|
|
|
|
Vol. 13, Issue 12, 4414-4428, December 2002


and
Institute of *Biochemistry, and
Food-Chemistry and
Technology, Graz University of Technology, A-8010 Graz, Austria,
and §Department of Medicine, Division of Biochemistry,
University of Fribourg, CH-1700 Fribourg, Switzerland
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Fungal sphingolipids contain ceramide with a very-long-chain fatty
acid (C26). To investigate the physiological significance of the
C26-substitution on this lipid, we performed a screen for mutants that
are synthetically lethal with ELO3. Elo3p is a component of the ER-associated fatty acid elongase and is required for the final
elongation cycle to produce C26 from C22/C24 fatty acids. elo3
mutant cells thus contain C22/C24- instead of
the natural C26-substituted ceramide. We now report that under these
conditions, an otherwise nonessential, but also fungal-specific,
structural modification of the major sterol of yeast, ergosterol,
becomes essential, because mutations in ELO3 are
synthetically lethal with mutations in ERG6. Erg6p
catalyzes the methylation of carbon atom 24 in the aliphatic side chain
of sterol. The lethality of an elo3
erg6
double
mutant is rescued by supplementation with ergosterol but not with
cholesterol, indicating a vital structural requirement for the
ergosterol-specific methyl group. To characterize this structural
requirement in more detail, we generated a strain that is temperature
sensitive for the function of Erg6p in an elo3
mutant
background. Examination of raft association of the GPI-anchored Gas1p
and plasma membrane ATPase, Pma1p, in the conditional elo3
erg6ts double mutant, revealed a specific
defect of the mutant to maintain raft association of preexisting Pma1p.
Interestingly, in an elo3
mutant at 37°C, newly
synthesized Pma1p failed to enter raft domains early in the
biosynthetic pathway, and upon arrival at the plasma membrane was
rerouted to the vacuole for degradation. These observations indicate
that the C26 fatty acid substitution on lipids is important for
establishing raft association of Pma1p and stabilizing the protein at
the cell surface. Analysis of raft lipids in the conditional mutant
strain revealed a selective enrichment of ergosterol in detergent-resistant membrane domains, indicating that specific structural determinants on both sterols and sphingolipids are required
for their association into raft domains.
| |
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Sphingolipids are ceramide-containing lipids that are
highly enriched in the outer leaflet of the plasma membrane, where they exert both structural and signaling functions (for review see Dickson,
1998
; Schneiter, 1999
). In fungi, these lipids are composed of an
inositolphosphate-containing hydrophilic head group bound to
phytoceramide. The mammalian ceramide typically contains saturated acyl
chains ranging from 16 to 24 carbon atoms in length (Gu et al., 1997
). The fungal ceramide, on the other hand,
contains a saturated C26 very-long-chain fatty acid. Synthesis of this
C26 acyl chain occurs by chain elongation of saturated long-chain fatty
acids (C16/C18), a reaction that requires an ER-associated acyl chain
elongation complex. Elo2p and Elo3p are two components of this complex
(Oh et al., 1997
). They are presumed to catalyze the
condensing reaction of the elongation cycle and exhibit slightly different substrate specificities. Although Elo2p elongates C16/C18 fatty acids to C22/C24, Elo3p is specifically required for the final
elongation step from C22/C24 to C26. Cells with mutations in
ELO3 are viable but synthesize ceramide/sphingolipids with C22/C24 instead of the natural C26 fatty acid. Synthesis of the C24/C26
fatty acid is essential as an elo2
elo3
double
mutant is not viable (Oh et al., 1997
). The physiological
significance of this particular fatty acid requirement of the fungal
ceramide is unknown, but it is interesting to note that maturation of
glycerophosphatidylinositol (GPI)-anchored proteins in yeast
involves acyl chain remodeling reactions that serve to introduce a C26
fatty acid into glycolipid protein anchors, suggesting that the
presence of C26 is of functional importance (Sipos et al.,
1997
).
Synthesis of ceramide in mammals and yeast is confined to the ER
membrane; subsequent maturation of ceramide to the more complex sphingolipids occurs upon transport to the Golgi apparatus (Levine et al., 2000
; Funato and Riezman, 2001
). The mature
sphingolipids are then transported to the plasma membrane, where they
are highly enriched, and constitute ~30% of all the
phosphate-containing lipids (Patton and Lester, 1991
; Hechtberger
et al., 1994
). In addition to sphingolipids, the plasma
membrane contains high levels of sterols (Lange et al.,
1989
; Schneiter et al., 1999
). These high levels of sterols
and sphingolipids are generally believed to be important for reducing
the permeability of the outer most membrane, thus protecting the cell
against hostile environmental conditions.
Sterols have a high affinity for lipids containing saturated acyl
chains, particularly ceramide (Sankaram and Thompson, 1990
; Schroeder
et al., 1994
). By restricting acyl chain mobility on ceramide, sterols induce the formation of dispersed liquid ordered phase domains, which are resistant to solubilization by detergents (for
review see Brown and London, 2000
; Rietveld and Simons, 1998
). These
sphingolipid/cholesterol-rich membrane domains have been proposed to
serve as platforms/rafts for the lateral sorting of certain proteins,
particularly for those containing a GPI anchor (Brown and Rose, 1992
;
Simons and Ikonen, 1997
; Muniz and Riezman, 2000
). Sterols and
ceramides are both synthesized in the ER membrane, allowing for a
possible early lipid-dependent segregation of proteins along the
secretory pathway to the plasma membrane (Brown and Rose, 1992
; Bagnat
et al., 2000
).
