|
|
|
|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Vol. 14, Issue 2, 571-584, February 2003
Department of Cell and Molecular Biology, Northwestern University, Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, Illinois 60611-3008
Submitted August 28, 2002; Revised October 14, 2002; Accepted October 31, 2002| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
During macronuclear development in the ciliate Euplotes crassus, the highly repetitive, transposon-like Tec elements possess an unusual chromatin structure. We observed that the Tec element chromatin is highly resistant to salt extraction and behaves like a nuclear matrix/chromosome scaffold-associated structure. Standard matrix/scaffold extraction procedures identified two major proteins: 1) an ~140-kDa protein that seems to be topoisomerase II based on its reactivity with anti-topoisomerase II antibodies, and 2) an 85-kDa protein that we further purified by acid extraction and have shown to be a novel protein by sequence analysis of its gene. The 85-kDa protein (p85) is a developmental stage-specific protein and is located exclusively in the developing macronucleus. Immunolocalization studies of p85 show that it colocalizes with topoisomerase II in chromatin. In addition, in situ hybridization combined with immunofluorescence localization of the proteins indicates that 100% of the Tec elements colocalize with 70% of the p85, whereas no significant colocalization with a total macronuclear sequence-specific probe is observed. p85 is the first developmental stage-specific protein identified as being specifically associated with sequences undergoing elimination in E. crassus.
| |
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
During the sexual phase of the life cycle of the ciliated
protozoan Euplotes crassus, a macronucleus is formed from a
copy of a micronucleus (reviewed by Jahn and Klobutcher, 2002
). As in
other ciliated protozoa, the macronucleus is transcriptionally active
during vegetative life, whereas the micronucleus is not. The formation
of a macronucleus involves polytenization of the micronuclear
chromosomes, highly specific DNA-processing events, and massive
chromatin elimination, such that only the genes, with very little extra
noncoding DNA, remain. The macronuclear genome comprises only a small
percentage of the micronuclear genome (5-10%); thus, the chromatin
elimination involves as much as 95% of the DNA. Two types of DNA
processing form the macronuclear chromosomes: 1) precise deletion of
DNA sequences that are internal to the sequences that are retained as
the macronuclear genomic sequences and hence, called internal
eliminated sequences (IESs); and 2) precise fragmentation of
chromosomes 5' and 3' of genes coupled with the de novo addition of
telomeres, which results in the "gene-sized" linear DNA molecules
characteristic of E. crassus and other "hypotrichous" ciliates (Figure 1A).
|
In E. crassus, the IESs defined to date are either repeated
sequences corresponding to two closely related families of transposable elements called Tec elements (referred to as Tec-IES) or they are
small, unique sequences (referred to as SU-IES) (Jahn and Klobutcher,
2002
). Both types of IES are eliminated by a common mechanism that
generates extrachromosomal circular forms of the IES (Jahn et
al., 1989
; Tausta and Klobutcher, 1989
, 1990
; Jaraczewski and
Jahn, 1993
). The IES deletion occurs during the last part of each of
two discrete S phases that give rise to the polytene chromosomes (Frels
and Jahn, 1995
) (developmental timing is shown in Figure 1B). Tec-IES
can be deleted in either S phase, whereas most SU-IES are deleted in
the second S phase (Frels and Jahn, 1995
; Frels et al.,
1996
).
Our laboratory has demonstrated that during the replications that form
the polytene chromosomes, the Tec elements become organized into an
unusual chromatin structure that differs from the chromatin structure
of the macronuclear-destined sequences (Jahn, 1999
). This is the first
evidence that chromatin structure could play a role in defining which
DNA sequences are to be eliminated in E. crassus. A role for
chromatin structure in DNA elimination was previously demonstrated in
the distantly related ciliate, Tetrahymena thermophila,
where three proteins, Pdd1p, Pdd2p, and Pdd3p, have been shown to be
associated with the eliminated DNA in heterochromatic "vesicle"
structures that associate with the nuclear periphery (Madireddi
et al., 1996
; Smothers et al., 1997b
; Nikiforov
et al., 2000
). Pdd1p and Pdd3p are chromodomain proteins (Madireddi et al., 1996
; Nikiforov et al., 2000
)
and thus share the characteristic heterochromatic localization of this
class of proteins (Koonin et al., 1995
). The Pdd proteins
are referred to as "DNA degradation"-specific proteins because they
are also associated with "old" macronuclei that are undergoing
elimination while the new macronucleus develops. Recent work using
reverse genetic approaches to knock out the Pdd1 and Pdd2 genes in the parental macronucleus, which alters the timing of appearance and amounts of these proteins during development, has demonstrated that
these proteins are critical for the DNA-processing events that
eliminate DNA in the Tetrahymena-developing macronucleus (Coyne et al., 1999
; Nikiforov et al., 1999
).
