|
|
|
|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Vol. 14, Issue 4, 1677-1690, April 2003
Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, Missouri 63110
Submitted November 12, 2002; Accepted December 26, 2002| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Myosin heavy chain (MHC) is a large, multidomain protein important for both cellular structure and contraction. To examine the functional role of two C-terminal domains, the end of the coiled-coil rod and the nonhelical tailpiece, we have generated constructs in which residues within these domains are removed or mutated, and examined their behavior in Caenorhabditis elegans striated muscle. Genetic tests demonstrate that MHC lacking only tailpiece residues is competent to support the timely onset of embryonic contractions, and therefore viability, in animals lacking full-length MHC. Antibody staining experiments show that this truncated molecule localizes as wild type in early stages of development, but may be defective in processes important for thick filament organization later in embryogenesis. Ultrastructural analysis reveals thick filaments of normal morphology in disorganized arrangement, as well as occasional abnormal assemblages. In contrast, molecules in which the four terminal residues of the coiled coil are absent or mutated fail to rescue animals lacking endogenous MHC. Loss of these four residues is associated with delayed protein localization and delayed contractile function during early embryogenesis. Our results suggest that these two MHC domains, the rod and the tailpiece, are required for distinct steps during muscle development.
| |
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The mechanism by which the proteins of the striated muscle thick
filament are organized into the highly ordered contractile apparatus is
an important unresolved question in the biology of the muscle cell. A
key aspect of the process, how a cell specifies where and when to build
a thick filament, is poorly understood. Control of filament placement
presumably involves regulation of the distribution and activity of at
least some of the individual protein components found within the thick
filament. In invertebrates, the major structural proteins of the thick
filament are myosin heavy chain (MHC) and paramyosin, which is
homologous to the C-terminal two-thirds of the MHC coiled-coil domain
or "rod" (Kagawa et al., 1989
). In this article, we
investigate the role of two MHC domains, the C-terminal rod and the
tailpiece, in MHC localization and function in Caenorhabditis
elegans striated muscle.
The rod has long been recognized as the filament-forming domain of the
MHC molecule (for review, see Squire, 1981
). Interaction of rod
residues is thought to play a large part in driving filament assembly
and specifying filament structure in striated muscle. A potential
mechanism for temporal and spatial control of filament assembly is
regulation of the accessibility or activity of the rod residues
required for filament initiation. In smooth muscle, such regulation has
been proposed to occur through the action of a C-terminal tailpiece
domain: a small, nonhelical region that contains phosphorylation sites.
Phosphorylation of the tailpiece promotes the formation of a folded,
assembly-incompetent confomer (Castellani and Cohen, 1987
). In addition
to regulation of assembly competence, the smooth muscle MHC tailpiece
may play a structural role, influencing molecular packing within the
filament (Rovner et al., 2002
).
Tailpiece sequences are often associated with nonmuscle myosins that
form dynamic structures. Studies using primarily biochemical techniques
suggest that the tailpiece may have different functions in nonmuscle
myosins and may even serve more than one role in a given molecule. Like
smooth muscle myosin, the tailpiece domain of nonmuscle myosins has
been implicated in filament assembly and structure. For example, in
human nonmuscle myosin II, tailpiece phosphorylation acts to decrease
assembly of rod fragments in vitro (Murakami et al., 1998
).
In Acanthamoeba, the tailpiece has been proposed to mediate
the initial association of assembling myosin II molecules (Sinard
et al., 1989
), thereby driving assembly and specifying
minifilament structure. There are contradictory data as to whether
phosphorylation regulates assembly of Acanthamoeba myosin
into filaments (Collins et al., 1982
; Sinard and Pollard, 1989
). Phosphorylation of the tailpiece has also been proposed as a
mechanism for regulating activity of the MHC motor domain once
filaments are formed (Sathyamoorthy et al., 1990
).
A tailpiece domain is present in the MHC and paramyosin proteins of
C. elegans body-wall muscle. Interestingly, these homologous sequences are at opposite ends of the two molecules: the MHC tailpiece is at the extreme C terminus, whereas the paramyosin "tailpiece" is
at the extreme N terminus. The paramyosin tailpiece is phosphorylated at multiple sites by an endogenous kinase, and a phosphorylation motif
(S_S_A) was identified (Schriefer and Waterston, 1989
). Several copies
of this motif are found in the tailpiece domain of the body-wall MHC
isoforms. MHC is also phosphorylated (Dey et al., 1992
), but
the location of the phosphorylated residues is unknown.
The C. elegans body-wall muscle cells provide a system with
well-defined genetics and morphology in which to test the function of
MHC domains (for reviews, see Waterston, 1988
; Moerman and Fire, 1997
).
Two isoforms of MHC (MHC A and MHC B) assemble upon a core composed of
paramyosin and associated proteins (Deitiker and Epstein, 1993
). MHC A,
encoded by the myo-3 gene, is present in the central
1.8-µm region of the 10-µm-long thick filament. This region
includes the part of the bipolar filament in which myosin molecules
associate in an antiparallel (tail-to-tail) manner (Miller et
al., 1983
). Mutations in the myo-3 locus that eliminate MHC A cause the complete lack of normal thick filaments, resulting in
paralysis and death (Waterston, 1989
). Thus, MHC A is required for an
essential aspect of filament formation. The major isoform, MHC B, is
encoded by unc-54 (Epstein et al., 1974
) and is
present in the filament arms, where parallel addition occurs. Mutations that eliminate MHC B reduce the number of thick filaments present. The
resulting filaments can be of normal length, and they contain MHC A
along their entire length (Epstein et al., 1986
). Increasing the expression of the minor isoform, MHC A, can restore an
unc-54 (MHC B-deficient) animal to near wild type (Fire and
Waterston, 1989
). Thus, in addition to being required to initiate the
filament center, MHC A can add in parallel to form the filament arms.