Sterols are the product of a complex biosynthetic pathway with more
than 20 distinct reactions. The sterol-specific part of this pathway
starts by the condensation of farnesyl pyrophosphate to form squalene
and, in fungi, ends with the synthesis of ergosterol. The early
reactions of this 11-step conversion are essential. They involve
cyclization of squalene to lanosterol and subsequent removal of three
methyl groups. The enzymes that catalyze the last five steps of the
pathway are nonessential. They serve to modify the basic sterol
backbone by introduction of a methyl group at position 24 of the side
chain (ERG6), isomerization of the double bond from position
8 to position 7 (ERG2), introduction of a second double bond
in the B ring (ERG3), introduction of a double bond at
position 22 of the side chain (ERG5), and reduction of the
methylene bond originally present at position 24 (ERG4; see
Figure 1A; for review see Lees et
al., 1999
; Parks et al., 1999
).
|
Just as sphingolipids differ in structure between fungi and mammals, the sterols differ too. Ergosterol is distinct from the mammalian cholesterol by three structural modifications, two in the side chain and one in the B ring. The structure of the plant sterols is intermediate between that of the fungal ergosterol and the mammalian cholesterol. The functional significance of these structural differences, however, is not yet understood (see Figure 1B).
We were interested in investigating the physiological role of the C26
substitution on the fungal ceramide. Using a screen for mutants that
are synthetically lethal with elo3
, genetic conditions
under which the final elongation step from C22/C24 to C26 becomes
essential were generated. One of the mutants isolated in this screen is
defective in the sterol C-24 methyltransferase, ERG6 (Gaber
et al., 1989
). We show here that the interaction between ELO3 and ERG6 is highly specific and affects raft
structures at the plasma membrane, indicating that fungal-specific
lipid modifications in sterols and sphingolipids are codependent and of
functional significance.
| |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Strains and Growth Conditions
Yeast strains used in this study are listed in Table
1. Strains bearing single deletions of
nonessential ERG genes were obtained from EUROSCARF (see
www.rz.uni-frankfurt.de/FB/fb16/mikro/euroscarf/index.html; Winzeler
et al., 1999
). Strains were cultivated at 24, 30, or 37°C
in YPD rich media (1% Bacto yeast extract, 2% Bacto peptone [Difco
Laboratories Inc., Detroit, MI], 2% glucose) or minimal media.
To counterselect for the presence of URA3 containing
plasmids, 5-fluoroorotic acid (5-FOA; bts BioTech Trade and Service
Gmbh, St. Leon-Rot, Germany) was added to solid media at 1 g/l. Media supplemented with sterols contained 5 mg/ml Tween 80 and either 20 µg/ml or 10 ng/ml sterols (Sigma Chemical Co., St. Louis, MO). Sterol
rescue experiments were performed under anaerobic conditions by placing
the plates into an anaerobic jar containing an AnaeroGen sachet (Oxoid
Limited, Hampshire, UK). Plates supplemented with brefeldin A contained
50 µg/ml of the drug. For DNA cloning and propagation of plasmids,
E. coli strain XL1-blue (Stratagene, La Jolla, CA) was used
throughout this study.
|
Plasmid Constructions
To generate the ADE3-containing sectoring plasmid
used for the synthetic lethal screen, ELO3 was amplified by
PCR using the primer pair ELO3RegF2/ELO3RegR (see Table
2 for sequence of oligonucleotides) and
genomic DNA from strain FY1679 as template. The ELO3
fragment was cloned blunt end into the unique SmaI site of
pCH1122 to yield pPS2 (Table 3).
|
|
The kanMX4-containing ELO3 tester plasmid, pPS5,
was generated by cloning the NotI/SacI fragment
harboring the kanMX4 gene from pFA6a (Wach et
al., 1994
) into the corresponding sites of pIBI96
(García-Arranz et al., 1994
).
The ERG6 gene was cloned, after PCR amplification with the
primer pair ERG6RegF/ERG6RegR from genomic DNA, as a
SacI/BamHI fragment into the corresponding sites
of pRS426 (Christianson et al., 1992
) to generate
pRS426-ERG6. The ERG6-containing
SacI/BamHI fragment from pRS426-ERG6 was then
cloned into the corresponding sites of pRS315 (Sikorski and Hieter,
1989
) to generate pME1.
Restriction and ligation of DNA fragments, preparation of plasmid DNA, elution of DNA from low-melt agarose gels and transformation of lithium acetate competent yeast cells was performed according to standard procedures. Enzymes used for DNA manipulations were supplied by MBI Fermentas (St. Leon-Rot, Germany).
Synthetic Lethal Screen
To generate a host strain for the synthetic lethal screen, the
ade2 ade3 parental strain CH1462 was first transformed with pPS2 [ADE3 URA3 ELO3] to render it
HIS3-dependent auxotrophic for histidine (Kranz and Holm,
1990
). The ELO3 gene of this strain was then replaced by the
bacterial his5 gene, amplified with the primer pair
ELO3koF/ELO3koR from pFA6a-His3MX6 (Longtine et al., 1998
),
to generate strain YRS1116. This strain formed red/white colony sectors
on YPD and was used for the synthetic lethal screen using a
transposon-based knockout library (m-Tn3; see
http://ygac.med.yale.edu/; Burns et al., 1994
).
