microscopy slides over many generations. Using this procedure the
analysis of nuclear dynamics in a large number of consecutive cell
cycles became possible.
We compared distinct steps of nuclear migration between diploid
wild-type and cnm67
mutant cells: nuclear positioning
(movement of the nucleus to the bud neck before anaphase), nuclear
orientation during anaphase (alignment of the elongating nucleus along
the mother-bud axis, equivalent to spindle orientation; see below), insertion of the anaphase nucleus into the bud neck (equivalent to
spindle insertion), fast and slow nuclear elongation (equivalent to
fast and slow spindle elongation, as described by Yeh et
al., 1995
), separation into two nuclei, and postanaphase
movements. Each of 120 observed wild-type cell cycles displayed these
nuclear dynamic steps in a very similar mode with the exception of
occasionally delayed mitoses (Movie 1). A representative example is
shown in Figure 1, which also indicates
that completion of cell separation can be monitored by rotational
movement of the daughter relative to the mother cell. Time-lapse
studies of 325 cnm67
mutant cell cycles revealed
characteristic alterations in some nuclear migration phases, leading to
bi- and multinucleate cells within a few generations (Movie 2), with
representative examples shown in Figure
2. We first describe our analyses of
nuclear dynamics in single nucleate cells; the fate of multinucleate
cells and empty buds will be discussed in later sections.
|
|
A quantitative evaluation revealed that correct nuclear positioning of
the preanaphase nucleus was accomplished in 73% of cnm67
mutant cells and that 75% of all mutant cells elongated the nucleus
along the mother-daughter axis. Only 13.5% of cnm67
cells showed early insertion of the anaphase nucleus into the bud neck,
whereas this was always the case for wild-type cells. Hence elongation
of the anaphase nucleus was usually limited to the mother cell in
cnm67
mutants. Rapid oscillations and bending of the
elongated nucleus typical for anaphase in wild-type cells were
completely absent in the mutant, indicating weakened forces acting on
the nuclei at this cell cycle stage.
The analyses of pedigrees also allowed us to answer the question
of which degree failed nuclear positioning or spindle misorientation influenced distribution of nuclei between mother and daughter cells. If
the preanaphase nucleus was positioned close to the bud neck,
successful nuclear migration was achieved in most cnm67
cells, although it was often delayed. A failure in nuclear positioning to the bud neck resulted in a high rate of nuclear mis-segregation leading to binucleate mother cells and anucleate buds. Data are summarized in Table 2. If the spindle had
been aligned along the mother-bud axis, almost all mutant cells showed
a successful nuclear migration. If the spindle had been misaligned,
only few cells succeeded in directing a nucleus into the daughter
cells. Data are summarized in Table 3. In
conclusion, successful nuclear migration in cnm67
cells
was dependent on the correct execution of early nuclear migration steps
such as nuclear positioning and spindle orientation.
|
|
Astral Microtubules Detach in cnm67
Cells after SPB Duplication
Nuclear migration is achieved by forces acting on the nucleus via
astral microtubules (Huffaker et al., 1988
; Sullivan and Huffaker, 1992
; Carminati and Stearns, 1997
; Shaw et al.,
1997
). Therefore, it was important to investigate whether the observed nuclear segregation phenotype in cnm67
could be explained
by changes in astral microtubule dynamics. Using a GFP-Tub1 fusion (Straight et al., 1997
), we constructed diploid wild-type
and cnm67
cells with fluorescently labeled microtubules.
We monitored astral microtubules by time-lapse studies over several
generations (Movies 3 and 4) and additionally by acquisition of still
images of live cells from log phase cultures (Figures
3 and 4).
Morphology and dynamics of the astral microtubule arrays early in the
cell cycle (G1 and early S phase) were similar in wild-type and
cnm67
mutant cells (Movies 3 and 4; Figures 3A and 4A).