Nevertheless, antibodies to the Pdd1p and Pdd2p proteins and gene
probes have not identified potential homologues of these proteins or
genes in E. crassus. Thus, the goal of the experiments
described herein was to use the properties of the unusual chromatin
structure of the Tec elements to identify proteins that might be
associated with the elements during their elimination and which might
play an analogous role to the Pdd proteins.
| |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Cell Culture and Preparation of Nuclei, Scaffolds, and Chromatin Spreads
E. crassus strains X1 and X2 were cultured, mated,
and harvested as described previously (Roth et al., 1985
;
Krikau and Jahn, 1991
). Nuclei were prepared by lysis in TE (10 mM
Tris-HCl, 1 mM EDTA, pH 8) with 0.5% Triton X-100 and sonication, and
MNase digested as described previously (Jahn, 1999
). Protease
inhibitors were used throughout all preparations and included the
following: N-tosyl-L-phenylalanine
chloromethyl ketone (100 µg/ml),
N-tosyl-L-lysine chloromethyl ketone
(50 µg/ml), leupeptin (2 µg/ml), and aprotinin (1 µg/ml) (all
from Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, MO). Chromosome scaffolds/nuclear
matrices were isolated by suspending the purified nuclei in either NaCl
extraction buffer (2 M NaCl, 0.25 M sucrose, 50 mM Tris-HCl pH 7.5, 3 mM MgCl2, 0.5 mM CaCl2) or
in LIS extraction buffer (10 mM lithium iodosalicylate, 20 mM
HEPES-NaOH pH 7.5, 100 mM lithium acetate, 0.1% digitonin, 1 mM EDTA
pH 8) (Mirkovitch et al., 1984
) for 30 min on ice,
centrifuging the nuclei, and washing the nuclei once (30 min on ice)
with NaCl or LIS buffer after which the nuclei were washed three times
and suspended in TMS (50 mM Tris-HCl pH 7.5, 10 mM NaCl, 10 mM
MgCl2) and DNase I added at 200 µg/ml for 30 min at room temperature. Nuclei were then washed three times with TE.
(Identical results were obtained with the 2 M NaCl washes followed by
three washes with 0.25 M sucrose, 50 mM Tris-HCl pH 7.5, 15 mM NaCl, 3 mM MgCl2, 0.5 mM CaCl2 and
digestion with MNase at 5 U/ml for 30 min at 37°C.) For further
extraction of the scaffolds, the nuclei (nucleoskeletons) were washed
with 4 M guanidine-100 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.0, followed by two washes with
8 M urea.
Chromatin spreads were prepared by suspending purified nuclei in 100 mM
Tris-HCl pH 8, 35 mM NaCl, 1 mM EDTA, 1 mM dithiothreitol, adding
trypsin at 10 µg/ml and incubating for 10 min at room temperature. Treatment of E. crassus anlagen with trypsin and the effect
on chromatin structure was described previously (Jahn, 1999
). At this
concentration of trypsin, the Tec element chromatin is not disrupted
and histones are not digested. Formaldehyde was added at 5% and the
nuclei/chromatin were immediately spun onto polylysine-coated coverslips by diluting the chromatin either 1/10 or 1/50 in 500 µl of
phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) and centrifuging for 5 min at 300 × g. The coverslips were rinsed twice with PBS and
air-dried.
Purification of p85 and Sequence Analysis
Purified nuclei were suspended in TE, H2SO4 added to 0.4 N, and the nuclei sonicated and left on ice for at least 30 min. In many cases, samples were frozen immediately after addition of H2SO4 and processed further later. After centrifugation at 12,000 × g for 10 min the supernatant was made 3.5% in perchloric acid (PCA) and allowed to sit on ice for at least 30 min. After centrifugation as described above, the supernatant was made 20% in trichloroacetic acid (TCA), left on ice >30 min, and then centrifuged again for 10 min. The pellet was washed with acetone, 0.1% HCl, and then with acetone and air-dried. For more highly purified preparations, such as that used for affinity purification of antibodies, the above-described TCA pellet was resuspended in 5% PCA and centrifuged at 100,000 × g for 1 h followed by TCA precipitation and acetone washes as described above. Protein concentration was determined using Bio-Rad (Hercules, CA) protein assay dye reagent concentrate with bovine serum albumin as a standard or by comparison with standards on Coomassie-stained gels.
The p85 purified by acid extraction was subjected to N-terminal amino
acid sequence analysis by the University of Massachusetts Proteomic
Mass Spectrometry Laboratory (Amherst, MA) by using their
recommended methods of blotting SDS-polyacrylamide gels to
nitrocellulose membranes. In addition, p85 blotted to nitrocellulose was subjected to asp protease digestion, which resulted in numerous peptides, two of which were purified and sequenced by The Rockefeller University Protein/DNA Technology Center (New York, NY).
Oligonucleotide primers for polymerase chain reaction (PCR) of the p85
gene were designed based on the N terminal and internal peptide
sequences by using the Web-based Entelechon Backtranslation program,
which includes an E. crassus codon usage table. The peptide
sequences obtained are shown in Figure 4 and oligonucleotides that
resulted in a p85 gene-specific product were as follows: 5' end (amino terminus)
AAGGGTAAGATAGCCACCAAGGTAGCTGGAAAGGGATTAAAGACTAAGGGAAAGAA-GACAAAGGCTGCAGA, and 3' end (internal peptide) CTCCTCTTCTACCTTACCCTTTTTTCCTTC. The PCR
was performed using platinum Taq DNA polymerase, high fidelity (0.5 U/µl), from Invitrogen (Carlsbad, CA) by using the buffer supplied by the manufacturer, 10 ng/µl total E. crassus DNA, 2 pmol/µl each primer, and 200 µM dNTPs. The PCR
was performed for 30 cycles with 30 s at 94°C, 30 s at
52°C, and 2 min at 72°C. The PCR product was cloned and sequenced
and shown to contain the sequence corresponding to the second internal
peptide sequence obtained at The Rockefeller University. By using the
PCR product as a hybridization probe, the macronuclear DNA molecule
bearing the p85 gene and cDNA clones were isolated from a macronuclear genomic library and a developmental stage-specific cDNA library described previously (Harper and Jahn, 1989
; Ling et
al., 1997
). The macronuclear genomic clone and two
different cDNAs were sequenced in their entirety. DNA sequencing
reactions used the ABI PRISM big dye terminators cycle sequencing kit
(Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA). Gel analysis was carried out by
the Northwestern University Biotechnology Laboratory (Chicago, IL). The
DNA sequences were analyzed using BLAST searches (National Center for
Biotechnology Information) and several programs available through the
ExPASy Web site (www.expasy.ch), including Translate Tool, NetPhos,
Coils, and Paircoil.