In this article, we use the advanced molecular genetics of C. elegans to examine the function of the nonhelical tailpiece and the C-terminal rod. Performing these experiments in vivo allows the assessment of MHC function in the context of the muscle cell, with its full complement of potential interacting proteins, including endogenous kinases. Our results demonstrate that very small perturbations of the coiled coil have dramatic effects on early myosin localization and the onset of contractile function. In contrast, removal of tailpiece residues has no discernible effect on these early events of protein localization and filament formation. Instead, defects observed during later stages of embryogenesis and in adults suggest that the tailpiece domain may be required to establish or maintain proper filament position within the sarcomere. These observations suggest that the functions of the rod and the tailpiece are distinct, and are required at different times during development in C. elegans striated muscle.
| |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Transgenic Nematode Strains
MHC A construct, pUCAA plasmid: RW3680 unc-54(e190); stEx79. RW3825 unc-54(e190); myo-3(st386); stEx79. RW3838 myo-3(st386); stEx79. RW3681 unc-54(e190); stEx80. RW3685 myo-3(st386); stEx80. RW3826 unc-54(e190); myo-3(st386); stEx80.
30, pRA7: RW3896 unc-54(e190); myo-3(st386); stEx148.
RW3897 unc-54(e190); myo-3(st386); stEx149. RW3873
unc-54(e190); stEx148. RW3874 unc-54(e190);
stEx149. RW3883 myo-3(st386); stEx149. RW3884 myo-3(st386); stEx148. RW3875 unc-54(e190);
stEx150. RW3889 myo-3(st386); stEx150.
BHtag
30, pPP3: RW3885 unc-54(e190); stEx152. RW3905
myo-3(st386); stEx152. RW3906 unc-54(e190);
myo-3(st386); stEx152. RW3907 myo-3(st386); stEx153.
RW3908 unc-54(e190); myo-3(st386); stEx153. RW3886
unc-54(e190); stEx153. RW3909 myo-3(st386);
stEx154. RW3887 unc-54(e190); stEx154.
34, pRA4: RW3829 unc-54(e190); stEx129. RW3867
myo-3(st386); stEx129. RW3868 unc-54(e190);
myo-3(st386)/eDf1; stEx129.
BH
34 previously called chimera 6 (Hoppe and Waterston, 1996
): New
transgenic lines carrying the rol-6::GFP
coinjection marker were generated for these experiments. RW3824
unc-54(e190); stEx111. RW3781 myo-3(st386);
stEx111. RW3820 unc-54(e190); myo-3(st386)/eDf1; stEx111. RW3823 unc-54(e190); stEx112. RW3817
unc-54(e190); myo-3(st386)/eDf1; stEx112. RW3782
myo-3(st386); stEx112. RW3783 myo-3(st386);
stEx113. RW3818 unc-54(e190); stEx113. RW3819
unc-54(e190); myo-3(st386)/eDf1; stEx113. RW3816
unc-54(e190); stEx114. RW3784 myo-3(st386);
stEx114.
BHtag
34, pRA2: RW3828 myo-3(st386); stEx120. RW3830
unc-54(e190); myo-3(st386)/eDf1; stEx120. RW3833
unc-54(e190); stEx120.
Chimera 3: RW3768 unc-54(e190); stEx55. RW3827 unc-54(e190); myo-3(st386); stEx55.
Chimera 4.tag: RW3811 unc-54(e190); stEx118. RW3860 unc-54(e190); myo-3(st386); stEx118
BHtag
KIRA: RW3942 unc-54(e190); stEx200; RW3949
myo-3(st386); stEx200; RW3954 unc-54(e190);
myo-3(st386)/eDf1; stEx200
BHtagPIRA: RW3946 unc-54(e190); stEx203. RW3957 myo-3(st386); stEx203. RW3956 unc-54(e190); myo-3(st386)/eDf1; stEx203. RW3947 unc-54(e190); stEx204. RW3955 myo-3(st386); stEx204. RW3958 unc-54(e190); myo-3(st386)/eDf1; stEx204.
BHtagPIAA: RW3944 unc-54(e190); stEx201. RW3951 myo-3(st386); stEx201. RW3952 unc-54(e190); myo-3(st386)/eDf1; stEx201. RW3945 unc-54(e190); stEx202. RW3950 myo-3(st386); stEx202. RW3953 unc-54(e190); myo-3(st386)/eDf1; stEx202.
DNA Construct
The previously published chimera 6 construct (Hoppe and
Waterston, 1996
) has been renamed BH
34. The premature stop codon resulted from an error introduced during a polymerase chain
reaction step used to generate chimera 4, which contains MHC B
sequences in the tailpiece domain. Therefore, the last amino acid
residue before the stop codon is from MHC B, but the remainder of the rod residues are from MHC A. The other
34 constructs were made by
moving the sequences encoding the premature stop codon from BH
34 to
the myo-3 gene or a hemagglutinin (HA)-tagged chimeric construct, by using standard cloning techniques and previously described genomic cassettes (Hoppe and Waterston, 1996
). The addition of the HA epitope tag to the MHC B head has been described previously (Hoppe and Waterston, 2000
). To make the
30 constructs, oligo ACAAGATTCGTGCATaAtaaTCCATGGaTCCACCAGATGGTTT and its complement were
used with the Stratagene QuikChange kit to replace S1940 and A1941
codons with consecutive ochre codons in the 1.4-kb
SphI-KpnI subclone encoding the
myo-3 C terminus. The same protocol was used with the
following oligonucleotides to generate the constructs containing
mutations within the C-terminal rod:
KIRA,
CTGTCAAAGATGCGTAACTCAGCTTCgATGGCTCCACCA; PIRA,
TCAAAGATGCGTAACccaATTCGTGCcTCAGCTTCCATGGC; and PIAA,
TCAAAGATGCGTAACccaATTgccGCcTCAGCTTCCATGGC. Oligonucleotide bases in
lowercase do not match wild-type sequence and include silent mutations
to eliminate hairpins. Fragments generated by polymerase chain reaction
were verified by DNA sequencing. Complete constructs encoding truncated
MHC A or chimeric proteins were made by moving the mutant subclone as
described for
34.