For this phase we could confirm in wild-type and mutant cells the
previously described search-and-capture mechanism of astral
microtubules making contact with the nascent bud, followed by
interaction of microtubule bundles with the bud cortex and movement of
the nucleus toward the bud neck (Shaw et al., 1997
).
|
|
After the onset of SPB separation and the formation of a thick, short
spindle, microtubules detached from the SPB in all 56 analyzed
cnm67
cells (Movie 4; Figure 4, B and C). In 47% of the
cases this was accompanied by a slight movement of the nucleus away
from the bud neck. The microtubules that were detached from the SPB
still interacted with the bud-cortex in a manner that had been
described as a "sweeping mechanism" (Carminati and Stearns, 1997
).
We observed that the tip of a microtubule touched the cortex, moved
back and forth, and started to align along the bud cortex. This
resulted in the translocation of the entire microtubule into the bud.
Detached astral microtubules in the bud appeared to be very stable.
Detachment of microtubules occurred from both SPBs, but we observed a
five times higher detachment frequency from the SPB destined for the
bud. The formation of new astral microtubules at the SPBs could be
observed in all cnm67
cells, which detached again in 87%
of the cells. A higher resolution of this detachment process, 15 s
instead of 2 min, can be viewed in Movies 5 and 6, with 12 representative frames of Movie 5 depicted in Figure 5. In wild-type cells we never observed
detachment of astral microtubules, and such an event has not been
reported in previous studies focusing on astral microtubule dynamics
(Carminati and Stearns, 1997
; Shaw et al., 1997
).
|
The ends of astral microtubules at the SPB are capped by the
-tubulin binding complex, which is anchored by Spc72 to the half-bridge or bridge and the SPB outer plaque (Knop and Schiebel, 1998
, Pereira et al., 1999
). In wild-type cells, an
Spc72-GFP fusion protein exclusively localizes to the SPBs (Soues and
Adams, 1998
). We monitored the localization of an Spc72-GFP fusion
protein in a total of 100 cnm67
cells. In G1 cells
Spc72-GFP exclusively localized to the SPB as in small budded cells
with just separated SPBs (Figure
6A). After further separation of the
SPBs, we detected additional spots of Spc72-GFP clearly separated from
the nuclear periphery (Figure 6B). In time-lapse experiments we
observed that these new Spc72-GFP spots detached from the SPBs,
displayed straight movement into the bud, and moved along the bud
cortex with kinetics very similar to that described above for detached
microtubules. One representative example of Spc72-GFP loss observed at
high time resolution is shown in Movie 7.
|
Our observations suggest that microtubules including Spc72
and thus the
-tubulin complex detach from the SPBs after SPB
separation. The presence of the
-tubulin complex at one end of
detached microtubules is also supported by the observed stability of
these microtubules, as apparent in Movies 4-6. The observed time point
of detachment, after the onset of SPB separation, allows the conclusion
to be drawn that astral microtubule-directed forces on the nucleus are most likely absent or at least severely impaired in later phases of
cell cycles in cnm67
cells.
Synthetic Effects in cnm67
Double Mutants
Dynein and three kinesin-related proteins have been
identified in S. cerevisiae as motor proteins exerting
forces on the nucleus via astral microtubules (Meluh and Rose, 1990
;
Eshel et al., 1993
; Li et al., 1993
; Carminati
and Stearns, 1997
; Cottingham et al., 1997
, DeZwaan et
al., 1997
; Saunders et al., 1997
; Miller et
al., 1998
). To determine which of these motor proteins is
essential or important for the observed remaining nuclear segregation
in cells lacking the SPB outer plaque, we deleted genes encoding these
motors in a cnm67
background. None of the double
deletions was lethal, indicating that, as in wild-type cells, none of
the four motors is essential. As a measure of a change in nuclear migration failure in the double mutants compared with the
cnm67
single mutant, we determined the frequency of bi-
and multinucleate cells in log phase cultures and investigated growth
on solid media. Data are summarized in Table
4.