Western Blotting and Antibody Purification
Nuclear proteins were resolved on 10 or 12.5% SDS-polyacrylamide gels and transferred to nitrocellulose membranes. Membranes were blocked in 5% nonfat milk in PBST (PBS + 0.05% Tween 20) for 1 h at room temperature. After washing, primary antibodies were applied at a dilution of 1:500 for anti-p85 and 1:1000 for anti-topoisomerase II in PBST + 1% bovine serum albumin for 1-2 h at room temperature or overnight at 4oC. Membranes were washed and exposed to the appropriate peroxidase-conjugated secondary antibodies (goat anti-rat, Amersham Biosciences, Piscataway, NJ; or goat anti-rabbit, Chemicon International, Temecula, CA) at the dilution of 1:1000. Staining was detected by chemiluminescence by using the Western blotting luminol reagent (Santa Cruz Biotechnology, Santa Cruz, CA) and exposure to x-ray film. To affinity purify anti-p85 antibodies, purified p85 protein was electrophoresed and blotted to polyvinylidene difluoride membrane (Schleicher & Schuell, Keene, NH) and incubated with serum. Bound antibody was then washed off the membrane and collected.
In Situ Hybridization and Immunofluorescence
Immunohistochemistry was performed on trypsinized nuclei or
whole nuclear matrices as follows. Samples were fixed with 5% formaldehyde in PBS for 10 min at room temperature, washed twice in
PBS, and resuspended in 1 ml of PBS. For whole cells, urea was added to
a final concentration of 4 M and allowed to incubate at room
temperature for 30 min (Jacobs et al., 1999
). Approximately 100 µl of sample was dropped on polylysine-coated coverslips and allowed to air dry. Dried coverslips were processed in 100% ice cold
methanol for 6 min followed by acetone for 30 s. Coverslips were
then blocked in 5% nonfat milk in PBST for 1 h at 30°C. Primary antibody was applied for 4-12 h at 4°C at 1:50 dilution in PBST + 1% bovine serum albumin for the anti-p85 and 1:100 for the
anti-topoisomerase II antibodies. Secondary antibodies
rhodamine-conjugated goat anti-rat (Jackson Immunoresearch
Laboratories, West Grove, PA) or fluorescein-conjugated goat
anti-rabbit antibodies (Invitrogen) were used at a 1:50-1:100 dilution
in PBS for 1 h at room temperature in the dark. Coverslips were
washed three times in PBS and 4,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole (DAPI)
(Sigma-Aldrich) was added at 5 µg/ml to the second wash. Coverslips
were blotted dry, mounted using Vectashield mounting medium for
fluorescence (Vector Laboratories, Burlingame, CA), and glued down.
Immunofluorescence analysis of 10-µm sections of whole nuclei was
performed similarly, except that fixed whole nuclei were resuspended in
Tissue-Tek OCT embedding medium (Miles, Elkhart, IN) and flash frozen
in liquid nitrogen. Frozen blocks were sectioned using a cryostat at
20°C. Sections were transferred to polylysine-coated slides and
processed as stated above. In situ hybridization was performed as
described in Madireddi et al. (1996)
, except that 50 ng of
probe was used per coverslip for hybridizations. The rDNA probe used
was a plasmid clone of the full-length rDNA molecule (Erbeznik et
al., 1999
). The macronuclear sequence probe was prepared by Bal31
treatment and size fractionation of total E. crassus DNA as
described previously (Jahn, 1999
). The Tec 1 and Tec 2 probes consisted
of plasmid subclones of restriction fragments from the Tec1-1 and
Tec2-1 elements (Jahn et al., 1993
; Jahn, 1999
). The results
shown in figures were obtained by mixing the Tec1 and Tec2 probes after
labeling. Results obtained with the mixed probes were consistent with
what was seen with individual probes.
| |
RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Extraction Behavior of Tec Element Chromatin: Identification of Chromosome Scaffold/Nuclear Matrix-associated Proteins
To define what proteins might be determinants of the Tec element
chromatin structure, we performed salt extractions of nuclei either
before or after MNase digestion to see whether protein determinants of
the chromatin structure would be stripped from the chromatin at
increasing ionic strength. This demonstrated that treatment of nuclei
with NaCl concentrations as high as 2 M had no effect on the MNase
digestion pattern of the Tec element chromatin (Figure
2, A and B), despite the fact that the
majority of DNA is completely unprotected from digestion (>80% acid
soluble at the most extensive digestion). The unusual pattern of Tec
element chromatin digestion products described previously (Jahn, 1999
), which consists of an ~200-base pair nucleosomal repeat ladder starting at ~300 base pairs instead of ~200 base pairs, is evident regardless of the salt concentration. Furthermore, the excised circular
forms of the Tec elements (Figure 2B, stars), which are resistant to
nuclease digestion in chromatin (Jahn, 1999
), retain their resistance
to MNase digestion at all NaCl concentrations examined. In samples of
nuclei that are 2 M NaCl treated and digested with MNase, <10% of the
DNA remains undigested and hybridization to macronuclear sequence
probes is completely eliminated. Quantitation of the Tec element
hybridization indicates that they comprise at least 50% of the
remaining DNA; thus, these preparations are enriched for the Tec
element chromatin.