Injections
Transformed lines were generated as described previously (Mello
et al., 1991
). A 30:10:1 ratio of Bluescript/pPHgfp-1/myosin (at 200 ng/µl in 10 mM Tris, 1 mM EDTA, pH 8) was used to produce extrachromosomal arrays with low myosin copy number. The coinjection marker expresses green fluorescent protein (GFP) in the hypodermis under the control of the rol-6 promoter (Hoppe and
Waterston, 2000
). Arrays were selected for robust expression by
injection into unc-54(e190) animals and screening for
restoration of motility. Arrays with lower expression levels were
identified by poor rescue of unc-54(0), or by injection into
myo-3(st386)/eDf1 and screening rescued myo-3
homozygotes for wild-type muscle structure by using polarized light
microscopy. To test whether a construct could support viability when it
is the only myosin heavy chain expressed, arrays with robust expression
were first crossed into an unc-54(e190); myo-3(st386)/eDf1;
stExN background. Animals were then picked singly to identify any
viable double mutant animals, which do not segregate the recessive
larval lethal phenotype associated with the eDf1 balancer chromosome.
Brood Analysis
Transgenic unc-54(e190); myo-3(st386)/eDf1; stExN hermaphrodites were picked singly to freshly seeded plates and allowed to lay for 1 d. After an additional day, the transgenic progeny (identified using a fluorescent dissecting microscope) were sorted and counted. Arrested animals that showed no GFP signal were picked onto microscope slides and scored again using a compound fluorescent microscope. Viable transgenic animals were picked singly to plates, and their progeny examined to determine parental genotype.
Antibody Staining
Embryos were fixed with paraformaldehyde and methanol and
stained using the methods of Hresko et al. (1994)
. Adults
were fragmented, fixed with methanol, and stained as described
previously (Francis and Waterston, 1985
). Monoclonal antibodies 5-6,
5-8, and 5-14 were gifts of Henry Epstein and Irving Ortiz (Baylor
College of Medicine, Houston, TX). The HA epitope was detected
using the rat monoclonal anti-HA high affinity (Roche
Diagnostics, Indianapolis, IN).
Time-Lapse Recording
Gravid adult hermaphrodites were cut in half with a razor blade in M9 buffer. The embryos in a small amount of buffer were transferred to a 2% agarose pad on a microscope slide and covered and gently flattened with a Vaseline-lined coverslip. The embryos were videotaped overnight (~16 h) using Nomarski optics and then photographed on a fluorescence microscope to record the presence of GFP expression in any arrested individuals. The progression of development up until the twofold stage (designated as 450 min in Figure 3) was scored by monitoring morphology rather than actual time elapsed. Subsequent to the twofold stage, elapsed time was used to determine the point at which movement began. Because temperature was not strictly controlled, all times are approximate. The strains carrying genomic mutations were RW3667 myo-3(st386)/eDf1, CB190 unc-54(e190), and RW3858 unc-54(e190); myo-3(st386)/eDf1.
Electron Microscopy
Samples were prepared as in Waterston et al. (1977)
:
adult worms were fixed with 3% glutaraldehyde, 0.1 M sodium phosphate (pH 7.4) at 0°C for 4 h., cut in half, and fixed overnight in the same solution. After postfixation in 1% osmium tetroxide in 0.1 M
sodium phosphate (pH 7.4) for 1 h at 4°C, the samples were embedded in agarose, dehydrated, and embedded as described previously (Hall, 1995
) using a Pelco eponate 12 kit.
| |
RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
To investigate the possible structural or regulatory roles of the C-terminal MHC residues in thick filament formation and function, we generated various mutant constructs containing point mutations or deletions within the tailpiece and/or C-terminal rod residues. Extrachromosomal arrays expressing mutant or chimeric protein were isolated (see MATERIALS AND METHODS) and crossed into various genetic backgrounds to test their ability to function in different aspects of thick filament formation. Filament initiation function was assessed by testing for rescue of the lethal phenotype of myo-3(0) mutations, which eliminate MHC A. Competence in thick filament elongation and contractile function was assessed by the ability to restore motility in unc-54(0) animals, which lack MHC B. Last, constructs were tested in the double mutant background to determine the requirement for C-terminal residues in animals that express no other MHC in their body-wall muscles.
Constructs were made primarily using the myo-3 gene, which
encodes MHC A, the minor isoform that is essential for thick filament initiation, and therefore for viability (see INTRODUCTION). All chimeric constructs, made by combining sequences from MHC A and MHC B,
contain all or most of the MHC A rod and are therefore able to supply
MHC A-specific initiation function in a myo-3(0) mutant
(Hoppe and Waterston, 1996
). Chimeric and HA-tagged constructs were
included to test the function of different MHC domains and to allow
construct-specific antibody staining experiments (see below).