Approximately 40,000 leucine prototrophic transformants were screened
for nonsectoring colonies. Plasmid independence of the nonsectoring
phenotype was then assessed by transformation with pPS5. The site of
transposon insertion was identified using a vectorette PCR protocol
that used the oligonucleotides Bubble-1, -2, and -224, as
described
(http://genome-www.stanford.edu/group/botlab/protocols/vectorette.html). DNA sequencing was performed on an ABI 373A sequencer using the ABI
PRISM BigDye Terminator Cycle Sequencing Ready Reaction Kit with
AmpliTaq DNA Polymerase (PE Perkin Elmer-Cetus, Foster City, CA).
Generation of ERG6 Alleles That Are Temperature Sensitive for Function
To generate a strain in which the synthetic lethal interaction
between ELO3 and ERG6 could be conditionally
imposed, the 3' end of ERG6 was amplified by PCR under error
prone conditions (2.5 mM dGTP instead of the normal 250 µM) using the
primer pair ERG6mutF/ERG6mutR. The 569-base pair fragment was then
cotransformed with NheI/MscI gapped pME1 into
strain YRS1508. One thousand leucine prototrophic colonies were replica
plated on 5-FOA media to force loss of pPS2. Uracil auxotrophic
colonies were screened for temperature-sensitive growth by replica
plating to 37°C. Three plasmids conferring temperature-dependent growth to an elo3
erg6
double mutant were isolated and
subject to sequence analysis. pME1ts#6 was used
for all further studies.
Isolation of Detergent-insoluble Membrane Domains
Detergent-insoluble membrane domains were isolated after
floatation on Optiprep gradients (Axis-Shield, Huntingdon, UK) exactly as described by Bagnat et al. (2000)
. Proteins were
precipitated with TCA (10%), dissolved in sample buffer, and subjected
to SDS-PAGE and Western blot analyses. Raft association of newly
synthesized Pma1p was examined as described by Gong and Chang (2001)
.
Lysates of labeled cells (3-4 OD600 nm
equivalents) were extracted with 1% Triton X-100 for 30 min at 4°C.
Samples were centrifuged at 100,000 × g for 1 h.
Pellets were resuspended in 1% SDS. Detergent concentrations in
aliquots of total, supernatant, and pellet samples were adjusted for immunoprecipitation.
For lipid analysis, cholesterol was added as internal standard, and lipids were extracted using n-heptane. Silylated sterol adducts were then quantified and analyzed by gas chromatography-mass spectroscopy (GC-MS) analysis as described below. Raft association of inositol containing lipids was examined after growing cells in inositol-free media containing 0.1 µCi [3H]myo-inositol (Perkin Elmer-Cetus Life Sciences, Cambridge, UK) for 16 h.
Western blot analyses using rabbit anti-Erg6p or anti-Pma1p (1:10,000;
G. Daum, Graz University of Technology, Austria) or rabbit anti-Gas1p
(1:2000; A. Conzelmann, University of Fribourg, Switzerland) was
performed as described before by Schneiter et al. (1999)
.
Protein Secretion and Maturation
Secretion of invertase was assayed as follows. Cells were grown
in minimal media containing 5% glucose to an OD600
nm of 0.2. Invertase expression was induced by resuspending
the cells in low glucose media (0.05%), and the cultures were
preshifted to 37°C for 15 min. Samples were then removed at the
indicated time points, and cells were metabolically poisoned by the
addition of 10 mM NaN3. Invertase activity of
equal number of cells was determined as described by Goldstein and
Lampen (1975)
. Carboxypeptidase Y and Gas1p maturation was analyzed as
described by Munn et al. (1999)
and quantified using NHI
Image 1.61.
Lipid Analysis
Sterols were isolated as described by Quail and Kelly (1996)
,
using cholesterol as internal standard. GC-MS analysis of silylated sterol adducts was performed on a Hewlett-Packard HP 5890 Series II gas
chromatograph (Palo Alto, CA), equipped with a HP 5972 mass selective
detector, and HP 5-MS column (cross-linked 5% phenyl methyl siloxane;
dimensions: 30 m × 0.25 mm × 0.25 µm film thickness). The
following temperature program was run: 1 min at 100°C, 10°C/min to
250°C, and 3°C/min to 300°C. Sterols were identified based on
their mass fragmentation pattern and by comparison to commercially available standards.
Inositol-containing lipids were labeled by incubating 10 OD of
cells with 30 µCi
[3H]myo-inositol (Perkin
Elmer-Cetus Life Sciences) at either 24 or 37°C for 2 h and
analyzed as described by Reggiori et al. (1997)
. For
analysis of sphingolipid precursors, 10 OD of cells were incubated with
200 µCi [3H]serine (Perkin Elmer-Cetus Life
Sciences) at either 24 or 37°C for 4 h, lipids were extracted
with chloroform/methanol (1:1; vol/vol), and mild-base-resistant
lipids were analyzed by TLC. Mild-base treatment was performed by
incubating lipids in 0.1 M NaOH at 30°C for 1 h.
| |
RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A Synthetic Lethal Screen with elo3
Identifies
Mutations in ERG6
To investigate the physiological function of very-long-chain fatty
acid (C26)-substituted lipids in yeast, we created genetic conditions
under which acyl chain elongation from C22/C24 to C26 becomes
essential. Therefore, a red/white colony sectoring-based visual screen
was performed to identify mutants that are synthetically lethal with
mutations in ELO3. In an initial evaluation of the screening
strategy, a transposon-based knockout library was used to mutagenize
the genome (Burns et al., 1994
). This approach has the
advantage of allowing rapid identification of the mutant loci by a
PCR-based protocol (see MATERIALS AND METHODS). Of ~40,000 colonies
screened, 19 mutations were isolated that could be grouped into 14 complementation groups.