|
We have previously documented (Jahn, 1999
) that the Tec element
chromatin digestion products are tightly associated with the nuclear
substructure and cannot be released by treatment of nuclei with EDTA,
whereas the nucleosomal multimers of the macronuclear-destined sequences and most other sequences (based on quantitation of soluble and insoluble fractions) are solubilized by this treatment. Similarly, washing nuclei with 2 M NaCl after MNase digestion did not release the
Tec element chromatin digestion products (Figure 2C). Conditions similar to those described above (MNase digestion and 2 M NaCl extraction) have previously been used to selectively purify the macronuclear telomere-binding proteins in association with
Oxytricha nova and E. crassus telomeric DNA
(Gottschling and Zakian, 1986
; Price, 1990
). Likewise, this is one
method of isolating a "nuclear matrix" or "chromosome
scaffold," which is operationally defined as the proteinaceous
structure remaining insoluble after these treatments (Berezney and
Coffey, 1977
; Mirkovitch et al., 1984
). We therefore
examined the proteins remaining in the anlagen after 2 M NaCl
extraction and nuclease digestion to see whether we had selectively
purified any proteins. In addition, we used a second type of nuclear
matrix/chromosome scaffold preparation, involving lithium iodosalicylic
acid (LIS) extraction of nuclei and DNase I digestion (Mirkovitch
et al., 1984
), to determine whether a similar set of
proteins remained postextraction.
As seen in Figure 3, A and B, one major
protein species (85 kDa) is enriched in Coomassie-stained
SDS-polyacrylamide gels of the nuclear matrix preparations. In
addition, there is a prominent band at ~140 kDa. Comparisons were
made between the NaCl- or LIS-insoluble proteins obtained from the
"pellicle" or "cortical" fraction of E. crassus,
because these would be the most abundant and most likely contaminants
of the nuclear matrix preparation. Although the "140-kDa" protein
in the matrix preparations comigrates with a protein seen in the
pellicle fraction, we believe it is a different protein because it is
always present regardless of the amount of the other pellicle proteins
that contaminate the preparation. In both types of matrix preparations,
a cytologically visible "nuclear skeleton" is obtained that retains
the size and shape of an intact nucleus. This structure is highly
insoluble in every type of solubilizing agent we have tried (6-8 M
urea, 4 M guanidine-isothiocyanate, ethylene glycol, dimethyl
sulfoxide, SDS gel sample buffer supplemented with SDS at 10%, or
-mercaptoethanol at 10% and extensive boiling of the samples; high
and low pH). Some portion of this nucleoskeletal material
migrates into the polyacrylamide gel and remains as a smear of
Coomassie-stained protein at the top (Figure 3A, NS), but the majority
of the material remains particulate as spherical nucleoskeletons and is
removed by centrifugation of the SDS-PAGE samples before loading of the
gels. We generated rabbit polyclonal antibodies to the nucleoskeleton
fraction that remained after LIS extraction, DNase digestion, and
extensive washing with guanidine isothiocyanate and urea. These
antibodies react to both the 85-kDa protein and the smear of protein at
the top of the gel (Figure 3D,
-skeleton). We have affinity-purified
antibodies to the 85-kDa protein from this sera for additional
characterizations of the 85-kDa protein (described below). Due to the
insolubility of most of this nucleoskeleton fraction, we chose to focus
the majority of our efforts on the two identifiable soluble proteins
(85 and 140 kDa) and their potential association with the Tec element chromatin.
|
The Smaller Soluble Protein Is a Novel Protein with H1-Histone-like Extraction Properties
In the process of characterizing histones from E. crassus, we determined that the 85-kDa protein extracted from the
anlagen with sulfuric acid (0.4 N
H2SO4) and in addition, was
the only protein that behaved like an H1 histone in that it was both
H2SO4 and PCA soluble
(addition of PCA to the
H2SO4-soluble fraction precipitated core histones) (Oliver et al., 1972
) (Figure
3C). Thus, p85 is readily purified from the anlagen based on its PCA solubility. We therefore generated rat antibodies to the PCA-extracted p85; these react with the LIS-extracted, or 2 M NaCl extracted "nucleoskeleton fraction" p85 (Figure 3D,
-p85). Likewise,
antibodies to p85 that we affinity purify from the "total
nucleoskeleton" (rabbit) antibody described above react to p85 from
either type of preparation and show identical p85 localization as the
rat antibody prepared to PCA-extracted p85 (see results below).