|
Loss of Dhc1, the large subunit of dynein, in a cnm67
background only caused a marginal change in the frequency of bi- and multinucleate cells, and we did not observe differences in growth compared with the cnm67
single mutant. Initial time-lapse
analyzes of dhc1
cnm67
cells did not point
toward differences in nuclear migration or frequency of microtubule
detachment compared with cnm67
cells (our unpublished
results). This result is on one hand expected because dynein acts late
in nuclear migration (Carminati and Stearns, 1997
; Cottingham and Hoyt,
1997
) after the time point of astral microtubule detachment. On the
other hand, it also shows that the process of detachment is dynein
independent. Loss of the kinesin-related proteins Kip3 or Kar3 in a
cnm67
mutant background increased the frequency of bi-
and multinucleate cells by 20 and 24%, respectively, and led to
severely reduced growth compared with the cnm67
single
mutant. This enhanced failure rate in nuclear migration is not
unexpected, because Kip3 and Kar3 have been suggested to function early
in the cell cycle in nuclear positioning and spindle orientation
(Cottingham and Hoyt, 1997
; DeZwaan et al., 1997
). Indeed,
in initial time-lapse studies of kar3
cnm67
cells, we observed a high portion of cells that failed to localize the nucleus near the bud neck before anaphase B and that did not correctly align the spindle (our unpublished results). In addition, these movies
showed that astral microtubule detachment was similar to the single
mutant. An interesting case is the kinesin-related protein Kip2, which
was described as counteracting force to Kip3 and also Dhc1 with the
potential of moving the nucleus from the bud neck back into the mother
cell (Cottingham and Hoyt, 1997
; Huyett et al., 1998
). Not
unexpectedly, loss of Kip2 in the cnm67
background
resulted in a significant improvement of nuclear migration (24% less
bi- and multinucleate cells) and to improved growth compared with the
cnm67
single mutant.
To generate forces on the nucleus, the distal ends of astral
microtubules have to interact with the bud cortex or the mother cell
cortex, respectively (Carminati and Stearns, 1997
). Kar9 has been
suggested to mediate astral microtubule-cortex interactions in the bud
and Num1 in the mother cell (Farkasovsky and Kuntzel, 1995
; Miller and
Rose, 1998
). This implies that loss of Kar9 may impair pulling forces
acting on the nucleus toward the bud, and loss of Num1 may impair those
acting in the opposite direction. We deleted KAR9 or
NUM1 in a cnm67
background and determined the
frequency of bi- and multinucleate cells as well as growth on solid
media. Data are summarized in Table 4, revealing for kar9
cnm67
cells an increase in bi- and multinucleate cells and reduced growth compared with cnm67
. In contrast,
num1
cnm67
mutants showed improved nuclear
migration (23% less bi- and multinucleate cells) and concomitantly
improved growth very similar to those in kip2
cnm67
cells.
Spindle Elongation Provides the Pushing Force for Nuclear Transfer
in cnm67
Cells
In cnm67
cells transit of a nucleus through
the bud neck mostly occurred after detachment of astral microtubules.
This raised the question of how the forces for bud neck penetration
were established. Analysis of our time-lapse data revealed that, unlike
in wild-type, initial spindle elongation in cnm67
mutants
was mostly restricted to mother cells (Movies 2 and 4). Only when the
spindle was as long as the diameter of the mother cell and continuing
to elongate could we observe transit of one SPB through the bud neck.
Successful insertion of a nucleus during this process was dependent on
the correct orientation of the elongating spindle, as depicted in Table
3. The potential of spindle dynamics to generate pushing forces became
apparent in cases in which the spindle was misaligned: it continued to
elongate despite spatial constrictions by the mother cell, resulting in
bent spindles. We observed bent spindles aligned along the cortex with
>1.5 times the length of the mother cell diameter (Movie 4). The
dependence of successful nuclear segregation on the pushing forces of
elongating spindles was supported by the observation that in 56 cnm67
divisions we never observed transit of a nucleus
through the bud neck after spindle disassembly.