Truncated Constructs Define a Four-Amino-Acid Region of Coiled Coil Required for Viability
The C-termini of the constructs are shown in Figure
1A, and diagrams of the sequence content
of the complete constructs are shown in Figure 1B. The
30 and
BHtag
30 (chimeric) constructs lack all potential phosphorylation
motifs, but based upon paircoil scores (Berger et al., 1995
)
are likely to have an intact rod. These constructs were used to examine
the behavior of MHC lacking only the tailpiece domain. The use of
truncations, rather than point mutations, is likely to produce a
loss-of-function phenotype and requires no assumptions as to the
precise site or timing of potential phosphorylation events. The more
severe truncation, present in all
34 constructs, removes the
tailpiece and four residues within presumptive coiled coil. The
34
constructs were used to determine the effects of disrupting the extreme
C terminus of the coiled-coil domain. The results of the genetic tests
are shown in Figure 1B. All truncated constructs were able to produce lines of rescued myo-3(0) homozygous animals. Similarly, all
constructs rescued the paralysis of unc-54(0) mutants. These
genetic tests demonstrate that truncated proteins lacking up to 34 C-terminal residues have sufficient function to restore viability and
motility in single-mutant animals lacking either MHC A or MHC B.
|
To determine whether functional thick filaments could be formed
containing only truncated myosin, we tested the transgenes for rescue
in the double-mutant background unc-54(0);
myo-3(0). MHC A and chimeric constructs that lack all of the
potential phosphorylation motifs (
30) rescue the double mutant
animals to viability and are thus competent to function as the sole
myosin heavy chain. Some of the rescued lines have good motility and
egg-laying function, but do not seem completely wild type in movement.
The observed slowness may be due to a number of factors, including
inappropriate levels of myosin accumulation or a small impairment in
MHC function. However, these results demonstrate that the nonhelical
tailpiece and its candidate phosphorylation motifs do not play an
essential role in thick filament formation or function.
In contrast, the
34 constructs could not be isolated in the
double-mutant background (Figure 1B). Therefore, the four residues of
predicted coiled coil that are present in
30 but absent in
34 are
essential for some aspect of myosin function. The two full-length
chimeric constructs, chimera 3 and chimera4.tag, which contain the MHC
A rod but have some MHC B sequences, both rescue the double mutant.
Thus, the MHC A head and tailpiece residues do not have
isoform-specific function that is required for viability. Furthermore,
the presence of the HA tag does not affect rescuing activity.
The Four-Amino-Acid Region KIRA Contains Highly Conserved Charged Residues
Genetic tests of the truncated constructs
30 and
34 define
an essential region of the MHC A C-terminal coiled coil containing the
residues KIRA. To examine the importance of these residues in striated
muscle of other species, we compared the C-termini of striated muscle
myosins from a variety of organisms (Figure 2). The two charged residues within the
four-residue region (lysine and arginine) are highly conserved,
suggesting an important role for this part of the coiled coil in all
striated muscle. In contrast, the length of the potential tailpiece
domain, as well as the placement of possible phosphorylatable residues
(serines and threonines) within this domain, varies among species.
Therefore, the role of the tailpiece, or at least the mechanism of
domain action, does not seem to be broadly conserved. Invertebrate
myosins tend to have a longer tailpiece that contains a number of
phosphorylatable residues. Interestingly, all vertebrate
striated-muscle myosins examined contain a phosphorylatable residue
within the four-amino-acid region of coiled coil defined by our
truncated constructs.
|
The Four-Amino-Acid Region Is Essential for Function of Full-Length MHC
Our experiments with truncated constructs indicate that removal of
the tailpiece and four residues of coiled coil disrupts an essential
myosin function, whereas removal of the tailpiece alone does not. To
determine whether the four coiled-coil residues, KIRA, are essential
for MHC function in molecules that contain an intact tailpiece domain,
we generated three constructs in which either one or both conserved
basic residues (K, R) were altered or deleted (Figure 1A). The
BHtag
KIRA construct contains an in-frame deletion that removes the
four-residue region. The resulting protein is thus slightly shorter and
has a small shift in the position of the tailpiece relative to the
remainder of the molecule. The other two constructs contain point
mutations that alter the properties of the KIRA region but leave the
overall length of the molecule intact. The BHtagPIRA construct changes
K1936 to P, eliminating a positive charge and prematurely disrupting
the coiled coil. The BHtagPIAA construct, containing mutations K1936P
and R1938A, eliminates two positive charges and prematurely disrupts
coiled coil.
Genetic tests revealed that the two constructs in which both basic residues were altered or deleted failed to rescue double mutant animals (Figure 1B). Thus, mutations within the four residues of C-terminal coiled coil result in the disruption of an essential myosin function despite the presence of an intact tailpiece. The inability of the tailpiece domain to compensate for disruption of the four-residue region of coiled coil suggests that the two domains play distinct roles in thick filament formation or function.
The BHtagPIRA construct, in which the K1936P change prematurely
disrupts coiled coil and removes one of the conserved basic residues,
exhibits partial function in vivo. Most double mutant animals
expressing only BHtagPIRA die (Table 1).