Purified p85 was subjected to amino terminal sequence analysis as well
as cleavage and internal sequence analysis, and the resulting peptide
sequences were used to obtain PCR products from the p85 gene and
subsequently cDNA and genomic clones of the p85 gene (see MATERIALS AND
METHODS). Sequence analysis of the p85 gene (accession no. AY155457)
indicates that it encodes 542 amino acids (Figure
4A), which would have a predicted size of 60 kDa. Expression of the p85 gene in bacteria results in a protein that is PCA soluble, migrates as 60 kDa in SDS-PAGE, and is recognized by anti-p85 antibodies. This size difference from what is observed for
the protein extracted from E. crassus can be explained by the likelihood that it is a highly phosphorylated protein. The encoded
p85 protein contains 62 serines and 35 threonine residues of which 57 and 13, respectively, are predicted to be phosphorylatable. These
phosphorylatable residues occur within predicted sites for cAMP/cGMP-dependent protein kinase, protein kinase C, and casein kinase
II. The amino acid composition of the encoded p85 protein indicates
that it is highly charged (30% basic amino acids, primarily lysines,
24% acidic residues, and <1% aromatic amino acids). This composition
is similar to the HMG14/17 proteins, which have similar perchloric acid extraction properties to p85 (Johns, 1982
; Walker, 1982
). Nevertheless, p85 does not show sequence similarity to any known
HMG proteins, including the T. thermophila HMG proteins (Schulman et al., 1991
).
|
Protein-structure prediction programs indicate that much of the p85 protein is "low-complexity" sequence (as can be seen by the multiple lysine and glutamic acid residues in the predicted protein) and that it contains two potential regions of coiled coil structure (Figure 4). Most database matches to p85 are proteins containing a domain that is similarly low in complexity and rich in lysine, glutamic acid, and serine. High similarity was observed to the "repeat domain" (~500 aa) of the neurofilament heavy chain protein from rabbit and human, which contains a repeat of "KSP" phosphorylation sites embedded within glutamic acid residues. Likewise, the UNC-89 protein from Caenorhabditis elegans was similar over an ~600-aa domain that contains the KSP motif repeated in the context of multiple lysine and glutamic acid residues. The p85 protein does not contain repeats of KSP. A region of p85 from amino acids 343-465 consists of a heptamer repeat of the sequence KK(E/D)XXK(E/D), where the X denotes variable amino acids. A portion of this region is predicted to form a coiled coil structure (Figure 4A).
As is typical of many E. crassus genes, the macronuclear molecule carrying the p85 gene has limited amounts of noncoding DNA. As shown in Figure 4B, there are 120 base pairs between the telomere and the start of the p85 coding region (ATG). At the 3' end, there are 32 base pairs after the TAA stop codon (no internal stop codons are found). Sequence analysis of two independent cDNA clones indicates that the polyA tail is added at a residue corresponding to a position eight base pairs internal to the telomere.
The Larger Soluble Protein Is Topoisomerase II
Because topoisomerase II is associated with metaphase chromosome
scaffolds (Berrios et al., 1985
; Earnshaw et al.,
1985
) and is a major protein species that is resistant to the types of
extractions described above, and because the larger of the two
solubilized proteins was in the molecular weight range of topoisomerase
II proteins from other lower eukaryotes, we tested whether this protein was topoisomerase II. To do this, we determined whether antibodies to
Drosophila topoisomerase II (kindly provided by Paul Fisher, SUNY, Stony Brook, NY) would react with the 140-kDa band in Western blots of the polyacrylamide gels. As seen in Figure
5, four different antibodies to
Drosophila topoisomerase II reacted with the 140-kDa band in
Western blots of either total nuclear proteins or the chromosome
scaffold preparations. One of these antibodies was made to the intact
Drosophila topoisomerase II protein (Figure 5B), whereas the
other three antibodies were made against large peptides corresponding
to regions of Drosophila topoisomerase II that are related
in sequence to topoisomerase II from a wide range of organisms (Figure
5, A and C) (Meller et al., 1995
). Given that antibodies to
different regions of Drosophila topoisomerase II and to the
intact protein react with the 140-kDa species it is highly likely that
the 140-kDa protein is the E. crassus topoisomerase II. The
antibody cross reactivity is consistent with our ability to use
subfragments of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae topoisomerase II gene to detect a single topoisomerase II gene in E. crassus (Jahn, unpublished observations).
|
The 85-kDa Protein and Topoisomerase II Colocalize
To determine the localization of the 85-kDa protein relative to
topoisomerase II in the polytene chromosome structure, we used the
antibodies that we generated to PCA-extracted p85 in rats, such that
double labeling with the rabbit anti-Drosophila topoisomerase II antibodies could be performed. We used several types
of nuclear preparations to determine the subnuclear distribution of
these proteins, including isolated intact nuclei, LIS-extracted nuclei,
and frozen sections of nuclei. In all three cases, the localization of
p85 and topoisomerase II is diffuse and little substructure is
discernible (Figure 6, A and B). However,
in all three types of preparations, spots of intense staining were
apparent with both antibodies, and double labeling indicated that these spots are coincident for topoisomerase II and p85. Confocal microscopy indicated that these spots were internal in the nuclei and not just
associated with the nuclear periphery. Because there were typically one
or two spots per nucleus with about half of the nuclei showing spots,
we thought that they might be related to the early differentiation of a
nucleolus in the developing macronucleus. In three separate experiments
combining immunofluorescence with anti-p85 or anti-topoisomerase II and
in situ hybridization with an rDNA probe, colocalization of rDNA
sequences with the intense spots of anti-p85 or topoisomerase II
staining occurred in <20% of the nuclei. Thus, the intense spots of
p85 and topoisomerase II staining do not seem to be associated with
nucleoli and must be some other subnuclear region of increased
concentration of these two proteins.
|
Given the abundance and dispersed localization of these proteins, we
further examined their localization by spreading the chromatin, which
affords higher resolution analysis of the localization. The polytene
chromosomes cannot be released from the anlagen nuclear structure by
any standard procedures of lysing nuclei. Thus, we resorted to mild
trypsin treatment of nuclei to disrupt the nuclei and release
chromatin, which we centrifuged onto coverslips. By treating with
trypsin for varying amounts of time before fixation with formaldehyde,
we obtained chromatin preparations with different degrees of spreading,
either with small amounts of chromosome-like structures spread away
from an obvious nuclear mass to a more uniformly spread region of
chromatin that was discrete but no longer spherical in structure.