We also addressed the question of whether spindle dynamics are
influenced by loss of the Cnm67 protein. We measured spindle dynamics
by two methods: directly in GFP-Tub1-labeled cells and indirectly by
the kinetics of chromatin separation as visualized by Hhf2-GFP. In
Hhf2-GFP-labeled cells the round-shaped nucleus became bar shaped
during spindle elongation (Figure 1, 61 min) and elongated further,
adapting a typical hourglass-like shape (Figure 1, 66 min) before the
chromosomal masses were focused into two spherical structures with very
similar GFP intensities (Figure 1, 69 min). We compared the length of
these distinct elongated nuclear shapes and the dynamics of their
formation in wild-type and cnm67
cells (Table
5). In both strains we measured very similar parameters. In addition, from the onset of anaphase to final
spindle disassembly (apparent in GFP-Tub1-labeled cells of Movies 3 and 4), we measured similar time intervals and maximal spindle lengths
in both strains.
|
In summary, our data support the notion that unaltered spindle
elongation dynamics contribute the main force for transit of one
nucleus through the bud neck in cnm67
cells.
Consequences of Failed Nuclear Migrations
cnm67
cells that failed to direct one nucleus into
the growing bud did not show a permanent growth arrest but initiated a new cell cycle, as seen by new bud emergence, SPB duplication, and
spindle assembly. Multiple nuclei in cnm67
cells
underwent simultaneous mitotic divisions in the next cell cycle (Figure 2, 348 min; Movies 2 and 4). This led to a large number of cells that
carried more than two nuclei, as depicted in Table 4. Transfer of more
than one nucleus into the new bud was not observed in cnm67
cells (n = 325). Interestingly, deposition of
a nucleus into a still attached anucleate bud of a previous cell cycle
was also not detected (n = 325). In addition, we detected no
transfer of detached microtubules or Spc72-GFP into a bud of a previous cell cycle. cnm67
cells with >12 nuclei were observed
giving rise to single nucleate daughter cells that followed mutant
characteristics described above.
We were also able to follow cell separation in wild-type and
cnm67
cells, which was apparent by a sudden change in the
position of the bud relative to that of the mother cell (Figures 1 and 2; Movies 1-4). In wild-type and cnm67
cells separation
of nucleate buds promptly occurred ~30 min after entry of the nucleus
into the bud. However, we never observed separation of anucleate buds in cnm67
cells (Figure 2, 192-558 min, cell A, 354-558
min cell B, Movie 2 and 4). The process of cytokinesis and separation
of new daughter cells did not change the attachment of anucleate buds
generated in previous cell cycles as concluded from unchanged positions
of these buds relative to the mother cell (Figure 2, 354-384 min cell
A, 498-558 min, cell B, Movies 2 and 4). Our observations point toward
a link between successful nuclear migration and cell separation in
cnm67
mutants.
The First Nuclear Segregation of a Diploid cnm67
Daughter Cell
Is Always Successful
One striking observation during analyzes of consecutive cell cycles revealed that the first nuclear migration of a newborn daughter cell was always successful (n = 768) (Figure 2, cells B and C; Movies 2 and 4). To our knowledge this phenomenon has not been described previously. It did not depend on 1) the number of nuclei in the mother, 2) astral microtubule detachment, or 3) the age of the mother that had generated a daughter cell.