One of the mutants isolated in this screen contained a transposon
insertion in a gene of the ergosterol biosynthetic pathway, ERG6 (unpublished data). Erg6p catalyzes the
methylation at position 24 of zymosterol to form fecosterol (Gaber
et al., 1989
). The synthetic lethality of mutations in
ELO3 and ERG6 was independently confirmed by
crossing of the respective single mutants followed by tetrad analysis
(unpublished data).
The Interaction between ELO3 and ERG6 Is Specific
Mutations in ELO3 and ELO2/FEN1 have
previously been isolated in screens for mutants that are resistant
against the immunosupressor SR31747, an inhibitor of the sterol C-8
isomerase, ERG2 (Silve et al., 1996
). In
addition, mutations in ELO2/FEN1 result in resistance against the fungicide fenpropimorph, an inhibitor of the sterol C-14
reductase, encoded by ERG24 (Ladevèze et
al., 1993
). These ELO-dependent suppressions of
inhibitors of the ergosterol biosynthetic pathway, however, have been
reported only for the FL100 genetic background, in which both
ERG2 and ERG24 are essential. In most other
genetic backgrounds, ERG2 and ERG24 are
nonessential (Crowley et al., 1996
; Winzeler et
al., 1999
).
In light of this apparently complex genetic interaction between
mutations in ELO2/3 and the ergosterol biosynthetic pathway, we first determined whether the synthetic lethal interaction that we
uncovered between ELO3 and ERG6 is specific.
Therefore, an elo3
mutant strain harboring a wild-type
ELO3 gene on an URA3 marked plasmid (pPS2, strain
YRS1247) was crossed to all viable mutants in genes of the ergosterol
biosynthetic pathway, i.e., ERG2, ERG3,
ERG4, ERG5, ERG6, and
ERG24. Viability of the respective double mutant was then
assessed by plasmid loss on media containing 5-FOA. As shown in Figure
2A, this analysis revealed that the mutation in ELO3 is viable with mutations in all the
nonessential ERG genes, except for ERG6,
indicating that the synthetic lethal interaction between mutations in
ELO3 and ERG6 is specific.
|
To determine whether a mutation in ERG6 is synthetically
lethal with other mutations that affect C26 metabolism, we crossed an
elo2
mutant strain to erg6
, bearing a
wild-type ERG6 gene on an URA3-containing
plasmid. Unlike elo3
mutants, cells defective in
ELO2 are still capable of synthesizing the C26
very-long-chain fatty acid, albeit at reduced efficiency (Oh et
al., 1997
). Viability of the resulting elo2
erg6
double mutant was again assessed by plasmid loss on media containing
FOA. As shown in Figure 2B, this analysis revealed that the
elo2
erg6
double mutant is viable, indicating that the
synthetic lethality observed between ELO3 and
ERG6 is specific for both partners of the respective
biosynthetic pathways.
The Viability of an elo3
erg6
Double Mutant Is
Rescued by Ergosterol but not by Cholesterol
Analysis of sterol auxotrophic mutants has revealed distinct
cellular functions of sterols that can be fulfilled by supplementations with different concentrations of sterols. The function of sterols required for membrane integrity, termed the bulk function, requires supplementation with 5 µg/ml ergosterol and is also provided by cholesterol. A second function of ergosterol is required for cell cycle
progression (Dahl et al., 1987
). This sparking function of
ergosterol requires 10 ng/ml ergosterol and is not provided by
cholesterol but has a stringent structural requirement for ergosterol
(Rodriguez and Parks, 1983
).
To determine which of these two essential functions of ergosterol is
affected in the elo3
erg6
double mutant, cells were supplemented with different sterols and grown under anaerobic conditions to allow sterol uptake. Viability of the double mutant was
again assessed by monitoring loss of a plasmid-borne copy of a
wild-type ELO3 or ERG6 gene on media containing
5-FOA. As shown in Figure 3A, the
elo3
erg6
double mutant was rescued on media
supplemented with bulk concentrations of ergosterol. Cholesterol, a
mixture containing bulk concentrations of cholesterol and sparking
concentrations of ergosterol, or sparking concentrations of ergosterol
alone, failed to rescue the double mutant. This observation indicates
that the elo3
erg6
mutant has a stringent requirement
for bulk concentrations of ergosterol that is not provided by
cholesterol and that is not depending on sparking concentrations of
ergosterol.
|
To further define the structural requirements for this bulk
function-dependent rescue of the elo3
erg6
mutant,
viability of this strain was assessed on media supplemented with
various sterol derivatives. As shown in Figure 3B, growth of the double mutant could also be rescued by supplementation with bulk
concentrations of dehydroergosterol
(ergosta-5,7,9(11),22-tetraene-3-ol), a sterol with a third double bond
in the ring system and a methyl group at position 24 of the aliphatic
side chain, as is characteristic for ergosterol. However,
dehydrocholestrol (5,7-cholestadien-3-ol), which lacks this methyl
group at position 24 but has a double bond configuration of the B ring
identical to that of ergosterol, failed to rescue the double mutant,
indicating that the presence of the methyl group at position 24, rather
than the double-bond configuration of the B ring, is essential for
rescue. An ethyl group at position 24, as present in the plant
sitosterol, on the other hand, was nonfunctional, because sitosterol
did not rescue the double mutant. Taken together, these results
indicate that the synthetic lethal interaction between mutations in
ELO3 and ERG6 is likely to reflect an increased
structural requirement for the methyl group at position 24 of the
ergosterol molecule in an elo3
mutant background.