Analysis of the proteins from these trypsinized nuclear samples by
Coomassie staining and by Western blotting with anti-p85 and
anti-topoisomerase II indicated that these proteins, as well as the
core histones, were not digested at the concentration of trypsin and
duration of treatment used. Furthermore, MNase digestion of the nuclei
after treatment with trypsin at these concentrations showed that the
unusual Tec element chromatin digestion pattern was unaltered (Jahn,
1999
). Disruption of the Tec element chromatin structure was only
accomplished at 102- to
103-fold higher concentration of trypsin and
digestion at 37°C instead of room temperature (Jahn, 1999
).
As seen in Figure 6, C and D, the staining by anti-p85 and anti-topoisomerase II colocalizes in discrete subregions of the chromatin seen by DAPI staining of the DNA. Immunofluorescence with antibodies to core histones colocalizes with all of the DAPI staining (our unpublished data); thus, the specific subregions rich in anti-p85 and anti-topoisomerase II are not due to an unusual redistribution of chromatin proteins relative to DNA. The chromatin spreads give a better idea of the abundance of p85 and topoisomerase II. Typically, staining for these two proteins occurs within ~50% of the chromatin spread from a single nucleus. Although variations in fluorescent intensity are apparent when comparing the staining for the two proteins, the p85 and topoisomerase II staining is completely coincident (Figure 6, C and D).
Tec Elements Colocalize with p85
Although p85 and topoisomerase II are abundant in the E. crassus anlagen, they do not seem to associate with all of the
eliminated DNA, as observed for the Tetrahymena Pdd
proteins, because eliminated sequences comprise 80-90% of the
E. crassus genome. Given that the extraction of these
proteins paralleled the extraction properties of the unusual Tec
element chromatin, we sought to determine whether any specific
association with Tec elements was apparent. We performed in situ
hybridization with Tec element probes as well as a bulk "macronuclear
sequence" probe (see MATERIALS AND METHODS) by using two different
fluorochromes to label the two probes. We have estimated that the
macronuclear sequence probe, which was Bal31 digested to remove
telomeres and size fractionated to remove the abundant rDNA molecucles,
hybridizes to the majority of the macronuclear sequences (Southern blot
hybridizations are shown in Jahn, 1999
); thus, it is expected to
hybridize to numerous chromosomal regions where the ~20,000
precursors to the macronuclear linear DNA molecules are clustered in
the genome (Jahn et al., 1988
). Likewise, the Tec element
probes should detect the >20,000 copies of the elements dispersed
throughout the genome.
We initially performed the immunofluorescence and hybridization on
intact nuclei and frozen sections of nuclei. This demonstrated that the
myriad of punctate spots of anti-p85 reactivity colocalized with Tec
element hybridization but not with the macronuclear sequence hybridization at least at the resolution of two-color discrimination of
overlap. However, the abundance of spots made this difficult to
quantitate. In addition, permeabilization for immunofluorescence relative to in situ hybridization was difficult to control in these
preparations. We therefore did higher resolution localization by using
the chromatin spreads described above. In hybridizations with these two
probes to 40-, 42-, or 45-h anlagen chromatin spreads, we see very
little overlap between the sites of hybridization of these two probes
(Figure 7A). Although approximately
one-third of the Tec elements would be expected to be close to
macronuclear sequences because they interrupt them as IES, these time
points are during or immediately after IES excision and thus the
majority of the IES Tecs could be separated from the chromosomes. We
quantitated the number of spots hybridizing to each probe in chromatin
spreads where a substantial number (>30) of hybridizing spots were
visible for each probe and where the chromatin seemed to be equivalent to one nucleus. At least 10 individual spreads from at least three different hybridizations (i.e., different coverslips) were counted. Only 0.8% of the Tec spots were seen to overlap in their hybridization with the macronuclear sequence spots.
|
When the in situ hybridization to Tec or macronuclear sequences is carried out with immunofluorescence to detect p85, it is apparent that the Tec elements colocalize with p85 protein and the macronuclear sequences do not (Figure 7, B-D). Quantitation of the hybridization relative to anti-p85 reactivity was carried out as described above for the hybridization probes. This demonstrated that 100% of the Tec hybridization overlapped with spots of anti-p85 staining and that 70% of the p85 staining coincided with the Tec elements. In contrast, only 5% of the p85 staining coincided with the macronuclear sequence hybridization, with 9% of the macronuclear sequence-hybridizing spots overlapping p85. Thus, the p85 protein is associated with the Tec elements as well as some other sequences, the majority of which are not macronuclear-specific sequences.