We investigated the involvement of other known
mother-daughter-specific differences such as bud site selection or
cell size in generating the observed mother-daughter-specific division
characteristic in cnm67
cells. It was shown that the
first bud emergence of a diploid daughter cell usually occurs distally
from the birth scar, whereas later mother cell divisions follow a
bipolar pattern (Freifelder, 1960
; Chant and Pringle, 1995
). The distal
pole of a daughter cell is usually the region where the nucleus is
positioned by the spindle elongation process during the previous cell
cycle. Hence a distal first bud emergence might facilitate nuclear
positioning in cnm67
cells. We investigated whether the
high fidelity of first daughter nuclear migration events decreased in
cells with a first proximal bud emergence. Mutation of BUD8
was previously shown to lead to a proximal budding pattern in diploid
cells (Zahner et al., 1996
). We deleted both BUD8
alleles of a diploid homozygous cnm67
mutant. Of 67 first
proximal daughter divisions analyzed by time-lapse microscopy,
we never observed nuclear segregation failure. In addition, growth on
solid medium and the number of multinucleate cells in log phase
cultures did not suggest a worsening of the nuclear migration defect
(our unpublished results). Thus the high fidelity of nuclear migration
during the first division of a diploid daughter cell was not directly
linked to distal first bud emergence.
Another general mother-daughter difference consisted of the size of
the cells. We tested whether the high fidelity in first nuclear
segregations of daughter cells was linked to their smaller cell size.
We deleted the CLN3 gene in a cnm67
background. It has been shown that lack of this cyclin delays START
(Nash et al., 1988
). Therefore, daughter cells have more
time to grow and reach larger cell sizes before they enter the first
cell cycle. Measuring the size of daughter cells in the
cnm67
cln3
background indeed revealed
larger-daughter cell size at the time of the first bud emergence (6.7 µm;
= 0.42; n = 25) compared with cnm67
daughter cells (5.3 µm;
= 0.44; n = 30). Although
cnm67
cln3
daughter cells were even bigger
than cnm67
mother cells (5.6 µm;
= 0.42;
n = 30), all 42 first daughter cell divisions observed by
time-lapse microscopy were successful. Growth on solid medium and the
number of bi- and multinucleate cells in log phase cultures was similar
to cnm67
single mutants (our unpublished results). In
addition, we created a cln3-1 mutant (Cross, 1988
) in a
cnm67
deletion background. This truncated form of the
Cln3 protein lacks the C-terminal destruction box, and the high
cellular levels of Cln3 protein promoted early START (Cross, 1988
),
leading to a smaller daughter cell size at the moment of the first bud
emergence (4.9 µm;
= 0.42; n = 25). Although daughter
cells still showed a successful first division (n = 48), nuclear
migration in mother cells failed with the normal cnm67
frequency, although cln3-1 cnm67
mother cells were
smaller (5.4 µm;
= 0.44; n = 25) than cnm67
daughter cells. Our time-lapse data were consistent
with the nuclear segregation defect as determined for log phase
cultures and the growth on solid medium (our unpublished results). Our observations did not point to a direct link between cell size and the
site of the first bud emergence or the high fidelity of first nuclear
migrations in daughter cells.
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In this study we investigated the underlying mechanism for failed
and successful nuclear migration in cells lacking the SPB outer
plaques. Our observation of nuclear and astral microtubule dynamics
suggested that the main and primary reason for most phenotypic changes
in nuclear migration in cnm67
cells was a cell
cycle-dependent detachment of astral microtubules from the SPB after
onset of SPB separation. This led to a decrease or lack of forces
acting on the nucleus at a critical phase of the cell cycle, resulting in a failure of early insertion of anaphase spindles into the bud
necks, complete lack of rapid spindle oscillations, spindle misorientations, and, consequently, failed nuclear migrations. Successful nuclear migration in cnm67
cells was achieved
only when the preanaphase nucleus was positioned near the bud neck and
the spindle was correctly aligned early in the cell cycle before astral
microtubule detachment. In such cells, the elongating spindle often
still pointed into the bud when astral microtubule detachment was
observed. Further elongation of the spindle forced the insertion of one
SPB into the bud, which led to successful nuclear migration. This
remaining ability to properly orient the spindle in a substantial
number of cnm67
cells is essential for viability. Cells
that are unable to orient the spindle because of complete lack of
astral microtubules, as in tub2-104 mutants (Huffaker
et al., 1988
) or cnm67
kar1
mutants (Pereira et al., 1999
), are inviable despite the
presence of a functional spindle.