Characterization of a Strain That Is Temperature Sensitive for Erg6p Function
To investigate the increased structural requirement for ergosterol
in the elo3
mutant in more detail, we generated a strain that is temperature sensitive for the function of Erg6p. Therefore, the
3' end of the ERG6 gene, covering the carboxy-terminal 120 amino acids, was subject to mutagenesis by error prone PCR (see Figure
4A). After in vivo recombination and
plasmid shuffling, three temperature-sensitive ERG6 alleles
were isolated (see MATERIALS AND METHODS). Sequence analysis of one of
these alleles revealed a single base substitution in codon 341 (CTA to
CCA), resulting in the incorporation of a proline instead of the
wild-type leucine at this position of Erg6p.
|
Analysis of the growth characteristics of this elo3
erg6ts conditional strain revealed that the
strain grows like the corresponding wild-type at 24°C but that it
rapidly ceases growth upon incubation at nonpermissive conditions
(Figure 4B). Plating of cells that have been shifted for up to 8 h
to nonpermissive conditions revealed that the capacity of the mutant to
restore growth and form colonies when shifted back to permissive
conditions (24°C) was not impaired, indicating that the metabolic
block imposed by the temperature shift was fully reversible. In
agreement with these observations, Western blot analysis with an
anti-Erg6p antibody revealed that the mutant protein is stable and not
subject to temperature-dependent turnover (unpublished data).
The conditional growth phenotype of the elo3
erg6ts mutant could be fully rescued on rich
media by ergosterol supplementation, confirming the ergosterol
auxotrophic phenotype of the double mutant that was so far based on
plasmid loss on 5-FOA containing synthetic media (Figure 4C). Analysis
of the in vivo activity of the temperature-sensitive enzyme by labeling
cells with [3H]methionine revealed an
~800-fold reduced activity of the enzyme at permissive conditions.
This activity declined to undetectable levels upon incubation of cells
at nonpermissive conditions (unpublished data). Consistent with this
low activity of the conditional Erg6p allele, erg6
mutant
cells bearing this allele are sensitive to brefeldin A, as is an
erg6
null allele (Shah and Klausner, 1993
; Figure 4D).
Characterization of the Secretory Pathway in the elo3
erg6ts Conditional Mutant
To determine whether protein maturation and secretion were
conditionally affected in the elo3
erg6ts mutant strain, the kinetics of invertase
induction and secretion was analyzed (Novick and Schekman, 1979
).
Induction and secretion of invertase in the elo3
erg6ts conditional mutant was comparable to that
observed in the elo3
ERG6 strain, indicating that
vesicular transport from the ER to the plasma membrane is not affected
by the inactivation of Erg6p in the elo3
mutant
background (Figure 5A).
|
To examine whether vesicular transport between the Golgi apparatus and
the vacuole was affected, transport of the soluble vacuolar hydrolase
carboxypeptidase Y (CPY) was examined by pulse-chase analysis. CPY
leaves the ER as a 67-kDa preprotein to mature in the Golgi apparatus
to a 69-kDa form, which is cleaved to the active 61-kDa protease in the
vacuole. After a preshift to 37°C for 15 min, the elo3
erg6ts mutant exhibited wild-type kinetics of
CPY maturation, indicating that vesicular transport between ER and the
vacuole was not impaired by inactivation of Erg6p in an
elo3
mutant background (Figure 5B).
To complete the analysis of the secretory pathway, we examined whether
maturation of the GPI-anchored membrane protein Gas1p was affected.
Gas1p exits the ER as a 105-kDa precursor and matures in the Golgi
apparatus to a 125-kDa form (Fankhauser and Conzelmann, 1991
). The
accumulation of the ER form of Gas1p is a sensitive assay to detect
perturbations in ER-to-Golgi transport. Western blot analysis revealed
wild-type maturation of Gas1p in erg6
but a strong
accumulation of the ER precursor of Gas1p in the elo3
erg6ts mutant strain, irrespective of whether
the mutant was incubated at permissive or nonpermissive conditions
(unpublished data). Accumulation of the ER form of Gas1p was also
observed in the elo3
mutant alone and in the
elo3
erg6
double mutant bearing a wild-type copy of
ERG6 on a plasmid. To determine whether there is a
superimposed delay in Gas1p maturation by the inactivation of Erg6p in
an ELO3 mutant background, we followed maturation of Gas1p
by pulse-chase analysis and immunoprecipitation. This analysis failed
to reveal a significant delay in Gas1p maturation by the reduction of
Erg6p activity in the elo3
mutant background (Figure 5C).
Taken together, these results indicate that the efficiency of the
secretory pathway is not generally perturbed in the elo3
erg6ts conditional strain.
The elo3
erg6ts Mutant Has a
Sphingolipid Composition Characteristic of elo3
To determine whether inactivation of Erg6p affects
sphingolipid synthesis in the double mutant, cells were preshifted to
nonpermissive conditions and incorporation of
[3H]inositol into the
mild-base-resistant lipid fraction was examined. This analysis
revealed an approximately twofold decrease in the incorporation of
[3H]inositol into sphingolipids in
cells mutant for either ELO2 or ELO3,
irrespective of the activity of Erg6p (Figure
6A). Inactivation of ERG6
alone, however, resulted in a slight increased incorporation of label
into sphingolipids.
|
TLC analysis of the sphingolipid classes synthesized under these
conditions revealed a predominance of IPC-C
(inositolphosphorylceramide-C) species at the expense of the
more complex mannosylated sphingolipids in all strains with mutations
in ELO3, irrespective of Erg6p activity (Figure 6B). These
alterations in sphingolipid levels and composition in the
elo3
mutant are in agreement with previous analyses (Oh et al., 1997
; David et al., 1998
). The IPC-C
species produced in an elo3
mutant background has a
somewhat lower mobility compared with the IPC-C species of wild-type
cells, consistent with the idea that this sphingolipid is less
hydrophobic because of the presence of a shorter acyl chain. Taken
together, the results of the sphingolipid analysis indicate that
sphingolipid synthesis/composition of the elo3
mutant is
not affected by the activity of Erg6p.