We also did the in situ hybridization of Tec elements and localization of p85 relative to topoisomerase II on chromatin spreads prepared from developing macronuclei at 38 h, which is before the second round of Tec element deletion (40-42 h of development). These spreads are similar to the 40- to 45-h chromatin spreads and demonstrate colocalization of topoisomerase II and p85 (Figure 6, C and D) and the colocalization of p85/topoisomerase II with the Tec elements (Figure 7D). In the 38-h spreads, however, the chromatin fibers seem more continuous, which may be a function of how the eliminated chromatin behaves before vs. after the second round of Tec element excision from the chromosomes (i.e., pre or post 42 h). The numerology of colocalization of the DNA sequences with p85 or topoisomerase II at 38 h was as follows: 100% of the Tec spots colocalize with the p85 spots and account for 75% of the total p85 spots. Note that these numbers are similar to what we observed with the 40- to 45-h spreads.
p85 Is a Developmental Stage and Anlagen-specific Protein
Because the above-mentioned data suggest that p85, possibly in
association with topoisomerase II, could be generating the unusual
chromatin structure of the Tec elements, we would expect the p85
protein to be present during the developmental time periods that the
unusual Tec element chromatin structure is evident and that the protein
would be specific to the anlagen, because the unusual chromatin
structure is not apparent in the micronucleus. We have detected the
altered chromatin structure as early as 20 h of development (Jahn,
1999
) and the structure is evident as long as Tec elements are present
and undergoing elimination from the anlagen (through 65 h). Thus,
we examined a developmental time course of total cellular protein
samples to determine when p85 is present. As seen in Figure
8, p85 is not detected in any vegetative
cell sample by Western blotting. In mated cells, at 5 h the
protein is not detected in total protein samples. At 18 h, p85 is
detected and the amounts increase by 24 h and remain fairly
constant through 65 h, the latest time point we tested. We have
previously demonstrated that the excised circular forms of Tec elements
are abundant as late as 65 h (Jahn et al., 1989
) and
are just beginning to be degraded at that time. We have not detected
the circular forms after 80 h.
|
We used immunofluorescence on fixed whole cells to determine which
nuclei reacted with anti-p85. Immunofluorescence on whole cells is
technically difficult with E. crassus because the outer pellicle of the cells is difficult to permeabilize. Procedures for
immunofluorescence by using urea treatment after formaldehyde fixation
have allowed reliable detection of some antigens (Jacobs et
al., 1999
). In our hands, this procedure leads to a high
background fluorescence with the secondary antibodies used alone (40-h
control in Figure 8). Nevertheless, we are able to demonstrate
reactivity of the p85 antibodies on anlagen in whole cells at 45 h
of development as being significantly greater than the background
fluorescence by using this procedure; thus, we examined a time course
of samples to determine whether p85 is present in any other nuclei and
to determine whether the same time course of appearance is evident as
that observed by Western blotting. As seen in Figure 8, p85 is not
detectable above this background fluorescence in vegetative cell nuclei.
We performed immunofluorescence with antibodies to p85 on mated cells
at 2, 4, 6, 10, 12, 15, 18 and 20 h postmixing. Anti-p85 reactivity is not present in any nuclei before 15 h and is faintly apparent at 15 h, which is the earliest time point where we have seen a detectable anlagen (Figure 8). After 18 h, the staining with anti-p85 becomes much more visible and clearly differs from the
background staining seen with secondary antibody used alone (see 20-h
example compared with the 
p85 control and vegetative or 15-h
samples; Figure 8). In cells undergoing macronuclear development, the
old macronuclei and micronuclei do not react with antibodies to p85,
whereas developing macronuclei show increasing staining between 18 and
24 h with intense staining at various time points between 45 and
65 h. At 70-80 h, the staining of the anlagen decreased and we
noticed vesicle-like structures external to the anlagen that reacted
with both anti-p85 (70 h; Figure 8) and anti-topoisomerase II (our
unpublished data) and which stained faintly with DAPI (70 h;
Figure 8). These structures are similar in size to food vacuoles seen
in vegetative, fed cells and we suspect that they are involved in
degrading the eliminated chromatin. After 70-80 h, staining is no
longer seen.
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
We have identified p85 as a developmental stage and
anlagen-specific protein that colocalizes and coextracts with a subset of the eliminated sequences in E. crassus. Most notably, the
highly abundant Tec elements show 100% colocalization with 70% of the p85 throughout macronuclear development while they are being
eliminated. In contrast, a macronuclear sequence hybridization probe
that we estimate would detect a majority of the macronuclear genomic sequences (Jahn, 1999
) shows very little colocalization with p85. In
addition to the localization data, the solubilization properties of the
Tec element chromatin micrococcal nuclease digestion products parallel
the p85 and topoisomerase II extraction properties; both the Tec
element micrococcal nuclease digestion products and these two proteins
become highly enriched relative to other sequences and proteins in salt
extracted nuclei. In contrast, macronuclear-destined sequences (i.e.,
anlagen sequences hybridizing to macronuclear sequence probes) are
readily digested to subnucleosomal sizes after salt extraction and are
readily solubilized as nuclesome multimers and monomers at low salt
concentrations. Because of the unusual solubility properties of the Tec
element chromatin and the p85 protein, it is has not been possible to
demonstrate their association by other techniques such as chromatin immunoprecipitation.
p85 is the first protein identified that shows any association with
eliminated sequences in the E. crassus anlagen. The
localization of the p85 protein exclusively to the anlagen differs from
the Tetrahymena Pdd proteins in that the Pdd proteins are
found in both the anlagen and the degrading old macronucleus (Madireddi et al., 1996
; Smothers et al., 1997b
; Nikiforov
et al., 2000
). There are many features of DNA elimination in
Euplotes that differ from elimination in
Tetrahymena (reviewed by Coyne et al., 1996
), and
the degree to which these processes involve conserved functions is
debatable. At present, there seems to be a correlation between the
formation of "heterochromatic," higher order, condensed chromatin structures and the elimination of DNA. The condensed structure of the
eliminated DNA in Tetrahymena has been defined cytologically (Madireddi et al., 1994
, 1996
; Smothers et al.,
1997a
), whereas the condensed structure of the Tec elements is inferred
from their inaccessibility to nucleases (Jahn, 1999
) and their
extraction properties (this article).