Astral microtubule detachment in cnm67
cells started at a
cell cycle stage at which a major astral microtubule reorganization occurs, as already described in the pioneering work by Byers and Goetsch (1975)
: in wild-type cells with duplicated but
unseparated SPBs, long astral microtubules emanate from the bridge, and
after SPB separation astral microtubules are organized by the SPB outer plaque. Astral microtubules are anchored to these distinct SPB substructures via Spc72 (Knop and Schiebel, 1998
; Pereira et
al., 1999
) that binds the
-tubulin complex, which is necessary
for nucleation of microtubules (Sobel and Snyder, 1995
; Marshall
et al., 1996
; Knop and Schiebel, 1998
; Soues and Adams,
1998
). The half-bridge-specific protein Kar1 (Spang et al.,
1995
) was shown to bind Spc72 and is thus viewed as the anchor site for
cytoplasmic microtubules at the half-bridge (Pereira et al.,
1999
). The Spc72-interacting protein at the SPB outer plaque is not yet
known, although localization of Spc72 to the outer plaque has been
shown (Soues and Adams, 1998
). We observed that upon SPB separation in
cnm67
cells astral microtubules detached concomitantly
with Spc72-GFP. This suggests that intact microtubules, still carrying
-tubulin caps plus Spc72, detach from the SPB. In addition, astral
microtubule detachment was not blocked or decreased in
cnm67
double mutants deleted for astral microtubule
motors. These observations imply a release of intact astral
microtubules rather than rupture or breakage exerted by external
forces. In the context of our observations and the reported cell
cycle-dependent change in astral microtubule organization (Byers and
Goetsch, 1975
), it is conceivable that astral microtubules switch upon
SPB separation from the half-bridge to the SPB outer plaque, where they
are organized for the rest of the cell cycle. In cnm67
cells half-bridge-released microtubules fail to be anchored to the
region of the missing outer plaque and detach.
Switching of astral microtubules might by accomplished by altered
affinity of Spc72 to the half-bridge or the outer plaque. Consistent
with the idea of Spc72 being involved in switching of microtubules,
Pereira et al. (1999)
could show that in cells with an
Spc72-Kar1 fusion astral microtubules were restricted to the
half-bridge throughout the cell cycle and that accumulation of
binucleated cells did not occur even in the absence of the Cnm67
protein. Apparently, astral microtubules that are stably anchored at
the half-bridge throughout the cell cycle are able to fulfill all
mitotic functions, which raises the intriguing question about the
biological relevance of the cell cycle-dependent change in astral
microtubule organization in S. cerevisiae.