The sphingolipid precursors, ceramide and phytosphingosine (PHS),
regulate cell growth by activation of different signaling pathways
(Hannun and Luberto, 2000
). To determine whether accumulation of these
signaling lipids results in growth arrest of the elo3
erg6ts conditional mutant, ceramide and PHS
levels were examined by labeling cells with
[3H]serine (Figure 6C). This analysis revealed
a strong accumulation of PHS in the elo2
mutant strain
and lower levels of PHS in all strains with mutations in
ELO3, irrespective of Erg6p activity. These results thus
indicate that the activity of Erg6p does not affect sphingolipid
signaling in an elo3
mutant background.
The elo3
erg6ts Mutant Affects Raft
Association of the Plasma Membrane ATPase
Given that sphingolipid synthesis is continuing in the conditional
mutant under nonpermissive conditions, we wondered whether membrane
raft formation might be impaired. Therefore, raft association of two
marker proteins, the GPI-anchored Gas1p, and the plasma membrane
ATPase, Pma1p, was investigated (Bagnat et al., 2000
). After
two successive rounds of extraction with the nonionic detergent Triton
X-100 and floatation in density gradients, both marker proteins were
recovered in the detergent-insoluble fraction of the gradient when
membranes of cells that were cultivated at permissive conditions were
analyzed. On incubation of the conditional elo3
erg6ts mutant at nonpermissive conditions for
2 h, however, raft association of Pma1p but not that of Gas1p was
specifically impaired (Figure 7). It is
important to note that unambiguous determination of raft association of
Pma1p in the mutant required analysis by two successive gradients as
the portion of Pma1p from the detergent-resistant fraction of the first
gradient was recovered in the detergent-soluble fraction of the second
gradient. Raft association of Pma1p was not impaired in the
elo3
erg6
double mutant harboring a plasmid-borne wild-type copy of ERG6, indicating that steady state raft
association of Pma1p is dependent on Erg6p activity in an
elo3
mutant background.
|
To examine whether raft association of Pma1p is detergent induced, an equal number of cells of the two genotypes that had been incubated at nonpermissive conditions for 2 h was mixed, and raft association of Gas1p and Pma1p was reexamined. This analysis revealed that Gas1p maintained its raft association, but Pma1p was now observed in both the detergent-resistant and the -soluble fractions of the gradient.
elo3
Conditionally Affects Stability of the
ATPase at the Plasma Membrane
Pma1p has recently been shown to move into raft domains during
biosynthetic transport to the plasma membrane (Bagnat et
al., 2001
; Gong and Chang, 2001
; Ferreira et al., 2002
;
Lee et al., 2002
). Raft association of Pma1p is required for
proper delivery to the plasma membrane because inhibition of raft
association results in rerouting of the protein to the vacuole where it
becomes degraded (Bagnat et al., 2001
). To examine whether
raft association required for biosynthetic transport of Pma1p to the
plasma membrane is affected by inactivation of Erg6p in an
elo3
mutant background, cells were pulse-labeled and
maturation of Pma1p was followed by immunoprecipitation. This analysis
revealed rapid turnover of Pma1p in the elo3
mutant when
cells were incubated at 37°C (Figure
8A). Under these conditions, 80% of
newly synthesized Pma1p was rapidly degraded, irrespective of the
activity of Erg6p. These results thus indicate that mutations in
ELO3 affect raft association of newly synthesized Pma1p at
37°C.
|
The increased turnover of newly synthesized Pma1p in the
elo3
mutant occurs by vacuolar degradation because Pma1p
is stabilized by a mutation in the vacuolar hydrolase Pep4p (Jones,
1991
). Moreover, transport of Pma1p to the vacuole appears to occur
after it has reached the plasma membrane, because it is stabilized by
blocking internalization from the cell surface in end4
cells (Raths et al., 1993
; Figure 8B). Thus, Elo3p is
required for stabilizing newly synthesized Pma1p at the plasma membrane
at 37°C.
To examine at which point along the secretory pathway raft association
of Pma1p is affected in elo3
, the detergent solubility of
Pma1p was assessed by pulse labeling. To stabilize newly synthesized Pma1p, this analysis was performed in an elo3
pep4
double mutant strain. As shown in Figure
9, Pma1p becomes detergent insoluble already after 5 min in cells cultivated at 24°C. At 37°C, however, Pma1p does not acquire detergent resistance in elo3
,
indicating that elo3
affects raft association of Pma1p
early in its biosynthetic transport and that raft association of Pma1p
is important for maintaining its stability at the plasma membrane.
|
ERG6 Is Required for Maintaining Raft Domains in
elo3
Given the observation that the conditional elo3
erg6ts mutant affects steady state raft
association of Pma1p but not Gas1p, we examined whether lipid rafts by
themselves were affected. Therefore, the sterol content of the
detergent-resistant membrane fraction of mutant cells grown at
permissive conditions or incubated at nonpermissive conditions for
2 h was determined by quantitative GC-MS. This analysis revealed
that 30% of free sterols were raft associated in an elo3
ERG6 control strain at either 24 or 37°C. In the elo3
erg6ts conditional mutant, however, the content
of raft-associated sterols was reduced threefold at permissive
conditions and further declined more than sixfold upon incubation at
nonpermissive conditions (Figure 10A).