However, some animals of this genotype survive and reproduce, although
most of their transgenic progeny die. These data suggest that the
mutational changes in BHtagPIRA reduce protein function to a level near
the threshold of activity required for survival. Again, the tailpiece domain in this full-length construct cannot compensate for a point mutation within the C-terminal rod.
|
The Four-Amino-Acid Region Is Required for MHC Function in Early Muscle Development
To define the functional deficit of the constructs that do not
support viability, we analyzed the broods from heterozygous animals to
determine the terminal phenotype of the transgenic double mutant
animals (see MATERIALS AND METHODS). Like the myo-3 mutants
that lack MHC A, animals expressing only
34 constructs arrest
elongation at the twofold stage of embryogenesis and die as misshapen
L1 larvae (Table 1). These results suggest that small deletions in the
rod cause a severe deficit in early myosin function. Double mutant
animals expressing constructs with mutations within the KIRA sequence
that disrupt both conserved basic residues show a similar terminal
phenotype (Table 1). However, some of the double mutant animals
expressing these constructs arrest between the two- and threefold
stages. The ability of these constructs to support elongation beyond
the twofold stage suggests that the presence of the tailpiece residues
can to a small degree ameliorate the elongation defect associated with
the
34 construct.
Disruption of the Four-Residue Region Delays the Onset of Movement in Embryos
The Pat phenotype (paralyzed, arrested elongation at the twofold
stage) observed in animals expressing only
34 has been associated with mutations that have a range of defects in early movement (Williams
and Waterston, 1994
). To examine the movement of animals expressing
only
34 myosin, we used time-lapse videomicroscopy to view
developing embryos from heterozygous hermaphrodites carrying arrays
selected for robust expression (see MATERIALS AND METHODS). Embryos
expressing any of the
34 constructs alone showed delayed initiation
of movement (Figure 3). Whereas wild-type
animals twitch at the 1.5-fold stage and begin coordinated
rolling at the twofold stage (Williams and Waterston, 1994
), all
transgenic double mutant embryos exhibited no movement during these
early stages and arrested elongation at the twofold stage.
|
Double mutant embryos expressing
34 constructs did eventually move.
In most
34 transgenic lines, the late movements began as weak,
isolated twitches that slowly increased in frequency and strength, such
that most animals showed late (660-900 min), weak movement of the head
and tail, but did not roll. The BH
34 array stEx120
produced the strongest movement in double mutant animals. In this line,
some individuals eventually twitched vigorously and showed clear
attempts to roll. In all cases, however, the late movement did not lead
to further elongation, and therefore did not change the terminal arrest
phenotype (Figure 4). Similar analysis of
myo-3(0) mutants revealed that the movement phenotype of
embryos expressing only MHC B is similar to that of embryos expressing
34 (Figure 3). Double mutant animals that express no body-wall
myosin show no movement at any time, and have the Pat phenotype.
|
Animals expressing only MHC with an intact tailpiece and mutations
within the four-residue region (
KIRA, PIRA, PIAA) exhibited similar
defects in motility. The observed delay in the onset of twitching was
not as great in animals expressing these constructs compared with those
expressing only
34. However, the observed movement was qualitatively
similar: motility slowly progressed from twitches to movements of the
head and tail, but no rolling occurred.
In contrast, animals expressing only
30, which lacks the tailpiece,
have a movement phenotype similar to control lines expressing full-length MHC. Some variability in the onset of twitching is apparent
in any line expressing MHC from extrachromosomal arrays compared with
the lines expressing MHC from genomic loci (Figure 3). The second
30
transgene (stEx149), as well as the chimera4.tag array,
showed a slightly wider range in the time at which movement was first
detected. In both these lines, a few animals that did not twitch until
reaching the twofold stage went on to move well and elongate properly.
Therefore, these viable animals initiated movement later than some
nonviable individuals that expressed only MHC with mutations within the
KIRA residues. Thus, movement before the twofold stage is apparently
not essential for proper morphogenesis or viability. In addition, these
data indicate that lethality is not caused by a simple delay in the
onset of contractions. Instead, developmental arrest is associated with
defects in both the onset of twitching and the subsequent progression
to coordinated movement.
To assess the possible effects of gene dosage on early movement, we videotaped embryos where myosin levels were altered by genomic mutation or by transgene expression (Figure 3). Animals heterozygous for myo-3(0), which have reduced MHC A, as well as unc-54(0) homozygotes, which express no MHC B, showed little or no delay in the onset of movement compared with wild type. Double mutant animals that express full-length MHC A from transgenic arrays showed a small variation in onset of movement. Because the onset of twitching and progression to coordinated movement are not dramatically changed by variations in the level of full-length myosin, the delayed movement and subsequent lethality associated with constructs that have mutations in the C-terminal rod cannot be explained by a simple deficit in myosin expression.
Defects in Early Localization of
34 Protein
To elucidate the defect in
34 that leads to poor movement and
lethality, we used immunocytochemistry to examine the localization of
truncated proteins in developing embryos. Antibody staining of
homozygous myo-3 lines rescued by
34 revealed delayed
localization of the truncated protein into discrete bands. At the
1.5-fold stage, when movement normally begins, the
34 protein
did not exhibit the pattern of strong bands evident in wild type and in controls (Figure 5). Instead, the protein
localized weakly to bands, with much stain remaining diffuse in the
cytoplasm. Animals expressing reduced or increased levels of
full-length myosin do not show this phenotype (Figure 5). Thus, in the
absence of full-length MHC A, the truncated myosin appears to assemble
more slowly. However, these rescued animals, which contain endogenous
MHC B, elongate normally and survive.
|
To control for the possibility that the apparent delay in localization
of the truncated protein was a result of errors in staging or an
imbalance in myosin expression, we examined the localization of the
truncated protein in animals expressing endogenous MHC A but no MHC B. In this background, we could directly compare the localization of
full-length MHC A and truncated MHC in the same muscle cells (Figure
6). BHtag
30 protein colocalizes with endogenous MHC A at all stages, and its early localization appears wild
type. In contrast, BHtag
34 myosin shows a delay in localization compared with MHC A during early stages of embryogenesis, similar to
the delay seen with the
34 construct in the myo-3 mutant
(Figure 5). Thus, the presence of full-length MHC A protein does not
discernibly improve the movement of
34 protein into A-bands.