The salt extraction properties of p85, which parallel the extraction
properties of the unusual Tec element chromatin structure, and its high
lysine and glutamic/aspartic acid contents suggest that it could be
involved in the unusual chromatin structure of the Tec elements in the
anlagen. The MNase digestion properties of the Tec element chromatin
(Jahn, 1999
) indicate that the nucleosomal structure is modified such
that the linker region between nucleosomes is completely inaccessible
to digestion and only sites within the nucleosomal core become
accessible. Because no histone H1 is present in the anlagen (Ray
et al., 1999
; Jahn, unpublished observations), the high
lysine content of p85 may result in binding of p85 in the linker
region. In addition, the numerous patches of acidic vs. basic residues
occurring throughout p85 make it possible that p85 interacts with both
histones and DNA. Thus, it may span between and interact along
nucleosomes, which could result in complete occlusion of the linker
region. The potential coiled-coil structure within p85 indicates that
it has a protein interaction domain; this may be important in
associations with other proteins or in the self-association of p85 and
could explain the unusual insolubility of the p85 containing chromatin.
Further experiments to reconstitute chromatin with p85 and binding
studies of p85 with nucleosomes and their multimers should give us a
better idea of how p85 may function with respect to chromatin structure.
Our means of extracting and selectively enriching the Tec element
chromatin and the p85 and topoisomerase II proteins suggests that we
are looking at a chromosome scaffold structure. The best-studied example of a chromosome scaffold structure is the residual scaffold left from mammalian metaphase chromosomes after extractions similar to
what we used herein. Topoisomerase II, lamins, and "XCAP" proteins, now known to be part of the condensin complex, are the major proteins identified in metaphase scaffold preparations (Berrios et
al., 1985
; Earnshaw et al., 1985
). Thus, our finding of
topoisomerase II as one of the major proteins in the E. crassus anlagen "scaffold/matrix" fraction after extraction
with high salt or LIS was expected. In mammalian metaphase chromosomes,
topoisomerase II colocalizes with AT-rich DNA sequences referred to as
the "AT queue," which are detected by fluorescent dyes that
intercalate with AT-rich DNA (Saitoh and Laemmli, 1994
). It is thought
that both histone H1 and topoisomerase II preferentially interact with
AT-rich MARs/SARs (matrix attachment regions or scaffold attachment
regions) to facilitate chromosome condensation (Hart and Laemmli, 1998
)
and that topoisomerase II, as a chromosome scaffold protein, may play a
major role in the looped organization of chromatin fibers. This is
interesting with respect to our findings of topoisomerase II enrichment
in association with the Tec elements (and p85) because it has long been
recognized that the IES sequences in ciliates, or at least their
boundaries, are AT rich. For instance, the Tec element inverted repeat
is 96-98% AT in the first 68 base pairs (Jaraczewski and Jahn, 1993
).
Thus, these sequences may be equivalent to the AT-rich MARs/SARs
defined in other systems and may be preferential sites of topoisomerase
II interaction. In Drosophila, a similar sequence preference
for a repetitive DNA is apparent. Localization studies with injected
fluorescently tagged topoisomerase II and the mapping of in vivo
topoisomerase II cleavage sites indicate that topoisomerase II is
preferentially associated with the AT-rich satellite III (359-base pair
repeat) DNA (Kas and Laemmli, 1992
; Marshall et al., 1997
).
The functional significance of this association is presently unknown.
The presence of p85 and topoisomerase II in discrete chromosomal
subregions associated with the Tec elements and other eliminated sequences suggests that there may be a role for topoisomerase II in
DNA-processing events. Given the known properties of topoisomerase II
(Nitiss, 1998
), it is likely to be involved in decantenation of DNA
during the polytene replications. In mitotic cells, topoisomerase II is
required for sister chromatid separation postreplication and loss of
topoisomerase II function can result in a late S-phase block (DiNardo
et al., 1984
; Holm et al., 1985
). We are
intrigued by the fact that Tec element excision is a post replication
or late replication event in that it occurs at the end of each of the
two polytene S phases, and we wonder whether topoisomerase II could be
directly involved in the excision. If the polytene chromatin strands in
the E. crassus anlagen remain entangled with each other
postreplication and undergo a controlled separation, the inverted
repeat structure of the Tec elements could allow these entanglements to
become trapped via recombination junctions at the ends of the elements,
with the elements held as cantenated loops. Resolution of such a
structure, potentially by topoisomerase II, might result in excision of
the Tec element loops. Alternatively, topoisomerase II may control the
chromatin condensation state of eliminated vs. retained DNA. As an
alternative or adjunct to direct binding of p85 to nucleosomes to
generate a higher order structure, the unusual Tec element MNase
digestion properties could reflect a particular coiling state of the
chromatin that is maintained by p85 and topoisomerase II. The Tec
elements may be a discrete loop controlled by topoisomerase II, and the
combination of p85 with topoisomerase II anchoring may create a higher
order structure with altered MNase digestion properties.
| |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
This work was supported by National Science Foundation grant MCB-0078182 and by Northwestern University and Northwestern University Medical School. S.S. was supported by a fellowship from the Robert H. Lurie Comprehensive Cancer Center.
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
* Corresponding author. E-mail address: c-jahn{at}northwestern.edu.
Article published online ahead of print. Mol. Biol. Cell 10.1091/mbc.E02-08-0542. Article and publication date are at www.molbiolcell.org/cgi/doi/10.1091/mbc.E02-08-0542.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|