These results thus indicate that preexisting raft structures are
affected upon inactivation of Erg6p in an elo3
mutant
strain.
|
To determine whether the decrease in raft lipids observed in the conditional mutant is specific for sterols, we examined the sphingolipid content of raft membranes in the two strains. Therefore, cells were labeled with [3H]myo-inositol for 16 h and raft association of mild-base-resistant lipids was determined. This analysis revealed an approximately twofold elevated level of sphingolipids in the detergent-resistant membrane fraction of the conditional mutant (Figure 10B). Unlike the sterol content, however, the sphingolipid content of raft membranes did not decline upon incubation of these cells at nonpermissive conditions. These results thus indicate that the aberrant sterols in raft membranes of the conditional mutant do not resist detergent extraction.
A quantitative analysis of total cellular sterols revealed
significantly higher sterol levels in the elo3
and
erg6
single mutants. Combining the two mutations results
in a further increase in total sterol levels, resulting in four times
elevated total saponifiable sterol levels (Table
4). A compositional analysis of the total
saponifiable sterols in the conditional mutant revealed a sterol
pattern characteristic of an erg6
single mutant with zymosterol (45.4%) and cholesta-5,7,24-trienol (33.7%) as the major
sterols, which is in agreement with a previous analysis of the sterol
composition of an erg6
mutant (Munn et al.,
1999
; Table 5). The low ergosterol
content observed in the conditional mutant indicates that the
temperature-sensitive allele of ERG6 has a greatly reduced
activity already at the permissive temperature and that the
plasmid-borne wild-type copy of ERG6 also does not fully
complement the erg6
deletion.
|
|
Given the fact that the conditional mutant strain has a fourfold
increased level of total sterols but a threefold reduced level of
sterols in detergent-resistant membranes, we examined whether
detergent-insoluble membrane domains exhibit preference for certain
sterol species. Therefore, the composition of free (nonesterified)
sterols in the detergent-insoluble membrane fraction from an
elo3
erg6ts conditional strain
cultivated at permissive conditions was examined by GC-MS. This
analysis revealed a sevenfold enrichment of ergosterol in the
detergent-resistant membrane fraction (Figure 10C). Zymosterol and
cholesta-5,7,22,24-tetraenol, on the other hand, are deenriched in the
raft fraction. Given that ergosterol accounts for only ~1.3% of the
total saponifiable sterols in an elo3
erg6ts conditional mutant (Table 5) in which
10% of the sterols are raft associated, a sevenfold enrichment of
ergosterol in these raft structures, suggests that ergosterol synthesis
and hence Erg6p activity becomes limiting for the maintenance of raft
domains in this strain.
To determine whether the observed preference of membrane rafts for
ergosterol is specific for elo3
mutant cells or a more general property of yeast membranes, the sterol composition of membrane
rafts of cells making normal C26-substituted sphingolipids was
analyzed. Therefore, the sterol composition of total and
detergent-resistant membranes from an erg6
mutant that
harbors a plasmid-borne wild-type allele of ERG6 was
analyzed by quantitative GC-MS. This analysis revealed that both
ergosterol and cholesta-5,7,24-trienol were slightly enriched in raft
membranes, whereas zymosterol and other low abundant sterols such as
fecosterol and 14-desmethyl-lanosterol were deenriched to undetectable
levels (Figure 11). These data are
consistent with the proposal that ergosterol is preferentially included
in raft membranes in cells that have normal C26-substituted sphingolipids. However, given that erg6
mutants are
viable in an ELO3 wild-type background, this preference is
much less stringent.
|
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
We report a specific genetic interaction between mutations in
genes required for fungal specific lipid modifications: one in the
synthesis of long-chain fatty acids and the other in the synthesis of
sterols. The synthetic lethality between mutations in ELO3
and ERG6 is likely due to a vital interaction of the
respective lipid products, because the viability of the double mutant
is rescued by supplementation with ergosterol. The fact that the double
mutant is only rescued by sterols that have a methyl group at position
24 of the side chain indicates that the elo3
mutant has a
stringent structural requirement for this otherwise nonessential sterol modification.
Cross-talk between Lipid Biosynthetic Pathways
Comparison of the lipid composition of erg6
,
elo3
, and double mutant strains revealed apparently
compensatory changes in sterol and sphingolipid synthesis, indicating
that the two lipid biosynthetic pathways must be under coordinate
control (Swain et al., 2002
). First, the erg6
mutant displayed an increased rate of incorporation of radiolabeled
inositol into mild-base-resistant lipids and a ~2.1-fold
increase in total sterol levels, suggesting that the absence of
ergosterol in this strain is compensated by an increase in both sterol
and sphingolipid levels (Figure 6A, Table 4). Second, mutations in
ELO3 result in a reduced rate of sphingolipid synthesis and
in the absence of the more complex mannosylated sphingolipid species.
These changes in the sphingolipid pattern of an elo3
mutant appear to be compensated by a ~1.5-fold increase in sterol
levels. The sterol composition of the elo3
mutant,
however, is comparable to that of wild-type cells, indicating that the
altered sphingolipid composition affects sterol levels only but not the
activity of individual sterol biosynthetic enzymes. Third, the
combination of mutations in both ELO3 and ERG6
does not further affect sphingolipid synthesis, but results in an
additional increase in total sterol levels, and a sterol composition
characteristic of an erg6
mutant.