Conversely, we did not detect any dominant-negative effect of the
truncated protein disrupting the assembly of wild-type MHC A. These
data argue that an intact rod is required at the level of the
individual molecule for proper protein localization in early stages of
muscle assembly. However, the tailpiece does not play a detectable role in early protein localization.
|
To determine the behavior of
34 protein in the double mutant
background, where absence of the tailpiece and four rod residues results in lethality and a long delay in the onset of contractile function, we examined the localization of BHtag
34 protein in embryos
by using isoform-specific antibodies (Figure
7). The staining pattern observed is very
similar to that seen in the single mutants. Again, truncated protein
showed a delay in localization into discrete bands compared with
30
constructs and a full-length control. The localization of BHtag
34
protein in the double mutants improves over time, even following the
failure in elongation, such that the normal number of stained bands
across the quadrant is apparent in some regions of older arrested
animals. These results suggest that the C-terminal rod residues absent
in
34 are required for timely localization but that sequences within
the remainder of the myosin molecule also contribute to protein
localization, although their action is not sufficient to support
viability.
|
Animals expressing only MHC that contains mutations in the four-residue
region of the rod but has an intact tailpiece domain have a terminal
phenotype similar to those expressing only
34 (Table 1), but have
less severe defects in early movement (Figure 3). In antibody-staining
experiments we did not find a convincing delay in the localization of
these proteins into bands compared with endogenous MHC A within the
same cell (our unpublished data). Therefore, unlike the
34
proteins, the functional deficit associated with mutations that alter
only residues within the four-residue-region of the C-terminal rod
cannot be consistently detected at the level of the light microscope.
Nonetheless, these proteins are unable to support the timely initiation
and progression of motility required for proper development.
Defective Localization of
30 Protein in Later Stages of
Embryogenesis
Although
30 protein shows no apparent delay in
localization during early stages of embryogenesis (Figures 5 and 6),
all lines expressing
30 showed a variably penetrant defect in
localization in later stages. In these lines, some embryos at the
twofold stage or later contained regions where myosin staining had
broadened such that the banded pattern that was apparent at earlier
stages was no longer visible (Figures 6, F and I, and 7, I and J). The abnormally localized myosin appeared either as an inward extension of
the membrane-associated contractile apparatus, or as a relatively discrete round accumulation. In lines that express both
30 and full-length MHC A, the endogenous protein also appeared in regions of
expanded stain (Figure 6). Thus, molecules lacking only the tailpiece
seem to influence the localization of full-length molecules. These
observations suggest that
30 protein may be defective in a function
required at the level of the filament during later events in sarcomere
formation or maintenance.
Tailpiece Residues Are Not Required for Proper Filament Morphology
Animals expressing only
30, which lacks the tailpiece, show no
delay in early myosin localization or the onset of muscle contraction.
These observations suggest that the tailpiece does not play an
important role in the assembly of myosin into filaments. To test this
hypothesis further, we examined the ability of
30 protein to show
the MHC A-specific localization to the central portion of the
myosin-containing A-bands of the contractile apparatus. To obtain a
level of total myosin expression close to that of wild type, a
30 array selected for poor rescue of unc-54 (which lacks the major myosin, MHC B) was crossed into the myo-3
background, which lacks MHC A but expresses wild-type levels of
endogenous MHC B. In these animals the isoform-specific staining
pattern, as well as overall organization of the contractile apparatus, appeared wild-type (Figure 8). These data
argue that the MHC A tailpiece sequences are not required for proper
localization of the MHC A isoform within the filament, or for proper
placement of filaments within the sarcomere.
|
To determine whether loss of tailpiece residues affects filament
morphology, we examined cross sections of adult animals by transmission
electron microscopy (TEM). Most filaments in animals expressing only
30 seemed normal in diameter and orientation, but were poorly
organized (Figure 9, C and D). Defects in
organization varied, even between muscle cells within the same animal.
Common abnormalities included large clusters of filaments that had no apparent division into individual sarcomeres, and groups of filaments displaced interiorly from the membrane. Occasionally abnormal assemblages of filaments were seen, but the majority of filaments appeared normal in cross section. These observations suggest that the
tailpiece residues are not required for proper filament structure but
may be required at the level of the filament for establishment or
maintenance of sarcomere structure.
|
We were unable to do a similar TEM analysis of the morphology of
filaments containing only
34 because these animals arrest during
embryogenesis. However, we did examine muscle in which BH
34 replaced
the essential isoform, MHC A. In these animals, thick filament
morphology appeared wild type, and only relatively minor defects in
filament organization were apparent (Figure 9B). Therefore, the delayed
localization of
34 constructs does not have dramatic effects on
final filament or sarcomere structure in animals that also express
full-length MHC B.
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
An Intact Rod Is Required for Proper Assembly
Our experiments using C-terminally truncated myosin constructs
have defined a four amino-acid region at the C terminus of the MHC A
rod that is essential for viability (Figure 1). The observation that a
small deletion within the coiled coil causes a marked disruption of
early myosin function suggests that these residues are critical for
early events in filament formation (Figure 3 and Table 1). The abnormal
persistence of diffuse
34 protein (which lacks the tailpiece and
four residues of coiled coil) during early muscle development suggests
that loss of these rod residues delays proper localization and assembly
into filamentous structures (Figures 5-7). The presence of
34 MHC
did not disrupt the localization pattern of endogenous MHC within the
same muscle cell. Therefore, loss of these rod residues seems to delay
the organization of individual molecules but does not lead to
dominant-negative effects, such as the initiation of ectopic
structures, that incorporate full-length MHC.