Long-term time-lapse investigations allowed pedigree analysis of
cnm67
cells. This revealed a successful first mitosis of all diploid, single-nucleate daughter cells, whereas later divisions of
the same cells often failed. We observed the same characteristic in a
different SPB mutant also affecting nuclear migration (our unpublished
results). This points toward a general mother-daughter difference in nuclear migration rather than a
cnm67
-specific characteristic. One known general
mother-daughter difference consists of the identity of S. cerevisiae mother and daughter cells because of the asymmetric
distribution of the transcriptional regulator Ash1, a repressor of the
HO endonuclease gene (Bobola et al., 1996
). She1 is a myosin
involved in establishing the asymmetric distribution of Ash1 between
mother and daughter cell (Bobola et al., 1996
). We tested
whether She1 was also involved in transport of daughter cell-specific
products that influence nuclear migration. Loss of She1 in a
cnm67
mutant background, however, did not alter the
daughter fidelity phenotype of cnm67
mutants (our
unpublished results). Another general mother-daughter difference
concerns cell size. Daughter cells are smaller than mother cells at the time of their first bud emergence. Smaller cell size might facilitate force generation by spindle elongation, increase the chance of penetrating the bud neck because of smaller cell-surface, and facilitate astral microtubule-cortex interactions. However, we observed
no effect on nuclear migration by altering the size of cnm67
daughter and mother cells. A third general
difference between mother and daughter cells consists of bud site
selection. Daughter cells produce the first bud from the distal pole,
whereas mother cells have a bipolar bud site selection (Freifelder,
1960
, Chant and Pringle, 1995
). Distal bud site selection may
facilitate nuclear positioning, because spindle elongation of the
previous cell cycle deposits the nucleus in the daughter cell near the
region where the new bud is produced. But the high fidelity of first
daughter divisions was not directly linked to a general first distal
bud site selection in daughter cells, as shown in homozygous diploid bud8
cnm67
mutants in this study. Changes
of these three parameters, cell size, mating-type asymmetry, and first
distal bud site selection, did not affect the high fidelity in nuclear
migration of daughter cells. Our observations with cnm67
are reminiscent of the bud1
, bud
2, and bud5
mutant phenotypes
(Chant and Herskowitz, 1991
). In mutants deleted for any of
those genes the budding pattern is randomized except for the first
division of a daughter cell, which maintains a first distal bud
emergence. It appears conceivable that during bud emergence, bud
growth, and later cytokinesis, cortical landmarks or cytoskeletal
arrangements are positioned in the daughter by the mother cell, which
by default are used by the daughter cell during its first cell cycle.
Similarly, maternal effects have been described in other organisms,
e.g., during the oogenesis in Drosophila in which mRNA
gradients are established, defining anterior and posterior poles
(Nusslein-Vollhard, 1996
). Other ways of generating
mother-daughter cell asymmetries can be generated by genomic
imprinting and have been proposed to exist in yeast (Jiang and
Stillman, 1996
).
Our time-lapse studies of cnm67
mutants indicated
that cytokinesis depends on successful nuclear migration. The time
required from entry of the nucleus into the bud until completion of
cytokinesis was the same for wild-type and mutants. This indicated that
the cell separation process itself was not affected by Cnm67 loss. The
observed lack of separation of anucleate buds in cnm67
cells suggests that the nucleus carries a cytokinesis-triggering
signal. Recently, a putative cytokinesis checkpoint involving the
Yeb1/Bim1 protein was postulated (Schwartz et al., 1997
;
Muhua et al., 1998
). Loss of Yeb1 in the act5
nuclear migration mutant allowed separation of anucleate buds (Muhua
et al., 1998
). When we introduced the yeb1
deletion in a cnm67
background, we also saw separation of
anucleate buds in time-lapse studies (our unpublished results). Although separation of anucleate buds in cnm67
yeb1
cells did not occur in all cases, we were able to
visualize septa separating empty buds from the mother cells by staining
with DiI (our unpublished results). Such septa were not observed in
cnm67
single mutants. This also suggests that a nucleus
in the bud is not per se a requirement for cytokinesis. Observations of
the ndc1 mutant showed that the transfer of a defective SPB
without any chromosomal material can be sufficient to trigger
cytokinesis (Thomas and Botstein, 1986
). This finding and our
observations that detached
-tubulin-capped microtubules did not
trigger cell separation suggest that the cytokinesis-triggering signal
may be associated with entrance of one (incomplete) SPB into the bud.
| |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
We are grateful to Jürgen Wendland for helpful discussions, Florian Schärer for help setting up the microscope, and Tom Bickle for critical reading of the manuscript. We also thank A.F. Straight for the pAFS125 plasmid. This work was supported by grants from the University of Basel and the Swiss Federal Office for Education and Science (grants 95.0191-12 and 97.0537-1).
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Online version of this article contains video material
for Figures 1-7. Online version available at www.molbiolcell.org.
* Corresponding author. E-mail address: Peter.Philippsen{at}unibas.ch.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-galactosidase selection.
Biotechniques
5, 376-378.