Raft Formation in the elo3
erg6
Double Mutant
A common structural function of sphingolipids and sterols is their
association into membrane microdomains/rafts. Formation of these raft
domains is important for lateral sorting of proteins and for signal
transduction (Brown and Rose, 1992
; Simons and Ikonen, 1997
). Previous
studies have established that depletion of either sterols or
sphingolipids in yeast affects raft association of Gas1p and Pma1p
(Bagnat et al., 2000
, 2001
; Lee et al., 2002
). In
our strains, sterols and sphingolipids are not depleted, but their
structure and composition is altered. This affects raft association of
the two marker proteins differently. Although the GPI-anchored Gas1p
remains raft associated in the elo3
erg6ts conditional strain, Pma1p becomes
detergent soluble. Analysis of the composition of the
detergent-resistant lipids in this strain revealed that the sterol
content is greatly reduced, whereas the sphingolipid content of raft
membranes is increased, suggesting that sphingolipids compensate for
the absence of appropriate sterols to maintain raft function in this
strain, at least at 24°C. Under more stringent conditions (37°C),
the stability of preexisting raft domains becomes impaired to a point
where they can no longer resist detergent solubilization, resulting in
the release of Pma1p but not Gas1p. The observation that Gas1p
maintains detergent resistance may indicate that under these conditions
this GPI-anchored protein partitions into a domain that has a different
lipid composition than the typical raft, i.e., a sphingolipid-rich but
ergosterol-poor domain.
Analysis of the sterol composition of the raft membranes in the
conditional strain revealed a strong enrichment in ergosterol. This
observation and the fact that the elo3
erg6
double
mutant can only be rescued by sterols that have a methyl group in the aliphatic side chain suggests that C24-substituted sphingolipids have
an increased structural requirement for this methyl group. This notion
is supported by a recent biophysical study, which demonstrates that
ergosterol is significantly more strongly domain-promoting than
cholesterol (Xu et al., 2001
). Moreover, in
erg6
mutants the GPI-anchored plasma membrane protease,
Yps1p, is mistargeted to the vacuole, indicating that the precise
structure of the sterol is important for raft function in vivo (Sievi
et al., 2001
).
Raft Formation in the elo3
Mutant
Stable delivery of Pma1p to the plasma membrane requires
functional rafts (Bagnat et al., 2001
; Gong and Chang, 2001
;
Lee et al., 2002
). The observation that ~80% of newly
synthesized Pma1p are rapidly turned over in the elo3
mutant at 37°C through internalization from the cell surface and
delivery to the vacuole, indicates that nonraft-associated Pma1p is
unstable when it reaches the plasma membrane. A similar phenotype,
raft-dependent stabilization of surface delivered Pma1p has been
observed with a mutant allele of Pma1p, Pma1-10 (Gong and Chang,
2001
). In this case, raft association of Pma1-10 was suggested to be
required but not sufficient for its subsequent stabilization at the
cell surface. This is consistent with observations made with a second
allele of Pma1, Pma1-G381A, which remains raft associated but
nevertheless fails to become stabilized at the cell surface (Ferreira
et al., 2002
).
Pma1p that has entered rafts and that has been delivered to the plasma
membrane in elo3
at 24°C, however, remains stable even
if raft function is subsequently impaired by shifting cells to 37°C,
as indicated by the observation that steady state raft association of
Pma1p is not affected in the elo3
ERG6 mutant at 37°C.
These observations may indicate that elo3
at 37°C
affects raft assembly but that preexisting structures remain stable
unless ergosterol is depleted.
elo3
mutants display a number of lipid alterations that
potentially could affect raft formation, particularly when combined with mutations in the sterol biosynthetic pathway. First,
elo3
mutant cells have reduced levels of sphingolipids. A
complete block in sphingolipid synthesis as achieved using a
conditional allele of serine palmitoyltransferase
(lcb1-100; Sütterlin et al., 1997
), which
catalyzes the rate-limiting step of sphingolipid synthesis, has been
shown to affect raft association of both Gas1p and Pma1p (Bagnat
et al., 2000
; Lee et al., 2002
). The observation that the elo2
mutant has a similar reduction in
sphingolipid synthesis but is not synthetically lethal with
erg6
indicates that reduced levels of sphingolipids
cannot fully account for the defect observed in elo3
.
Second, elo3
mutant cells contain IPC-C as their main
sphingolipid species at the expense of the more complex mannosylated
lipids. Whether a defect in head group maturation of sphingolipids
could affect raft formation needs to be established. Third, the IPC-C
species in the elo3
mutant contains a C22/C24
very-long-chain fatty acid instead of the natural C26 fatty acid.
Biophysical studies indicate that the interaction of cholesterol with
sphingomyelin is not affected by differences in acyl chain length
(Ohvo-Rekila et al., 2002
). Phase separation of lipids in
model membranes, however, is favored by the mismatch of the hydrophobic
interaction surface of the interacting lipids (Silvius et
al., 1996
). A simplified static model of the interaction of
ergosterol with C26-substituted lipids, assuming interdigitation of the
C26 acyl chain into the hydrophobic core of the opposing membrane
leaflet (Slater and Huang, 1988
; but see also McIntosh et
al., 1992
), is illustrated in Figure
12. According to this model, shortening
of the C26 acyl chain to C22 with the simultaneous removal of the C24
methyl group on ergosterol could result in significant alterations in
the hydrophobic core o