Although the four terminal residues of the coiled coil are essential
for viability, removal of these residues clearly results in a molecule
that has only partial loss of function. The
34 constructs, which
lack these residues, are able to rescue mutants that lack either single
MHC isoform. Animals in which
34 replaces MHC A, the essential
isoform, can have near-normal muscle cell organization and contain
thick filaments of normal morphology (Figure 9). Therefore, in the
presence of full-length MHC B, the four residues of MHC A coiled coil
are not required for proper filament initiation or filament structure.
Although animals expressing only
34 did not commence embryonic
movement at the correct time, movement did eventually occur, as did the
late localization of the truncated protein to filamentous structures.
The motility phenotype and antibody staining results are consistent
with the hypothesis that the
34 protein eventually forms functional
filaments. Although we cannot rule out the possibility that filaments
containing only
34 are abnormal, the tools required to examine the
appropriate developing embryos at the ultrastructural level do not
currently exist.
Comparison of the C. elegans MHC A sequence to other
striated muscle myosins in the public databases revealed that two basic amino acids within the four-residue region are conserved in both vertebrate and invertebrate MHCs (Figure 2). Mutant constructs in which
these basic residues are altered or deleted behave genetically like
34 (Figure 1 and Table 1). That is, these proteins have sufficient
activity to rescue single mutant animals but do not support viability
of double mutant animals that lack endogenous MHC. Although the precise
manner in which loss of these charged residues within the rod affects
myosin function is unknown, previous studies have shown that small
perturbations in charge can have profound effects on assembly in vivo
(Gengyo-Ando and Kagawa, 1991
; Nock et al., 2000
).
Therefore, the functional defect may result directly from loss of two
highly conserved charged residues that play a key role in the
intermolecular interactions involved in driving filament assembly or
specifying filament structure.
A number of studies in various systems point to the importance of the
C-terminal rod in myosin assembly. In vertebrate striated muscle
myosin, a 29-residue region of the coiled coil near the C terminus of
the rod, the assembly-competent domain (ACD), has been proposed to be
essential for ordered assembly of rod fragments in vitro and of
truncated myosin expressed in COS cells (Sohn et al., 1997
).
Our studies did not alter or remove any residues within the ACD, so the
role of the ACD in C. elegans has not yet been tested. Sohn
et al. (1997)
tested C-terminally truncated constructs in
which the four-residue region defined in our study was removed and
found no effect on assembly competence in vitro or in cell lines. Their
observations are consistent with our data, which indicate that loss of
the four terminal residues of coiled coil causes a partial loss of
assembly function. Our genetic and antibody staining experiments were
able to detect a delay in the assembly of the
34 protein because of
the lethal consequences of delayed assembly in vivo and our ability to
compare the localization of truncated protein to that of endogenous MHC
A within the same muscle cell at different developmental stages.
MHC A-specific Function
Our current experiments confirm that the essential MHC A-specific
activity is limited to the rod sequences. A chimeric molecule that
contains only the MHC A rod has sufficient activity to rescue double
mutant animals expressing no endogenous MHC (Figure 1). However, the
observation that the
34 construct is able to provide MHC A-specific
function in the single myo-3(0) mutant demonstrates that the
presence of full-length MHC B allows viability when the only MHC A
present has partial function. In a previous study, two regions of the
MHC A rod sufficient for the essential MHC A-specific function were
mapped by testing chimeric myosins in the myo-3(0)
single-mutant background (Hoppe and Waterston, 1996
). Our current
results raise the possibility that the regions defined previously are
important for MHC A isoform-specific function but may not have
sufficient activity to support viability in the double-mutant background. Consistent with this possibility, studies of the MHC A-specific interaction with paramyosin led to the proposal that sequences along the length of the rod contribute to isoform-specific activity (Hoppe and Waterston, 2000
).
The Tailpiece Domain Is Not Required for Filament Formation
In contrast to the effects of small deletions in the coiled
coil, removal of the tailpiece alone does not discernibly alter early
myosin function in animals that do not express full-length MHC in the
body-wall muscle. Early myosin localization (Figures 5-7) and the
onset of contraction (Figure 3) seem normal in animals expressing only
30 myosin, which lacks the tailpiece domain. In addition, tailpiece
sequences are not required for isoform-specific localization within the
thick filament (Figure 8) or for normal filament morphology (Figure 9).
Because alterations within the adjacent rod region produce a dramatic
defect in early myosin function in vivo, we believe it is unlikely that
our failure to detect similar defects in the
30 protein is due to a
lack of sensitivity in our assays. Instead, our data suggest that the two adjacent domains, the rod and the tailpiece, are required for
distinct steps during muscle development in vivo. A very similar conclusion was reached in the in vitro analysis of proteolytically cleaved Acanthamoeba myosin II (Sathyamoorthy et
al., 1990
).
The ability of MHC A lacking the tailpiece (
30) to localize
correctly and support the timely onset of contractile function suggests
that the tailpiece residues do not play an important role in promoting
assembly of the filament per se. Therefore, our data do not support a
model in which tailpiece sequences in C. elegans striated
muscle act to drive filament assembly or specify filament structure, as
has been proposed for the tailpiece in Acanthamoeba myosin
II (Sinard et al., 1989
) and for smooth muscle MHC (Rovner
et al., 2002
). Our results are consistent with the observation that the assembly of Drosophila MHC into thick
filaments of the distinct morphologies found in different skeletal
muscle cell types is not dependent upon the identity of the tailpiece residues (Wells et al., 1996
).
Our failure to detect defects in
30 localization also suggests
that the tailpiece is unlikely to play an important role in regulating
assembly of MHC into filaments. In smooth muscle, phosphorylation of
tailpiece residues has been associated with the formation of a folded,
assembly-incompetent form of the MHC molecule. Similarly, phosphorylation within the tailpiece domain can reduce assembly of
nonmuscle MHCs in vitro (Murakami et al., 1998
). If the
tailpiece played a similar inhibitory role in C. elegans, we
might expect loss of the tailpiece domain to lead to premature assembly
of MHC into ectopic or otherwise aberrant structures. Instead, myosin stain in embryos expressing only
30 appears normal during early stages of muscle development (Figure 7). Furthermore, the
30 MHC A
protein shows the appropriate isoform-specific staining pattern within
the A-band in adult muscle cells (Figure 8). Therefore, our data do not
support a model in which the C. elegans body-wall MHC
tailpiece regulates the assembly competence of the individual molecule.
Possible Roles for the Tailpiece Residues
Our experiments with truncated MHC do not support a
requirement for the tailpiece in early events of thick filament
formation. Furthermore, because animals in which truncated MHC A
(
30) replaces endogenous MHC A have normal isoform-specific
localization and wild-type cellular organization (Figure 8), we can
conclude that the tailpiece need not be present throughout the
filament, nor in the filament center where initiation is thought to
occur, for normal sarcomere patterning and maintenance. Therefore, our
data suggest that any requirement for the tailpiece may be at the level of the individual filament rather than at the level of the single molecule.
Antibody staining experiments reveal that animals expressing
truncated myosin lacking tailpiece residues (
30) exhibit defects in
myosin localization in later embryogenesis (Figures 6 and 7). Therefore, it is possible that the tailpiece is required for the establishment or maintenance of filament position within the
contractile apparatus. Two observations suggest that loss of the
tailpiece may affect maintenance of sarcomere structure, rather than
specification of its pattern. First, initial localization of
30
during embryogenesis appears normal, and the appearance of disordered
myosin stain occurs when the embryo is actively moving. Second,
electron microscopy (Figure 9) reveals that animals expressing only
30 contain filaments that are located internally in the cell, rather
than being attached to the membrane adjacent to the hypodermis. Because
the patterning of the contractile apparatus in C. elegans is
thought to occur at this membrane (Hresko et al., 1994
;
Williams and Waterston, 1994
), the ectopic filaments may have been
displaced from their initial location. In Drosophila, loss
of sarcomere structure upon contraction has been demonstrated in
animals expressing an embryonic MHC isoform in adult flight muscle
(Wells et al., 1996
).
Two possible models for tailpiece function are suggested by the
apparent loss of sarcomere structure after the onset of contractile activity. First, the tailpiece may mediate proper attachment to, or
stabilization of, the M-line, which anchors thick filaments. Second,
the tailpiece domain may be required for appropriate regulation of the
contractile activity of the filament. A similar role has been proposed
for the tailpiece of Acanthamoeba myosin II (Ganguly et al., 1990
). Consistent with this possibility, mutations
in C. elegans twitchin (encoded by unc-22) that
disrupt contractile regulation lead to defects in sarcomere structure
(Moerman et al., 1988
; Benian et al., 1989
).
Although the tailpiece does not play an essential role in early muscle
development, our data suggest that the domain does affect the activity
of myosin molecules during early stages. The early movement and
terminal arrest phenotypes are more severe in animals expressing only
34 (which lacks the tailpiece and four rod residues) than in animals
expressing only constructs that have mutations within the C-terminal
rod and an intact tailpiece domain. The ability of the tailpiece to
improve motility and embryonic elongation suggests that the presence of
the tailpiece domain contributes to early myosin function. There are
three plausible mechanisms by which tailpiece sequences may be acting
during these stages: 1) the domain may directly contribute to early
localization of the molecule, although this role is not essential or
detectable in our studies of
30 protein; 2) the presence of the
tailpiece may stabilize the coiled coil at the C terminus of the rod,
which plays a key role in localization and assembly; and 3) the
tailpiece contributes to some other early function, such as filament
placement or contractile activity. Because our genetic and antibody
staining experiments have proven to be sensitive (discussed above), our data favor the latter two models. However, further studies are required
to elucidate tailpiece function in C. elegans. Because the
organization of the contractile apparatus is not completely wild type
in any strain expressing a single full-length MHC construct (our
unpublished observations), these experiments must involve different
approaches to test the possible role of the tailpiece in filament organization.
| |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
We thank Henry Epstein and Irving Ortiz for providing antibodies. We thank Bob Waterston, Chelly Hresko, and Larry Schriefer for scientific discussions, and Doug Coulter and Daniela Gerhard for critical reading of the manuscript. We thank Tim Schedl and laboratory members for generosity with equipment, time, and ideas. We thank Sandhya Koushika and Mike Nonet for materials and instruction in preparation of worms for electron microscopy, and Marilyn Levy for sectioning, materials, and expertise. We are grateful for the helpful suggestions provided by anonymous reviewers. This work was funded by National Science Foundation grant 9905687. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation.
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
* Corresponding author. E-mail address: phoppe{at}genetics.wustl.edu.
Article published online ahead of print. Mol. Biol. Cell 10.1091/mbc.E02-11-0728. Article and publication date are at www.molbiolcell.org/cgi/doi/10.1091/mbc.E02-11-0728.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|